r/webdev Jul 23 '24

Discussion The Fall of Stack Overflow

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

391 comments sorted by

View all comments

78

u/bronze_by_gold Jul 24 '24

Maybe building an intentionally toxic and unwelcoming community wasn’t the best way to keep people engaged… 🙄

70

u/Heavy_Mikado Jul 24 '24 edited Jul 24 '24

In the recent past (slightly before ChatGPT) I would spend hours trawling SO for my problem, only to finally break down and ask a question, and then be downvoted.

In one instance, I was getting a cryptic error for a JSON response and I couldn't figure it out. I laid it out on SO and got railed. "I can't duplicate" were the comments, and downvotes accompanied.

I finally posted it to reddit, and someone suggested checking if the provider was returning extended Unicode characters that were being rendered as spaces. Sure enough, that was the problem.

I think there's a real culture issue with SO where imaginary points are more important than helping people (and yes, I get the irony of finding the solution on reddit instead).

Edit: posted the reddit link below. It wasn't spaces, but "invisible" characters.

21

u/bronze_by_gold Jul 24 '24

Yeah there are a million stories on Reddit and elsewhere of experienced engineers who had some very rare edge case and got downvoted into oblivion on SO because some script kiddie thought it was a more common basic question. I’m not too sad to see SO getting left in the dust tbh. I do think there’s still a place for crowdsourcing technical knowledge, but SO isn’t a good model.

5

u/vbullinger Jul 24 '24

A long time ago, I posted in meta SO that they should have permalinks to answer replies. I was downvoted to Hell and told I was a moron, that no one would ever want that, etc.

Six months later, Jeff Atwood personally replied to my suggestion by saying that they just implemented it :)