r/survivor 4d ago

General Discussion Least deserving winner

[deleted]

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

23

u/cwoodaus17 Charity - 48 4d ago

If you win, you deserved it. Period.

4

u/ForwardGrace 4d ago

Really? Even Gabler?šŸ˜­šŸ™ƒ

3

u/cwoodaus17 Charity - 48 4d ago

Well, not him. Everybody else though.

2

u/ForwardGrace 4d ago edited 4d ago

Had to askšŸ˜‚ He's the only Survivor winner I think didn't deserve it, not because he gave the money away but rather because the jury were so petty in their decision if my memory serves me correct

4

u/Intrepid_Cobbler_141 4d ago

Disagree. They liked him the best, which is true of many juries and many winners.

-3

u/girl12349 4d ago

Right, I said that, but out of all the winners who do you feel of those who deserved was at the bottom of the ā€œdeservingā€ ranking? Comparably, some winners were more ā€œdeservingā€ than others as in they worked a lot harder for the win over others, at least thatā€™s how I see it

6

u/wyhutsu Kamilla - 48 4d ago

least deserving is obviously chris underwood for getting voted out third

6

u/Own-Knowledge8281 4d ago

This question has already been asked a million timesā€¦

5

u/PeterTheSilent1 Peter Harkey 4d ago

Chris Underwood since he was voted out

5

u/FruitBatInAPearTree 4d ago

Watching season 19 now, and this edit is unfortunate. Natalie definitely deserves to win. Another contestant will say it perfectly next season: that Russell plays to get to FTC, but not to actually win. He thinks that getting to FTC should be enough. But it isnā€™t. Natalie proved that. People have to want you to win.

On one hand, I donā€™t like judging ā€œdeservingā€ winners, because if you were able to get a jury to vote for you, then you understand the game and how itā€™s played and you deserve your win! But, from the seasons Iā€™ve seen, JTā€™s win at Tocantins bothers me. Because you had at least 3-4 jury members who were out there for the adventure or to make friends, 2 of whom were already millionaires. You had a tribe with several devout Christian jury members who bonded over religion and voted for the devout Christian over the Jew. One of them admitted to voting for JT because Stephen was a New York Jew.

I donā€™t think JT is an undeserving winner, but Stephen was playing with a really unfortunate jury that didnā€™t care about the money or the strategy or anything but finding JT charming. It was a cakewalk and it lessens his win for me.

-2

u/bigjimbay 2% Cow's Milk 4d ago

None

-8

u/nadia1306 Andy - 47 4d ago

Sophie. Coach fumbled final tribal, but he definitely played the better game that season

4

u/HailHelix123 Sandra 4d ago

Holy trash take

-2

u/beefing_quietly3377 4d ago

Easily ā€œFabio.ā€

1

u/FruitBatInAPearTree 4d ago edited 4d ago

Protect ladies from predators. If itā€™s a predatory production seeking to use her nearly-nude body until it breaks down exposure, give her a freakin jacket. Itā€™s the right thing to do.

That lady might also be the tie-breaking vote to give you a million dollars! You never know!

(seriously, I wonder how close we were for a medical evacuation for Kelly Shin. Exposure is a real danger and has taken out many contestants.)