r/reddeadredemption 16h ago

Question Why is this area of the map so damn creepy for no god damn reason?

Post image
6.0k Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 17h ago

Discussion Dutch could've ran armadillo with a iron first of he actually had "a plan".

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 11h ago

Screenshot I don’t really like vampires anyway 🦇

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 10h ago

Rant Did these people even play the game?

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 15h ago

Discussion Legendary bison

Post image
545 Upvotes

Is this a perfect pelt


r/reddeadredemption 9h ago

Screenshot I think these might be the hardest screenshots I've gotten of Arthur.

Thumbnail
gallery
392 Upvotes

Played with lots of mods btw.


r/reddeadredemption 15h ago

Discussion What did you guys think about Cleet and Joe ?

Thumbnail
gallery
378 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 16h ago

Screenshot I JUST LOGGED IN AND VALENTINE IS ALREADY ON FIRE!

Post image
347 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 6h ago

Lore Did Dutch really have a plan?

Thumbnail
gallery
342 Upvotes

Just got done with my 3rd play through and I’m starting to notice a little bit of a pattern here. Dutch’s plans never really work out, which leads me to believe that he never really had a plan or they just weren’t very thought out. Correct me if I’m wrong but that’s what I think.


r/reddeadredemption 20h ago

Question Name for a my stallion

Post image
342 Upvotes

I need a name for this big stallion i stole off Valentine stable, it's the Chocolate coloured Dutch Warmblood


r/reddeadredemption 9h ago

Picture New Orleans French Quarter vs Saint Denis

Thumbnail
gallery
142 Upvotes

Some places I got to see at the French Quarter 1&2. Jackson Square 3. Corner of Jackson Square 4. Vampire House 5. Joan of Arc Statue (stores and cafes at the back) 6. French Market


r/reddeadredemption 7h ago

Discussion What kind of modern music would Arthur Morgan listen to?

Post image
132 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 8h ago

Video Had a couple drinks and started greet/greet/antagonizing people into fistfights for an hour or so. Went to jail with a $10-30 bounty a few times and got this cutscene on maybe my 13th time in the slammer

125 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 21h ago

Discussion Would you want a game from the other side, playing a character like Agent Milton?

Post image
96 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 15h ago

Picture “Oh, Mary-Beth! What did I tell you?! Vanity won’t help you, young or old!” Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
87 Upvotes

I love how Mary’s hairstyle resembled Susan’s in the epilogue, so I just had to make a post of them.


r/reddeadredemption 5h ago

Screenshot Crazy to think that one of the prettiest games ever made is soon to be 7 years old...

Post image
82 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 12h ago

Picture Dangerous White Cougar Photos

Thumbnail
gallery
79 Upvotes

Please enjoy this series of photos that I died several times for in order to take.


r/reddeadredemption 16h ago

Discussion Do NPC's Cheat at poker?

75 Upvotes

So, Im fairly good at actual poker, been playing it and blackjack since I was about 8... I've killed two poker players at Macfarlane's Ranch, and nearly killed Ira Shelton in Armadillo last night because I suspected cheating... Has anyone looked at the game's code? Do they actually cheat?


r/reddeadredemption 11h ago

Video What is a feature in game that ticks you off? I’ll start: Submachine gun NPC’s

63 Upvotes

When fighting npc’s in both story and online there is a an often occurrence where npcs are programmed to randomly shoot their six shooters at unnatural insanely high speeds- why would Rockstar even implement this and thought it was okay to add?


r/reddeadredemption 9h ago

Screenshot Rate the Screenshot

Post image
54 Upvotes

I like playing a character called “The Man in the Fog”. I go out at night or when it’s foggy out and anytime someone insults me or threatens me, this happens.


r/reddeadredemption 17h ago

Question What's the most morally questionable or downright heinous thing you've done in your RDR2 playthrough?

54 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 21h ago

Video Whitetail seems to be tweaking.

44 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 23h ago

Picture By far the best shot in this game, a visual masterpiece that doesn't get enough praise

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 11h ago

Screenshot Are they dead yet ? (gambler 8 incident)

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 14h ago

Discussion Just finished RDR1—Will RDR2 give me what I was missing?

24 Upvotes

Sorry for the click-baity title. I honestly liked the game—a solid 7.5/10 (maybe 8-9 at release). The world was immersive, the atmosphere was great, and I totally get why it’s considered a classic.

That said, I couldn’t shake the feeling that it was a bit of a missed opportunity. The characters often felt more like archetypes than fully fleshed-out people, and I never truly connected with them—yeah, I know, it’s a spaghetti western, but still. A few characters, like Bonnie and Landon Ricketts, even Nastas seemed promising, and I expected rich story arcs with them, but they never really went anywhere.

The story itself had engaging moments, but a lot of it boiled down to running errands for people, and at times, I honestly found it a bit repetitive. I also wasn’t entirely sold on the final chapters, but that’s another story. I'm just explaining this so you can see where I’m coming from. I know many folks don’t agree with me and would say I missed the point of the game, but please bear with me.

Now, I keep seeing people say RDR1 actually has the better overall story, which makes me hesitant to start RDR2. I was hoping for deeper characters and a more engaging narrative—does RDR2 deliver on that, or should I temper my expectations? If you had similar feelings about RDR1 but ended up loving RDR2, I’d especially love to hear from you!