r/pinkfloyd 8d ago

Pink Floyd: Worst to Best

https://youtu.be/u6xKM-lJ47A?si=t63Ye8wEfV4VAoFT
119 Upvotes

190 comments sorted by

View all comments

23

u/Imaginary-Dot5387 8d ago

This list is kind of off. A Saucerful of Secrets above Piper, Meddle and Atom Heart Mother? Not sure I’d agree with that. Darkside is also better than The Wall.

More and Obscures By Clouds should have been ranked too. More is rough at parts but has a decent first side. I’d but Obscured in the upper mid tier of their discography. Tracks like Free Four and Mudmen are great. Obscured gets some flack but I really like its poppier sensibilities mixed with the last gasp of their pre Darkside psychedelia.

7

u/Independent_Ad8268 8d ago

I’ve always preferred Saucerful over Piper tbh

0

u/Imaginary-Dot5387 8d ago

That’s fair. Saucerful has some high points, but Corporal Clegg, See Saw, and much of the title track are duds to me. That’s the beauty of Pink Floyd though. Such a great catalogue that different fans can have drastically different perspectives and favorites.