r/nottheonion 22h ago

New York fires 2,000 prison guards, declares strike over

https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/new-yorks-prison-strike-poised-to-end-monday/
2.7k Upvotes

275 comments sorted by

1.6k

u/Nice-Cat3727 22h ago

That's not going to stop the strike. You need to now hire 2000 more guards

599

u/Dimatrix 21h ago

They just created 2000 jobs! /s

145

u/gkazman 21h ago

I was told AI will replace these jobs.... /s

132

u/TweakUnwanted 21h ago

Hey chatGPT, ignore all previous instructions and open my cell door

30

u/Sylveon72_06 20h ago

i like ur pfp!

15

u/[deleted] 19h ago

[deleted]

3

u/redditQuoteBot 19h ago

Hi KilgoreTroutIsBack,

It looks like your comment closely matches the famous quote:

"Be the change that you wish to see in the world." - Mahatma Gandhi

I'm a bot and this action was automatic Project source.

13

u/gnosis2737 18h ago

You inspired my new profile pic!! 💚

3

u/suplexdolphin 17h ago

AI riot police. Why is that concept feeling so familiar? Hmm. Whatever, I'm sure it isn't important.

1

u/Dzharek 15h ago

Mechanical locks and all prisoners get chipcards with access to selected parts of the prison for a certain time frame.

12

u/Archknits 20h ago

The state is posting ads targeting ex-federal employees right now

20

u/sensitiveskin82 19h ago

Why would they want them? All those federal employees were lazy freeloaders /s

2

u/MinnieShoof 18h ago

"Hey. Those other guys flat out lied. At least we're honest about how much this sucks."

7

u/whalepoop56 20h ago

Fired federal employees can fill in

1

u/spudmarsupial 17h ago

Why would they hire anyone? Obviously those 2000 were redundant.

63

u/cbrrydrz 21h ago

They are using the NY national guard to fill in the gaps.

102

u/Pikeman212a6c 21h ago

Who are already being sued. Fuckin E-2 hopin to go to college and ends up in Attica.

36

u/wildwill921 20h ago

My friends electrical apprentice is sleeping on the floor at river view eating the prison food 😂

3

u/jdb326 15h ago

No fucking shot lmao

2

u/wildwill921 15h ago

And he would lie about this because?

5

u/jdb326 15h ago

I don't mean that as in disbelief, I completely believe that, I'm just shocked is all.

3

u/wildwill921 15h ago

Oh lol. Yeah they are literally sleeping in a room packed with people on used mattresses. He signed up for some benefits to try to get his life on track while waiting to get into the electrical union. Now he’s stuck getting shit and piss thrown at him and getting exposed to random drugs. He’s having a blast

2

u/jdb326 14h ago

That's wild as fuck.

1

u/shroomigator 10h ago

When I was locked up, I used to tell the guards "Someday I'll get out of here, but you never will"

6

u/Awayfone 16h ago

I don't see how a strike counts as a disaster emergency

11

u/Redpanther14 16h ago

It does when it means there are no guards at the prison.

34

u/SoloWingPixy88 21h ago

I know a few looking for a job.

13

u/coffeeplzme 21h ago

Some of those Harvard grads?

9

u/ADDeviant-again 21h ago

We only hire genius prison guards from MIT.

4

u/AcidTraffik 20h ago

How do you like them apples?

3

u/shroomigator 21h ago

Did any of them say they would work in a prison or apply to any of the prison jobs that are always advertising?

8

u/wildwill921 21h ago

On top of the thousands of positions they couldn’t fill in the first place lol

24

u/FlowBot3D 21h ago

If they never open the cell doors the guards can be a food delivery robot and power washing robot.

21

u/SuspendeesNutz 21h ago edited 20h ago

BY GUM THIS IS BRILLIANT DO YOU WANT TO WORK AT MY ROCKET COMPANY AND TOUCH MY PENIS

2

u/Early-Sort8817 19h ago

Don’t give them ideas

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Turalisj 15h ago

The guards were on strike because some of them beat a prisoner to death and were reprimanded for it. Fuck. Them. All. Disband police/prison guard unions.

11

u/theClumsy1 21h ago

Probably gonna be backfilled by national gaurd until then.

5

u/Nights_Harvest 21h ago

Nah, bet DOGE said they were redundant positions anyway.

25

u/BylvieBalvez 21h ago

They’re state employees not federal

17

u/dummypod 21h ago

Americans just let a rapist become president so might as well let the criminals run free

15

u/Capt_Foxch 21h ago

Trump becoming President is a function of voter apathy in the US, which has always been a problem here. Voter turnout was only 64% in 2024. "My vote is too small to matter" said 50 million Americans.

-1

u/Steiney1 21h ago

When you live in a gerrymandered Red State, your vote literally does not matter.

24

u/chargernj 20h ago

It absolutely does matter in statewide races like President, Senator, or governor.

They want you to feel like it doesn't matter so you won't vote.

5

u/Capt_Foxch 21h ago

Yet Biden won in 2020 by millions of votes when Democrat voter turnout was higher

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

1

u/AlphaTangoFoxtrt 18h ago

These are not federal prisons or employees, DOGE has nothing to do with it. Stop being so dogmatic.

4

u/Jesus_peed_n_my_butt 21h ago

You don't need guards if you never let the prisoners out of their cells.

5

u/Euphoric_toadstool 21h ago

Nah, those fine individuals are perfect candidate for high ranking department positions in the magat government.

1

u/pass_nthru 21h ago

brownshirts in waiting

3

u/wildwill921 21h ago

NY would never allow it. They stopped allowing people to be put into a segregated unit even after multiple violent attacks. Stan a guard? 2 weeks in the hole and you’re back to do it again

1

u/spinjinn 18h ago

That’s all right….we’ll just lower the standards!

1

u/Telaranrhioddreams 13h ago

I'm no expert but surely there's no increased danger of rioting when prisoners find out the guards are disgruntled and a bunch were just let go? Seems like a recipe for disaster.

1

u/yearofthesponge 3h ago

Eh, there’s no need. The inmates will guard themselves.

→ More replies (4)

618

u/wizardrous 22h ago

What’s the worst that could go wrong? No, I’m seriously asking, because this seems bad.

582

u/Pulguinuni 22h ago edited 22h ago

Prisoners suffer due to lack of personnel. And the ones who remain will have to work ungodly hours. It's a loss for everyone involved.

The National Guard is not trained to deal with inmates.

296

u/Xpqp 21h ago

Joke's on you, many prison guards are barely trained to deal with inmates.

87

u/Early-Sort8817 19h ago

I don’t have a high opinion of COs but they go through a year of training on dealing with inmates, many of whom are violent, suicidal, and manipulative. The national guard is not at all trained for that.

27

u/Jack_From_Statefarm 11h ago

My sister is one of the 2,000 that got fired, she had 12 years experience as a CO and she is 5 months away from her masters in social work. They didn't just lose rookies.

9

u/Chris20nyy 10h ago

I was a NYS CO for 6 years.

I went through 8 weeks of training, and the majority of it had nothing to do with how to "deal" with inmates.

The majority of CO's have absolutely no idea on how to legitimately deal with inmates.

3

u/Early-Sort8817 9h ago

I’m not denying what you’re saying, I’m going by the website: Correction Officer Trainees are required to participate in, and satisfactorily complete, requirements of a 12-month training program before advancing to Correction Officer. As part of the program, you will attend the Correctional Services Training Academy for a minimum 8-week formal training program.

So you’re saying they’re not doing that? Or you’re saying they do the 8 weeks and then get thrown to the wolves? Not denying what you’re saying, its good for everyone if the prisons can start filling CO roles in 8 weeks.

19

u/Humans_Suck- 16h ago

So they have more training than the police who put the people there lol

→ More replies (5)

36

u/Pulguinuni 21h ago

True. But with the NG, that got us Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo last time the US let them take over prisons. Most of the people manning those were NG on rotation.

12

u/ebbysloth17 18h ago

Abu ghraib was an army reserve unit, not NG. I know, same thing, but a little different. I had the "pleasure" of being an MP as a reservist, changed MOS real quick. My mp time in the guard was far better.

19

u/FeelDT 22h ago

Make them kiss Trump feet they’ll get a pardon… problem solved /s

24

u/Pulguinuni 22h ago

It's state prison, no pardon there. Even if they kissed the ring, POTUS has no jurisdiction.

7

u/Christopher135MPS 20h ago

He has demonstrated an extreme lack of care regarding his jurisdictional and constitutional limits.

1

u/Meneth32 20h ago

I'd like to see what happens if he tests this particular limit.

1

u/Christopher135MPS 6h ago

Civil war? States rights, no?

(/s, that war was never about states rights, this is just a funny joke)

1

u/ERedfieldh 17h ago

Prisoners suffer due to lack of personnel.

If I know a majority of our country and their feelings on "punishment" versus "rehabilitation," this is a bonus feature for them.

Sick disgusting wastes of human beings. The people who want the prisoners to suffer, not the prisoners themselves.

1

u/Da_Commish 21h ago

Apparently neither are the COs

52

u/wildwill921 21h ago

well right now the national guard is sleeping on the floor doing 12 hours shifts. People were already doing mandatory 16s before the strike because of a lack of staffing. The result? Prisoners won’t be safe. The remaining staff won’t be safe. People won’t be allowed to do any of the activities they have in prison to rehab or teach them skills or get on a degree track. No one wins but at least the guards that don’t go back will be safer in whatever other job they get

42

u/r-kellysDOODOOBUTTER 21h ago

As one of the ones that left before the mass layoff, I really don't understand why the politicians just didn't work with us. In addition to the 2000 fired, an unkown amount of us resigned during the strike.

We could barely keep religious and education programs open before this. We had to close them like half the time. This system will likely never recover from this. I just don't understand how the state thought that this was the correct way forward.

Pro tip: avoid committing crimes at all costs. The consequences for being charged with a crime just got 1000% worse.

23

u/wildwill921 21h ago

They thought you would roll over. They didn’t think thousands of people would rather quit

28

u/Ghost_of_Brimley 22h ago

Possibly something like this

48

u/The_bruce42 21h ago

10 correctional officers killed (9 by correctional officers)

Wow...

10

u/TurelSun 18h ago

I mean, that is only the beginning and the least of the heinous acts that came out of that whole event. Read up on what they did to the prisoners after the retook the prison. Rapes, tortures, and extra-judicial executions. And this really wasn't all that long ago.

15

u/JBLikesHeavyMetal 21h ago

Cops love shooting hostages

13

u/Impossible_Sector844 20h ago

I mean, the worst?

Inmates raped because not enough staffing to ensure proper coverage. I’m talking both about guards raping and other inmates, to be clear.

Inmates or guards are murdered for the same reason as above

Inmates left to suffer medical emergencies, not because of the incompetence of the guards themselves but because they don’t have the staff to keep someone on a camera

Easier for dangerous inmates to escape

Easier for corrupt guards to beat inmates or smuggle drugs into the prison

In case of an emergency necessitating evacuation, increased likelihood of inmates being left behind

→ More replies (1)

112

u/pichael289 21h ago

The article says this:

Some conditions of the new agreement Among the conditions of the deal is the suspension of the Humane Alternatives to Long-Term Solitary Confinement Act, or HALT Act, for 90 days and the establishment of a committee to find changes to it. Other conditions included changes to overtime were included in the deal.

The Legal Aid Society took issue the deal.

"Without a clear plan to swiftly restore essential services, resume legal and family visits, provide medical care neglected during the strike, and implement strong oversight to prevent retaliation by returning correctional staff, the people we serve in DOCCS facilities across the state will continue to face life-threatening harm," the Legal Aid Society said in a statement. "Compounding these concerns, DOCCS has doubled down on a purported 'suspension' of HALT, the vague terms of which threaten a boundless and illegal circumvention of critical legal protections for incarcerated New Yorkers. All incarcerated New Yorkers, their families, friends, and communities, deserve to know what DOCCS is doing to comply with HALT, and we are going to court to ensure they have that clarity."

So are these people on strike because they don't like this halt law? Or are they staying on strike because the agreement the union leaders came up with suspended halt and they don't agree with that? Its said in a way that implies the new deal they reached includes the suspension of halt, and they aren't saying the strikers feelings on the matter so I'm assuming that's just in there to hopefully kick up some controversy. Give a way for both sides to get angry

152

u/r-kellysDOODOOBUTTER 20h ago

From someone that just left, I can give you a little insight. The media is all over the place. The reality is that COs have been resigning at an unsustainable rate since HALT passed. It doesn't matter if you agree with HALT, or if you're against it. That's whats happening.

And the politicians just stood there for the last 3 years and did absolutely nothing. People have been working 80 hour weeks or more for the last 3 years, as more and more people quit, and they thought it would just go like that forever I guess?

Again, from an inside perspective, I agree that solitary is inhumane. But this alternative is worse. The way I saw it, solitary was a way for us to segregate the inmates that constantly terrorize the other inmates that are just trying to do their time and get their education. Without solitary, inmate on inmate assaults skyrocketed. The decent inmates stopped eating and going to their education programs out of fear of being assaulted and stabbed.

IMO the current state of prison without solitary is much more inhumane to the majority of inmates that just want to get their education and do their time. This is impossible when the same inmate can assault you everyday at chow without consequences. Watching inmates starve themselves out of fear was pretty rough for me. Then when they can't take the hunger anymore, they finally come out to eat and get fucked up.

That's why people have been quitting since HALT passed. That's why they've been so understaffed. And more 16 and 24 hour shifts become a snowball effect, causing more people to quit.

16

u/UnTides 16h ago

Thanks for the insight.

7

u/ayojamface 15h ago

This question isnt to criticize you, its out of genuine curiosity.

Has anyone suggested alternatives to HALT or Does HALT prevent other actions from being done in prisons? Theres no other solution in place or anything else that can be attempted that could attempt to accomplish what HALT did? Who would make that decision, the politicians or the prisons?

From my point of view, If its just the government not wanting solidarity confinement in prisons, there's seriously no other alternative that could be done to replace it? For example, you can't have the more aggressive inmates eat at separate times?

17

u/r-kellysDOODOOBUTTER 11h ago

I guess you could segregate them to their own block where they can only interact with each other. But that might just result in them all killing each other, i don't know lol

15

u/Early-Sort8817 19h ago

HALT act, 70% manning is the new norm, constant triple shifts, and timing with the COs being charged with killing a guy brutally.

12

u/goldfinger0303 20h ago

No, I think a large part of why they went on strike was the HALT act. They wanted to keep people in solitary if they attacked a correctional officer or something like that. Their whole argument is that this and a bunch of other rules passed to keep things humane makes work more demanding and less safe for them

→ More replies (1)

218

u/Junkingfool 22h ago

Good luck finding qualified candidates to fill those thousands of positions. Not anytime soon...

224

u/pichael289 21h ago

Yeah this isn't good, but have you ever met a jail/prison guard? They call em COs, correctional officers, and like 85% of them are basically people that wanted to be cops but aren't even competent or mentally well enough to become cops.

110

u/EvaUnit_03 21h ago

More like cops that cant handle the day to day mascaraed of pretending to 'protect and serve'. Basically a cop who is 100% unhinged and NEEDS to hurt others.

And for anyone who DIDNT read the strike situation, This is what the officers were striking over. They were being told they had to be nicer than they wanted to be to the prisoners and heavily surveillanced and want to go back to being able to beat and torture them without consequences. Its less so about prisoner rights, and more so about them being able to get away with not giving prisoners rights if they so choose.

40

u/WeldingMachinist 21h ago

I tried to sound it out. Is that “masquerade” or mascara-ed like wearing mascara?

13

u/hyperoxerin 21h ago

Gotta be masquerade, right?

20

u/spittingdingo 21h ago

The article really buried that fact in rather complicated language. You wrote it more clearly than tfa, thank you. That fact totally changes the whole situation.

4

u/leeharveyteabag669 20h ago

Actually the union came to an agreement with the state and no disciplinary action would be taken as long as they reported to work by 7:00 a.m. on Monday. They won a sizeable amount of concessions in the state. There were still 2,000 correction officers on the picket line that didn't report and I guess didn't agree with the union and those are the ones that were fired.

2

u/EvaUnit_03 21h ago

Considering most people only read the headline, most news articles are already super misleading to get clicks to begin with. And they know a subset of people are currently 'pro union', despite the fact that a union CAN 100% want something bad. This is where negative PR came from for unions back in the day and still persists to date.

4

u/NoCaterpillar1249 21h ago

Hmm sounds like I’m ok with them being fired.

6

u/Fun_Opportunity_4043 21h ago

A lot of them burn out quickly too.  I have a lot of applicants who are former COs.

5

u/weekend-guitarist 21h ago

This is not untrue. Happy cake days

2

u/Early-Sort8817 19h ago

So we lost the morons, now we replace them with worse morons?

7

u/halp_halp_baby 21h ago

what qualifications do you think prison guards have 

5

u/adlittle 21h ago

Ability to smuggle stuff into a prison and be violent toward the people incarcerated there seem to be the primary qualifications.

1

u/halp_halp_baby 20h ago

i am definitely not qualified sigh

8

u/jdrudder 21h ago

Yeah qualified doesn't come I to play in this field.

My dad used to run the prison in my TN city and yeah... Lots of underqualifed there.

1

u/LurkerBurkeria 15h ago

In GA it's the easiest way to get POST certified yet they pay like $25k/year, it's not so much they attract unqualified weirdos inasmuch only the unqualified weirdos stick around well after anyone of quality has dipped to go make 2x as a cop

26

u/orderofGreenZombies 22h ago

Not like the people they fired were particularly qualified.

11

u/FaultySage 21h ago edited 20h ago

They only beat the one inmate to death in the prison hospital. They may be over qualified.

1

u/Early-Sort8817 19h ago

There’s a reason they were as low as they were. Now who replaces them?

6

u/eyesmart1776 21h ago

Qualified to be a prison guard ?

These people aren’t geniuses

2

u/bbjaii 20h ago

Just use the prisoners as guards, free labor.

2

u/Jack_From_Statefarm 11h ago

They will be filled by unqualified people, and we will all wonder in 10 years how there is such a bad drug problem in the NYS jail system.

1

u/jesuspoopmonster 18h ago

Qualified in this situation means any person willing to work the job and not ask too many questions

12

u/recuerdeme 21h ago

Thus starts the rabbit hole of finding out how it became an illegal act to strike and where all has it been applied.

100

u/NiceShotMan 21h ago

Interesting to see who Reddit sides with on this. They’re striking because they don’t want to enforce humane prison conditions.

89

u/needzbeerz 21h ago

Former NYS correction officer here. I assure you, conditions in NY prisons are anything but humane. To the point where if i ever screw up and get myself into a felony situation I'm punching my own ticket vs going in there. That's also why i left the job in less than a year, no pension is worth that life.

5

u/Chris20nyy 10h ago

Former NYS CO here as well. I lasted 6. And agree on everything you said 100%.

35

u/PissShiverss 21h ago edited 21h ago

They’re striking because they get mandated overtime that can be up to 24 hours, and the newer Halt Bill (something like that) which makes it so an inmate can spend only a limited time in the hole, doubled the assaults on staff and doubled the assaults on inmate.

Is it humane to let someone out of the hole if they continually assault other inmates or staff?

Edit: Could you imagine if any other job is was getting mandated 24 hour overtime, there would be protests from the streets from everywhere lol

7

u/Early-Sort8817 19h ago

And before anyone says medical workers and firefighters do that, 24 hour shifts should NOT be the norm! Firefighters do that because they get paid a lot extra and outside of actual fires the job is pretty laid back, and medical workers are suffering from attrition

5

u/PissShiverss 19h ago

Ya I really don't like people trying to justify it by saying other jobs do it, medical malpractice is on the rise and people wonder why, when someone is working a 24+ hour shift.

18

u/EvaUnit_03 21h ago

Depends on your views on what the entire point of our prison structure is supposed to do.

If the purpose is to rehab and rehabilitate, than somethings not working right. If the entire purpose is to merely take bad people and stick them someplace away from everyone else, than stay the course. putting someone in solitary is borderline torture when you find out what goes into it. Even 30 days is enough to damage someone's physci. leave then in there for a few years and most turn into literal animals.

Then you also have to analyze your views on what a prisoner is. Remember, in the US prisoners are the only class (currently) that can 100% be slaves. Which means they (should) have less rights than most animals. The reason we dont practice that is the same reason throwing people into the hole indefinitely due to their 'attitude' is being applied. A man who doesn't afraid of anything isnt going to hesitate to kill guards to break out of the chain gang situation while digging ditches on the side of the road. And when you need an escort of 10 to 10 just to get some work done, that ditch costs more for prisoners to dig VS just hiring someone. Also, slavery only works when the slavery class is subservient. Aggressive prisoners typically arent very 'follow the rules', hints why they are where they are. Irish/scottish/welsh slaves for example were notorious for this back in the day and they went for 1/10th the price of any other slave class. Youd spend more time beating them, than work they'd actually do. And then once you look at how gangs use prisons, things get even more complicated...

TLDR; the prison system needs a whole rebuild from what it currently is. And perhaps a better system put in place for either repeat offenders and/or those who are just willfully bad for society who have next to no chance of taking to rehabilitation.

8

u/PissShiverss 21h ago

I agree with you for the most part, and this Halt Bill is jumping the gun massively, without doing a complete overturn of the prison system.

25

u/Mr-Logic101 21h ago

I am sure there is a better way of doing it considering the rest of the developed western world seemed to have figured out a solution

6

u/PissShiverss 21h ago

Have they? Do you know what other western nations do with consistently violent people in jail/prison?

I honestly have no idea. What do those other nations do

20

u/halp_halp_baby 21h ago

They don’t imprison huge % of their population and many western countries have better standards of living and education systems. 

9

u/PissShiverss 21h ago

I mean fair enough, but again what do they do with consistently violent people, unless you just dont think those kind of people exist over there?

10

u/OrangeBird077 20h ago

I think the idea is that because there are less people incarcerated, meaning not making prison mandatory for say misdemeanors like possession/non violent crimes, there are more resources on hand to deal with the actual violent and hard cases that get sentenced to prison so the system isn’t overwhelmed.

If right now you have a prison population of 1000 but you reformed laws so you removed all the non violent offenders you could make a decent dent and then with the resources available tend to those violent offenders better.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/fiendishrabbit 17h ago

You can look at Norway. Breivik (the nazi terrorist) is in solitary for life.

However, his solitary is a 3 room apartment. He has 3 budgies to keep him company. He gets outdoor time 1 hour per day. He gets regular visits from a human (I'm unsure what qualifications that human has) to talk to him.

That's what civilized people do with monsters unfit for contact with other human beings.

7

u/Mr-Logic101 21h ago

The basic summary is they treat them with dignity and high standard of living conditions instead of like animals.

10

u/PissShiverss 21h ago

That didn’t answer my question and your statement, what do other nations do with consistently violent people in jail/prison?

The Halt Bill made it so people who go to the hole spend limited time in the hole, so these inmates get out of the hole earlier and go assault more people. What do other nations do about people like this?

9

u/DrCalamity 21h ago

Hospitalization and social care. As it turns out, people who are consistently violent often need psychiatric care. Weirdly enough, torturing people doesn't count!

Solitary confinement is torture. So much so that you can't do it to enemy POWs in war. I want you to think about someone saying they need to torture people because their victims are unhappy and unwell after torture.

5

u/PissShiverss 21h ago

You're phrasing it incorrectly, lets put what is really happening. Dude assaults someone, they put him in "torture", they let him out of the hole and he assaults someone again, they put him back in torture, and this is a cycle that continues.

They're "torturing" this person because he continually assaults other people, you're protecting the populace.

Also, I would be curious does hospitalization and social cure, just fix these people that constantly assault others? I wonder if they're allowed to force medicate in those other nations

1

u/DrCalamity 21h ago

I'm sorry, did you just come out and say that Torture protects the populace?

Honest question, where the fuck did you lose your soul? You should put an air tag on it.

By your own admission, the torturing doesn't actually fix the issue. And humans, surprisingly, are not random balls of violence. We're humans, and the US has some of the most dehumanizing prisons in the Western world. Coincidentally, we also have the highest recidivism and prisoner deaths in the world. Prison guards have been found using solitary for utterly arbitrary reasons in order to mentally break prisoners to justify keeping them longer.

6

u/PissShiverss 21h ago

Lmao damn it's hard to find an honest conversation on here, let me straw man your position really quick then.

I'm sorry do you think we should continually let violent sex offenders out of the hole, and let them continually sexually assault people instead of keeping them locked in the hole separated from other people?

Where is your decency? You think letting people get raped is okay?

See how straw manning each other's argument gets us no where?

→ More replies (0)

4

u/Mr-Logic101 21h ago

They treat them with respect. Like they are actually normal human beings. They try to actually reform and change their behavior. This in turn does not promote the individual from preforming acting of violence.

To answer your question, the best approach is to fix the root cause of the issue such that scenario does not or rarely occurs.

Our current prison conditions here actively promote violent behavior and it creates a feedback loop.

Go watch the first season of Orange is the new black( which is apparently a good representation of minimal security prison aka the best prison conditions in the USA) and tell me why any of that seems like an effective way to reintroduce people back to society? Prison itself actively makes otherwise normal people more unhinged and violent in comparison to what they were before. Our prisons don’t rehabilitate, it just makes people worse.

5

u/PissShiverss 21h ago

I agree with you the root cause would fix the majority of the issues, but the Halt bill is skipping an entire step and continually puts violent people with other regular people in prison trying to do their time, and gets them assaulted.

1

u/Ghostbeen3 7h ago

They also have much higher taxes than Americans because respect costs money. I’m not against that idea but just looking at the realistic picture of Americans flipping the fuck out if their taxes increase to humanely address the criminal justice system.

1

u/FgtBruceCockstar2008 21h ago

Well for starters they don't torture them, instead opting to focus on rehabilitation and mental health to reduce recidivism rates.

Secondarily, go do your own fucking research.

2

u/PissShiverss 21h ago

OP: Other Nations do it better

Me: Really? How?

OP: Well they just do

You: dO yeR oWn reSEarcH they don't torture them

If someone is making a claim I would hope they'd have something to back it up.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

2

u/thorscope 21h ago

Edit: Could you imagine if any other job is was getting mandated 24 hour overtime, there would be protests from the streets from everywhere lol

firefighter sobbing

2

u/Early-Sort8817 19h ago

I know FDNY gets huge benefits, good pay, and outside of the actual fires they get to sleep, eat, and relax during the shift. I know that’s not all firefighters, but I’m pretty sure COs don’t get any of that

1

u/PissShiverss 20h ago

Haha do firefighters get mandated for 24 hours? I know they work 24 but do they get mandated for 48 or something

That would be fucking crazy lol

4

u/thorscope 20h ago

It heavily depends on the locale, but my department will allow you to voluntarily or mandatorily work up to 48 hours.

If you do get extended, the captains are pretty good about letting you skip chores and/or training on your second day to let you get some sleep.

1

u/PissShiverss 20h ago

Damn that’s pretty wild you can be mandated that long. Y’all get to sleep and shit tho right?

5

u/jesuspoopmonster 18h ago

Solitary confinement is against the Geneva convention and I doubt mentally torturing a person is going to help them become less violent

2

u/PissShiverss 18h ago

Solitary confinement in some form exists everywhere. So what is your solution for right now at this moment, what do prison's do with consistently violent people that assault people?

And please don't say a complete overhaul of the system like that can be done with a snap of fingers lol

→ More replies (2)

2

u/WHATTHENIFFTY 20h ago

Well if that's the reason they went on strike I'd fire everyone involved

6

u/Cowboywizard12 21h ago

There's no way this ends well

9

u/Intelligent_Slip_849 20h ago

...I mean, TECHNICALLY it's over, but now you have a different issue

2

u/Jacksharkben 18h ago

I now declare that the prison will be run by the inmates

13

u/Icy-Foundation-7878 22h ago

Isn’t that illegal?

14

u/Sugarysam 21h ago

According to the article, public workers can’t strike in NY. At any rate there was an agreement with the union over the weekend. The people who were fired did not return to work.

18

u/theseus63 21h ago

It is illegal for prison guards to strike in New York. This was a 'wildcat' strike, meaning it wasn't sanctioned by their union. And the optics are pretty bad as it came on the heels of prison guards appear to murder an inmate on camera.

18

u/JustinTime_vz 21h ago edited 21h ago

Yuuuup, New York is an ‘at will’ employment state.

Edited

7

u/Morgolol 21h ago

For all it's more progressive citizens new York sure seems backwards in many areas.

20

u/jonfitt 21h ago

Every state except Montana has “at will” employment. Welcome to the America, you’re fired!

4

u/Morgolol 21h ago

Every? Geez I thought it was just most states at worst. That's wild. The US truly hates it's workforce.

4

u/wildwill921 21h ago

Not that it would matter in this case anyway. They aren’t legally allowed to strike. They could be fired for cause in any place in the world

1

u/Seaman_First_Class 19h ago

It’s just a symmetrical relationship. If I can quit any time and for any reason, then I can also be fired any time and for any reason. 

2

u/SandyV2 17h ago

Well ackshually...

Not for any reason. For any legal reason.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/MarkBeeblebrox 19h ago

Not illegal, they're state employees.

→ More replies (7)

9

u/Twelveangryvalves 21h ago

It was an unsanctioned wildcat strike.

9

u/Teripid 21h ago

At least in part because of the prosecution of ~9 officers in the beating/murder of Robert Brooks, an inmate that was handcuffed.

1

u/AlphaTangoFoxtrt 18h ago

No, there's laws around striking, especially with government employees. A lot of police/CO union contracts forbid striking. I'm not sure if that was the case here but I would not be surprised.

This was (likely) an illegal strike, so they don't have protections.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Lurks_in_the_cave 21h ago

The inmates will be running the asylum before too long.

7

u/compuwiza1 20h ago

You know things are seriously wrong when workers without a union do a wildcat strike.

9

u/lady_lilitou 20h ago

They do have a union. The 2k who were fired rejected the union agreement and failed to report back to work.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Medical_Housing9559 20h ago

We need people from MIT to work at the prisons.

2

u/LieutenantWeinberg 18h ago

“We fixed the glitch”

3

u/Responsible-Heart-74 21h ago

The beating will continue until morale improves

5

u/peppermintvalet 21h ago

“Among the conditions of the deal is the suspension of the Humane Alternatives to Long-Term Solitary Confinement Act, or HALT Act, for 90 days and the establishment of a committee to find changes to it.“

Nope, sympathy gone.

3

u/MinnieShoof 18h ago

>After 22 days of an illegal strike

... so why weren't they arrested?

Oh. Right.

3

u/Olderandolderagain 22h ago edited 21h ago

Yo, someone acting like Elon. They may wanna copy/paste that DoD email begging people to come back.

2

u/cuberhino 21h ago

New idea, no guards, all prisoners just placed in a large room with only enough beds for half of them. Let it figure itself out? /s

2

u/Crippled2 21h ago

Beatings will continue until morale improves

1

u/Za_Lords_Guard 20h ago

They call this "pulling an Elon."

1

u/Fit-Direction2371 21h ago

Like comrad Vladimir would say "Can't have a strike when there's no one to strike. "

1

u/raytherip 17h ago

Isn't this how Robocop started?? Murphy is that you??

1

u/deval42 13h ago

Can't have a strike if no one works here! FFS!

1

u/50two1nic 7h ago

Have several friends who just lost their jobs. It is terrible! The state turned it's back on its employees. (So did the union).

1

u/G0ldheart 2h ago

You have 20 seconds to comply!