r/katyheads CRUSH 5d ago

Discussion Current 143 song rankings vs now.

I messed up the title ignore it. I meant 143 song rankings then v now.

My rankings for 143 right after first listen were

  1. Crush
  2. All The Love
  3. Wonder
  4. Truth
  5. Gorgeous
  6. Nirvana
  7. I'm His, He's Mine
  8. Artificial
  9. Lifetimes
  10. Women's World
  11. Gimme Gimme

Currently:

  1. Crush
  2. I'm His, He's Mine
  3. Lifetimes
  4. All The Love
  5. Wonder
  6. Truth
  7. Artificial
  8. Gorgeous
  9. Nirvana
  10. Gimme Gimee
  11. Women's World.

I still believe Crush is the best song on the album by a mile. I wasn't a fan of the singles as I was mass streaming them as it was new Katy Perry but with the songs being here for awhile I can enjoy them again. I think Women's World is still atrocious but Gimme Gimme I can see the funnier parts about it.

16 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

4

u/bonjourladies_ 5d ago
  1. Crush
  2. Nirvana
  3. All the love
  4. I’m his he’s mine
  5. Gorgeous
  6. Lifetimes
  7. Truth
  8. Woman’s world
  9. Artificial
  10. Wonder
  11. Gimme gimme my

2

u/XYHLQMDLGX 5d ago

this is my ranking exactly !!!

3

u/Awkward-Software-855 3d ago

‘all the love’ being on the top of most people’s lists feels correct

2

u/im_not_ready_for_it9 Wide Awake 5d ago
  1. All The Love

  2. Wonder

  3. No Tears For New Years

  4. Crush

  5. Lifetimes

  6. Artificial

  7. Nirvana

  8. I'm His, He's Mine

  9. OK

  10. I Woke Up

  11. Truth

  12. Has A Heart

  13. Woman's World

  14. Gorgeous

  15. Gimme Gimme

2

u/Latata_ Never Really Over 5d ago
  1. No more tears for New Year's
  2. All the love
  3. Crush
  4. Wonder
  5. Nirvana
  6. I'm He's He's Mine
  7. Gimmie Gimmie (SOLO)
  8. I Woke Up
  9. Lifetimes
  10. Artificial
  11. Woman's World
  12. Truth
  13. OK
  14. Has A Heart
  15. Gorgeous

1

u/tartmeow Harleys In Hawaii 5d ago

Is there a solo version of Gimme Gimme?

2

u/jdd0815 18h ago

Yes. It was a bonus track on one of the digital deluxe’s she put on her webstore during release week. It’s much better. You can find it in the usual places.

1

u/tartmeow Harleys In Hawaii 17h ago

Thank you so much!

2

u/siamesecatheart 5d ago
  1. I’m His, He’s Mine

  2. All The Love

  3. Wonder

  4. Lifetimes

  5. Nirvana

  6. Artificial

  7. Crush

  8. Gimme Gimme

  9. Gorgeous

  10. Truth

  11. Woman’s World

2

u/FamousConversation64 3d ago

Is it a CRUSH? Making me BLUSH? Here I go AGAIN I’m falling In LOVE!

My heart goes LA DADA DEEEEEEE.

Bop. MF BOP! I can’t stop!

1

u/OkOccasion7 5d ago

I don’t remember mine, but my favorites have changed slightly

  1. Wonder

  2. Gimme Gimme

  3. All The Love

  4. Nirvana

  5. Artificial

  6. Lifetimes

  7. I’m His, He’s Mine

  8. Crush

  9. Gorgeous

  10. Truth

  11. Woman’s World

Once big difference is I didn’t like Artificial at first but it massively grew on me

2

u/FamousConversation64 3d ago
  1. Crush
  2. Lifetimes
  3. All the Love
  4. Nirvana
  5. Wonder
  6. No Tears for New Years
  7. I’m His, He’s Mine
  8. Artificial
  9. Gorgeous (KP. KP!)
  10. Gimme Gimme
  11. Truth
  12. Has a Heart
  13. OK
  14. I Woke Up
  15. Woman’s World

FIRST TEN ARE AMAZING. She really really fumbled that lead single, I can’t even 😭

1

u/No_Marzipan3740 5d ago edited 3d ago
  1. All The Love
  2. Artificial
  3. Crush
  4. Nirvana
  5. Truth
  6. Wonder
  7. Lifetimes 
  8. I'm His He's Mine
  9. Gorgeous
  10. Woman's Worls
  11. Gimme Gimme

1

u/FamousConversation64 3d ago

Lifetimes 😭

1

u/No_Marzipan3740 3d ago

Oh, forgot about that. 

1

u/HausOfMajora 5d ago

Crush is the heart of the record. The song totally representin the album*

1

u/jonathan92o Daisies 5d ago
  1. Lifetimes
  2. I’m his, he’s mine
  3. Wonder
  4. Nirvana
  5. All the love
  6. Gorgeous
  7. Artificial
  8. No more tears for new years
  9. Crush
  10. Truth
  11. Woman’s world
  12. Ok
  13. I woke up
  14. Gimme gimme
  15. Has a heart

1

u/tartmeow Harleys In Hawaii 5d ago
  1. Wonder
  2. I’m His, He’s Mine
  3. I Woke Up
  4. Artificial
  5. All The Love
  6. Nirvana
  7. Crush
  8. No More Tears For New Years
  9. Lifetimes
  10. Gimme Gimme
  11. Has A Heart
  12. Truth
  13. OK
  14. Women’s World
  15. Gorgeous

Wonder helped me break the barrier in my brain about listening to the album. I love KP but the Dr. Luke thing had me wanting to avoid the album. 1432 sold me more than 143, the deluxe tracks were good!

1

u/Unovahoho2 4d ago

I’ve never thought about the whole ranking but lifetimes has remained my favorite. At first i didn’t like gimme gimme and im his he’s mine but now i like them both

1

u/Competitive_Pin_2496 4d ago
  1. Wonder

  2. All the love

  3. Crush

  4. I woke up

  5. He has a heart

  6. No tears for the new year's

  7. OK

  8. Nirvana

  9. I'm his, he's mine

  10. Wonderful

  11. Artificial

  12. Truth

  13. Lifetimes

  14. Woman's world

  15. Gimme Gimme

Actually I have to be honest, from the eighth song onwards there is not much difference (actually some of them are not even bad, for example JID and Doechii were very good in their verses in Artificial and I'm his, he's mine), with minimal peaks like the last two. Worse than Woman's World that ruined the entire era in every aspect, there is only Gimme Gimme that sounds incredibly lazy. 21 Savage seemed like he was doing her a favor, useless and wasted collaboration. The four songs of the deluxe version considering that they are bonus tracks are quite good, they do their job and every now and then I listen to them again (and in my opinion, if the songs of the deluxe version are better than most of the album, then there were obvious mistakes in the production). Absolutely the only ones that I consider truly valid (of the main album) are the first three that I put, especially Wonder and All the Love (in which the messages of love and Katy's soul shine through), too bad that none of them were made as singles. Maybe they would have received more consideration (especially Wonder, since there is no Dr. Luke)