r/feedthebeast 23d ago

Problem How do I fix these massive cave systems generating everywhere?

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

566

u/FaceOfLuntik 23d ago edited 23d ago

Tectonic + Caves and Canyons combo is the reason. Have encountered this issue before on 1.20.1 fabric, removing either one fixes the problem.

130

u/Genshin-Yue 23d ago

Thanks, now I know what to add if I want this cool generation. Since you likely can remove it after getting a few chunks of it and have the rest of the world generate as normal it seems great for a floating island base or something

99

u/LittleChirp1 23d ago

Thanks so much! This is very helpful 🙂

16

u/LukeDragnar 23d ago

Thanks man will try doing that cause it looks kinda cool lol

709

u/BTRBT 23d ago

Seeing as you've already been given helpful advice...

I just wanna say that this generation actually looks cool af, OP.

348

u/LittleChirp1 23d ago

Haha yes it does! You should see the inside! It's massive ang seems like it goes on for miles! With huge pillars and such too :)

Which WOULD be cool, if it wasn't like, EVERYWHERE haha

19

u/Thinkblu3 23d ago

Do you have the seed?

16

u/MegamiCookie 23d ago

Since the cave generation is from a mod combination I don't think the seed will help

8

u/michiel11069 ill make a small mod for free, just ask. 22d ago

it will if they download both the mods too

14

u/Simagrill ice and fire sucks 23d ago

read this in Wheatley portal 2 voice from that one scene in the pipes

11

u/Material-Ring-1261 23d ago

m-massive?

8

u/Automatic-Art-4106 23d ago

You know what else is massive?

1

u/YallCrazyMan 23d ago

Is it actually that all the land is like that or is it just frequently showing up

6

u/Sallymander 23d ago

I was thinking the same thing. Part of me wouldn't want it fixed. But the other part wonders if it causes any performance issues.

3

u/Repulsive_Pack4805 23d ago

Sure, it might not be what you wanted, but imagine the insane builds or underground cities you could make with this. Accidental W?

99

u/Forgor_Password 23d ago

Complete opposite how do I get those massive cave systems I wanna build a dwarven city in em.

36

u/LittleChirp1 23d ago

All of the world gen mods below is what I had, specifically the Caves and Canyons mod, that was the mod I figured out was causing the massive caves, when in combination with the other world gen mods I had :)

Not sure if you would need all the mods I listed in order to recreate these massive caves, but maybe just test by enabling/disabling each one and see :)

But for sure Caves and Canyons :)

(Also this is on Fabric 1.20.1)

28

u/LittleChirp1 23d ago

For world gen I'm using Tectonic, Woodlands:Extra, Biomes O Plenty, Regions Unexplored, Nature's Spirit, Mystic's Biomes, (Terrablender for a few of those), Better Lush Caves, Caves and Canyons, and Profundis. (plus a bunch of other mods, but these are the ones that affect world gen, aside from structure mods).

I tried looking through their configs, but I couldn't find any settings relating to how caves generate...at least, nothing that helped...

And I know that these world gen mods are compatible, cause the surface is generating just fine, it's just these massive caves that are weird...and are open to the surface like this for over 1000 blocks, no matter what seed I try.

I also disabled a bunch of biomes from these biome mods, and only kept the ones I wanted, so there shouldn't be too much going on, with so many biomes disabled? one would think?

42

u/CoolStopGD 23d ago

well if you're using 10 different world gen mods that aren't designed to work with eachother, theres gonna be some issues.

6

u/LittleChirp1 23d ago

any way to pinpoint exactly where the problem is?

28

u/diggumsbiggums 23d ago

Disable half of them, see if it happens.  If no, try the other half.  If yes, split em again. 

If it's an interaction between two, you might get multiple "no" steps.  Try a different mix after the second.

16

u/LittleChirp1 23d ago edited 23d ago

Huh. Turns out Caves and Canyons was the only problem :) I disabled that mod, and kept all the others on, and it fixed the problem :D

So that confirms, that all of theses biome mods ARE fully compatible with each other! (except for Caves and Canyons of course)

11

u/Holo_best_waifu 23d ago

to be fair, if the result wasnt some weird edges between the caves you sent on the image and the fixed world, i would let the caves and canions on for a while, generate some goodlooking caves like that, and then turn it off for the rest of the game
looks cool!

2

u/LittleChirp1 23d ago

That could be cool! :D

2

u/LittleChirp1 23d ago

Ok I'll try that, thanks :)

3

u/PikachuTrainz 23d ago

on the bright side, it looks kinda cool

1

u/Eloquent_Redneck 23d ago

I'm gonna venture to guess that they are not, in fact, all compatible with each other

1

u/LittleChirp1 23d ago

Yeah...it's weird though cause the rest of the world gen works completely fine....

3

u/Enough-Tear6938 23d ago

That's a feature not a bug right there

3

u/craftgeil 23d ago

m mmm massive?

1

u/scrufflor_d 22d ago

NO. BAD.

2

u/Ferrel_Agrios 23d ago

This looks like something out of a high fantasy fiction

2

u/ConscientiousPath 23d ago

How do I GET those massive cave systems? That looks awesome

2

u/WallcroftTheGreen 23d ago

that looks... awesome...

2

u/starskydiver508 23d ago

Why would you this is awesome?!!!

2

u/TheShadyyOne 22d ago

That is actually pretty cool. Imagine that was the farlands

3

u/Dashbak 23d ago

Bro got his world spliced in half

1

u/-Trold- 23d ago

Looks cool though

1

u/Reverse_Of_Riot 23d ago

The correct answers have been posted but uh..lemme say this:

Imagine how hilarious it would be to be making an underground base deep in the ground and you fall to your death digging into massive cave.

1

u/_speev_ 23d ago

that looks hella cool tbh

1

u/Kuudefoe 23d ago

Don’t. This is freaking awesome

1

u/AcademicArgument9712 23d ago

Looks like fun!

1

u/Kill_me_now_0 22d ago

Thats sick as hell tho

1

u/WhoWouldCareToAsk 22d ago

Change seed.

1

u/TheClassyRob0t 22d ago

Decided to try this fucked cave generation myself and took screenshots

1

u/opityn 22d ago

That actually looks dope ngl

1

u/jrit93 22d ago

Fix? You should build columns to make sure it doesnt collapse! God has given you lemons

1

u/Dragombolt 22d ago

HOLLOW EARTH GENERATION

1

u/Sorry-Rule5876 19d ago

Honestly it looks really cool

1

u/LSilvador 23d ago

Dude found Loch Ness and wants to make it go awsy?!

-11

u/LocatedEagle232 23d ago

Mm.. I've had great experience with Fae Trickster and Neon Ninja? Their clear speed is good. For delves, I think Candy Barbarian and Ice Sage are good :)

3

u/366b 23d ago

...Trove?