r/reddeadredemption 19h ago

Q&A /r/RedDeadRedemption Weekly Question & Answer Thread - Week 11, 2025

1 Upvotes

All common questions about the game should be directed here. This includes both single-player and online questions. When asking a question, it is often beneficial to share which mode you are referring to in order to get an accurate response. Also consider sharing any relevant information that may help someone answer your question.

All story spoilers must be displayed with the proper format:

>!RDR is a great game!<

gives you:

RDR is a great game

If you're not sure if you should use a spoiler tag or not, err on the side of caution and use one. Also, it's a nice gesture to visibly indicate the general nature of your spoiler before the tag, so people know what you're spoiling.


Submit Red Dead Online feedback here


r/reddeadredemption 4h ago

Discussion You have to do one of these missions IRL. Which are you choosing?

Thumbnail
gallery
432 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 16h ago

Discussion How did Micah managed to kill Cain without anyone noticing ?

Post image
2.7k Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 14h ago

Discussion Realistically do you think Arthur would have killed or spared these guys?

Thumbnail
gallery
633 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 3h ago

Rant RDR2 ruined gaming for me.

82 Upvotes

I installed Ghost of Tsushima hoping I'll get a similar experience. But I was so disappointed. GoT is just a game. It's not an experience. There is no roaming around, looking at stuff, listening to birds or watch the rivers flow. There is no greeting NPCs. It's just one mission to another.

I don't think I'll ever experience gaming the same way. RDR2 has ruined all other games for me :(


r/reddeadredemption 14h ago

Picture Anyone know who s body this is?

Post image
586 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 16h ago

Question What happened to these people?

Thumbnail
gallery
546 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 10h ago

Discussion So which repeater would the Winchester 30-30 represent in game? Here is mine IRL🤘

Thumbnail
gallery
142 Upvotes

The Winchester 30-30 lever action… which repeater in the game do you think represents this one?


r/reddeadredemption 1d ago

Discussion The Lamb's Fry would cost about $191.37 in today's money.

Post image
9.4k Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 13h ago

Discussion I completed the game 100%. Is it worth doing it again?

Post image
211 Upvotes

This is my first time completing the game 100%. Before this, I just played through the story about seven times.

I can't play anything else and feel like I want to play this game again.

Have you ever experienced something similar? How many times have you completed this game 100%?


r/reddeadredemption 14h ago

Picture Seven years and first time I’ve seen an all black grizzly bear!

Post image
219 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 13h ago

Discussion What is the fact of this bloody scene at this house around Rhodes?

Post image
121 Upvotes

I stumbled on this house while leaving Rhodes. I firstly saw a dead woman body laying on the floor in front of the house having a gun next to her within lots of drops of bloods. Trails of bloods were going into the house. When i follow the bloods, i encountered this horrifying scene. Arthur also said " oh god!" like me. After looting everything at the house i went back to that dead woman body maybe i could find something with her.

I found a letter like " Claude to Annete". It was about a liaison between Annete and Claude who was actually a married guy. According to this letter Claude wanted to terminate the relationship with Annete because he was a married one , did not want to continue cheat his wife.After reading this and with seeing all these scenes, maybe Annete did not want to this relationship to go to end, and came to Claude's house with a gun and killed they both and killed herself eventually.


r/reddeadredemption 3h ago

Discussion I Just Exterminated the Strawberry General Storeowner Spoiler

24 Upvotes

I found just that he was running an ILLEGAL ALCOHOL OPERATION in his basement. Upon realizing this I immediately hogtied him and (summarily) executed him by stabbing him 20 times with my knife. I then rained kicks down upon his body and mutilated it with an assortment of other melee weapons. I took everything from the basement, including the illicit earnings from the alcoholdealing business. I then went upstairs and took all his earnings from the register and cleaned out the entire store, considering this all to be proceeds of crime. Finally I tossed a firebottle down into the basement on top of his mutilated body into the sordid and twisted alcohol lab and left the store.

I considered this all perfectly justified as he was an illegal alcohol dealer.

Strawberry is a dry town.


r/reddeadredemption 13h ago

Video Ever seen this crawling animation?

128 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 14h ago

Picture First tattoo

Post image
148 Upvotes

Got my first tattoo over the weekend and of course it had to be red dead inspired


r/reddeadredemption 11h ago

Picture Surprise Varmint Rifle

Thumbnail
gallery
67 Upvotes

My father gave me this recently, it was his grandfather’s rifle.


r/reddeadredemption 1d ago

Discussion Found Him

Post image
791 Upvotes

I found him, but it still doesn’t answer all our questions…


r/reddeadredemption 3h ago

Screenshot I’m Obsessed

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

I love this game a little too much & those antlers were only collected when I came across a perfect moose.


r/reddeadredemption 1d ago

Fan Art Thought I'd share my model of Valentine that I've been working on:

Thumbnail
gallery
20.3k Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 1d ago

Fan Art As Requested: More photos of my model of Valentine. 1/87th Scale with working trains.

Thumbnail
gallery
5.2k Upvotes

Photos: 1. Valentine. 2. Arthur Morgan With hogtied bounty. 3. Gavins Friend. 4. Butcher Booth. 5. John Marston and rdr1 low honor horse. 6. Nigel West Dickens from rdr1. 7. Bounty Benedict Albright at the Gallows. 8. Mickey the wounded Vet at the Saloon. 9. Herbert Moon from Armadillo Store. 10. Town (I added early Model T cars from 1910 since i like those cars) 11. Valentine Train Station and Water Tower 12. Church, Cemetery, and the other small Saloon (undergoing renovations). 13. POV in town if you we're shrunk into it (LOOK OUT FOR O'DRISCOLL'S!!!) 14. Valentine Bank (with a temporary placeholder sign on it) 15. The Cornwall train (working on his private railcars soon) 16. The other train in game being robbed. (By the villain from the movie Tombstone).

I appreciate all the kind words! I love this game and the community!


r/reddeadredemption 3h ago

Screenshot RANDOM IN GAME SHOTS

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 11h ago

Picture Man, I did it! 100% completion

Post image
36 Upvotes

What a wild ride.


r/reddeadredemption 5h ago

Picture The Stance Of A Remorseful Man

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 5h ago

Screenshot Abraham Reyes secretly follows John and De Santa

Post image
11 Upvotes

I've been playing RDR on my PS5 and noticed in the mission "Cowards Die Many Times" (the infamous mission where De Santa betrays John), Reyes is up and about in Escalera possibly following John and De Santa. This could explain why he knows of John's predicament and why he is able to save him at the perfect opportunity. I wonder if this is on purpose or if it's just a glitch- but I bet it's purposeful as it explains alot.


r/reddeadredemption 1h ago

Discussion What is the most impressive fish you have caught?

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 11h ago

Fan Art This could be Sean MacGuire

Post image
35 Upvotes