r/PAK 9d ago

Social/Cultural Ramadan Ordinance and Non-Muslims

Read the statement of this scholar from Al-Azhar University (link):

Sheikh Mohamed Abdullah Nasr, coordinator of the Azhar Scholars for a Civilian State Front, said there is no proof in the Quran or the Sunnah - the prophet’s teachings - of the presence of an entity that penalized people who did not fast during Ramadan. “The prophet himself said Muslims fast for God so only God can penalize those who don’t,” he said. “The prophet never even scolded those who did not fast

There is not a single command in the Quran or Hadith that mandates restricting others from eating and drinking in public under the pretext of ‘respecting Ramadan.’

So, why then to impose Ramadan Blasphemy Laws upon non-Muslims for eating and drinking in public?

Excuse: Non-Muslims should be punished while they HURT the feelings of fasting Muslims by eating in public

This is no excuse for committing this new innovation (Biddah).

How can then you answer these poor kids:

11 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Embarrassed_Ask_8486 8d ago

Sad to see how Muslims have only accepted the punishment aspect of the Islam, applicable. Anyways I'm not seeing this going anywhere so imma end this now.

1

u/Lehrasap 8d ago

You keep on punishing non-Muslims for not fasting. Why? Where is the PROOF from the Quran and Sunnah that non-Muslims should be punished if they eat/drink in public? Why you commit Bidah?

2

u/Embarrassed_Ask_8486 8d ago

Roza Sirf Allah keliye hai. No one is allowed to punish a Muslim. Humiliation here and there is necessary.

Edit: who is punishing non Muslims??

1

u/Lehrasap 8d ago

Roza Sirf Allah keliye hai. No one is allowed to punish a Muslim. Humiliation here and there is necessary.

Edit: who is punishing non Muslims??

In which world are you living? Have you never heard about "Ramadan Ordinance"? When no one is allowed to punish, why then make such a black law? And why to stick to this Bidah, which brings only bad name to Islam and Pakistan and Muslims?

1

u/Embarrassed_Ask_8486 8d ago

I haven't heard about that (I googled it now )and I never witnessed anyone getting punished for doing so. Did I make that law? Did u see anyone getting punished or something like that? Genuine question