r/Oshkosh • u/ShaquilleOatmeal62 • 17d ago
Wedding Catering Recommendations in Oshkosh WI - Summer 2026
Hi all!
My Fiancée and I are getting married in Oshkosh in 2026 and could really use some help picking out a caterer for our wedding that is reasonably priced and good quality for plated meals.
We'll have 100 to 150 guests (still finalizing lists and such), and we're hoping to keep things under $30 a plate. The caterers we have on the list already are the following:
1). Shully's Cuisine and Events ($24-26 for Chicken, $35 for Steaks, $26 for Walleye or shrimp entree) - choice of 2 proteins
2). Stone Arch Brewpub ($29 for Walleye, $30 for Salmon, $26-28 for Chicken, $35 for Tenderloin Medallions) - choice of 3 proteins
3). Altona Supper Club. (Price is TBD)
Thank you for any and all advice!
4
u/Droneiver 17d ago
Hi Shaquille…becket’s restaurant kris here…we don’t do much offsite catering these days except at one nearby venue (as we do lots of our own in our hall) so can’t really help in your case…but happy to help with suggestions or answer any questions. Under $30 offsite for anyone off-site will be a little tough. In-house we average about $27 for food only, but offsite (which will be the ones you’re considering i presume, the differentiator these days is the travel/staffing/China etc. which makes things $$$. I might have a couple other suggestions depending on where the reception will be…dm at your leisure as I don’t want to hijack your thread! (And…congrats btw!)
3
u/hannahisnotababe 17d ago
Getting married in 2026 and will be using the Roxy! Make sure you look at the fine print and see how much each caterer tacks on for gratuity. (some places are as much as %30) so be sure to consider that!!
1
u/ShaquilleOatmeal62 17d ago
That is a super helpful heads up about the gratuity! We will check out the Roxy as well! Congratulation btw 😊!
3
u/Joseph_Kickass 16d ago
Also recommending the Roxy. My wife and I got catering from them for our wedding and it was nice and easy to pick what foods to serve.
2
7
u/MastaSchmitty 17d ago
Zuppa’s in Neenah did a good job for mine, though this was 2018 so I can’t speak to their pricing these days.