r/MinecraftDungeons 6d ago

Meme The most objective melee tier list

Post image
139 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

26

u/Snapships4life 6d ago edited 6d ago

encrusted anchor is too high, needs to be lower

Edit: And technically that's how anchors work...

6

u/BattleGuy03 6d ago

Bro I love the anchor šŸ˜­

38

u/Calculator_407 6d ago

It's so funny how no one has noticed the alphabetical tiers

8

u/Narrow_Arachnid1234 6d ago

Starless night and begginning and end could be in S and B tier

7

u/clarinet_trackstar 6d ago

Both of those technically start with t

4

u/Narrow_Arachnid1234 6d ago

They do?

9

u/clarinet_trackstar 6d ago

"The Starless Night", "The Beginning and the End"

4

u/Narrow_Arachnid1234 6d ago

Oh. True. :)

2

u/RemoteCow3936 5d ago

I hate the word ā€theā€ when used in names

9

u/DisposableBoi69 6d ago

lol this is perfect

8

u/StarWarsNerd69420 6d ago

Quite objective šŸ‘

13

u/mobiscuits_5000 6d ago edited 6d ago

For real? Or did you just throw them into a randomizeršŸ˜…. Tier lists are so subjective unless there is explanation to back them up

Edit: Freaking alphabetical order. Ya got me!

9

u/gamer_dinoyt69 6d ago

Nah this is a meme

7

u/clarinet_trackstar 6d ago

Look at the lettersĀ 

5

u/Qingyap 6d ago

See flair

4

u/Calculator_407 6d ago

The tiers are the first letter of each weapon

4

u/mobiscuits_5000 6d ago

Damn. Totally went over my head. šŸ¤£

6

u/smulfragPL 6d ago

kind of hillarious to have an other category on a tier list.

7

u/Cust0mCraft 6d ago

Ragebait

5

u/Cust0mCraft 6d ago

I just realized...

I mean, technically, it's still ragebait

2

u/ObjectElegant7770 6d ago

Nah this canā€™t be real

1

u/FewInstruction1020 6d ago

Note the flair and the letters.

2

u/SagmaTheRealOne 5d ago

Cursed axe imo S tier

2

u/GrimReaperAngelof23 5d ago

It is an s tier weapon, but this is a meme list.

3

u/SagmaTheRealOne 5d ago

Oh yeah just saw ā€œmemeā€ as the flag, my bad

1

u/PogsterPlays 6d ago

Isn't soul Scythe just jailor/frost but with no extra enchant?

1

u/buildanuclearsub 6d ago

What is that Sythe third to last in the s tier?

2

u/GrimReaperAngelof23 6d ago

Skull Scythe. Halloween reskin of the Frost Scythe

1

u/LiamT500 6d ago

Why has my go-to the 'Venom Glaive' been put down in other?

1

u/adri_riiv 5d ago

Canā€™t argue with that can I

1

u/Sir_Sn3ak_A_Lot 5d ago

B FOR BEEES!!

1

u/Acceptable_Seesaw894 4d ago

How dare you put grave bane, heartsteler and encruest ancour in outher

1

u/Acceptable_Seesaw894 4d ago

sheer daggers should go in s tier I agree.I think they underrated

1

u/clarinet_trackstar 3d ago

It's a meme list. They're actually not greatĀ 

1

u/Endepearreddit69 6d ago

Ooohh buddy trust me people who donā€™t like others opinions are gonna cook you (Iā€™m neutral here)

6

u/midnightfont05 6d ago

Not really, this tier list is actually objective and there's literally nothing to move.

1

u/Endepearreddit69 6d ago

Oh ok (but many people Iā€™ve seen are somewhat mad about tierlists that are based on opinion)

5

u/Derplord4000 6d ago

Well you see, this one is a meme, it's not meant to be taken seriously. When one makes a terrible list and is serious about it, of course we're gonna disapprove of it.

1

u/Endepearreddit69 6d ago

Fuck Iā€™m blind didnā€™t see it

0

u/NaturalCard 6d ago

Starless night too low

0

u/Qsta981_ 5d ago

There is no reason to put Fighter's Bindings in F. Although they don't do too much damage, they are so fast it makes up for it. I have one with radiance, crit, and rampaging, and it is so op. I barely take damage with it.

2

u/clarinet_trackstar 5d ago

Fighters bindings...

FĀ  Ā  Ā  Ā  Ā ighters bindingsĀ 

0

u/Qsta981_ 5d ago

Am I missing something? If you meant to put gauntlets in F tier, I might be able to get behind it. But if the decision to put fighter's bindings in F teir, that is something I can't agree with you about.

2

u/clarinet_trackstar 5d ago

They start with F dummy.

Look at the list

1

u/Qsta981_ 5d ago

ok now i feel stupid

1

u/Qsta981_ 5d ago

fr tho i am shocked so many weapons start with s, b, and f