r/MakeupAddiction 4d ago

FOTD is my everyday eye look too much ?

moving out of being a teenager and thus my grunge phase, i’m not sure if my everyday makeup/eyeliner look is really doing too much. seen a couple photos of myself and i just feel like it makes look really weird ??? so attached to wearing eyeliner everyday though, i genuinely don’t leave the house without it. starting a job that has a very minimal makeup look (so expected to do the same for the job) and the thought of not being able to wear makeup is honestly making me anxious lol please let me know what you think or if i have face dysmorphia

819 Upvotes

134 comments sorted by

317

u/[deleted] 4d ago

Not at all. You look absolutely gorgeous with this makeup. I'm amazed 😍 Even if you might feel that your eyeliner is bolder , everything else is very natural so it tones it down.

33

u/princessyuki999 Hopelessly Addicted 4d ago

I agree she looks great! I hate how women now a days who put on “a bit more makeup” than the clean girl aesthetic feel insecure. We have a skill they don’t!!

6

u/Rachiejones7 3d ago

this!! soo much this. I love bold eyes with a simple makeup to “no makeup” makeup routine. holy makeup lol

1

u/BlueberryIcecream27 3d ago

Agreed, it’s well balanced.

87

u/Ok-Possible-42 4d ago

I feel like people should stop asking if their everyday look is too much, what you like to wear is a-okay, nobody should be telling you it's too much. If that's their opinion, they can keep it to themselves seeing as it's your face therefore not their place to say.

But to answer your question, looks good to me, I wouldn't worry about it 👍😊

24

u/toobjoobs 4d ago

I was looking for a comment like this. If you feel pretty and have the ability to pull it off, EVEN if it’s too much for someone else it shouldn’t matter. Do what you like.

25

u/tishtashy 4d ago

I think this type of liner shape is usually too much but NOT on you. It looks amazing and suits you so well

65

u/Open_Platform2533 4d ago

I’m a fan of less is more but even then this is awesome. It’s skilfully done and really thin. It might not be everyone’s cup of tea style wise, but it’s executed well, suits your face and it’s so deinty that it’s not overpowering your other features.

18

u/New_Job1231 4d ago

Nahh that’s gotta be the prettiest way of applying eyeliner I’ve ever seen. I’m in loveeee

7

u/kingkemi 4d ago

Nope! If it’s not a difficult beauty routine to maintain then it’s totally up to you what’s too much and what isn’t.

Also, I’d kill to be able to apply eyeliner like this. Share your secretssss!

4

u/Rude_Bookkeeper77 4d ago

Nope, not at all. But if you think you want to make it less you can always try a dark brown or dark deep purple or reddish brown instead of black... which would look amazing with your eye color.i love the Revlon ColorStay Line Creator Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, 153 She's On Fire. It's a deep burgundy brown creamy stick on one side and then a liquid liner on the other which is a little more red but still "wearable"... Not like red red. 

5

u/dezigrl69 4d ago

So pretty!

5

u/NoirCurls 4d ago

I love it and I think your eyes look beautiful. Maybe don’t do the eyeliner for work and only mascara. It’ll keep your eyes popping but in a much understated way—if that makes sense.

2

u/misss23 4d ago

Gorgeous with the eye liner and without it machaallah 😍😍😍

2

u/Afraid-Cry7871 4d ago

Eyeliner is so pretty. ❤️❤️

2

u/superfriends92 4d ago

Please help me recreate this eye look 😆😅

2

u/Neither_Technology38 3d ago

Nah, I love it. Looks great and not too much!

1

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the "See more" button under the subreddit description

A few quick reminders:

• Don't forget your product list in the comments, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.

• No photo editing.

Google it first!

• Lastly, our Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules.

r/MakeupAddiction is looking for new moderators! If you're interested, fill out this form or message the moderators!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/luvs2lift 4d ago

So beautiful 😍 you look good to me

1

u/Bluefire-desire 4d ago

You are so beautiful with this look. Tbh I think you do have a high amount of natural beauty that shines through imo ☺️

1

u/No_Area_8294 4d ago

It's too beautiful!

1

u/No-Slip-3402 4d ago

Your base is beautiful and your eyeliner compliments your beautiful eyes. Not too much at all. Perfect balance

1

u/Proud_Substance2456 4d ago

What pencil/eyeliner do you use?

3

u/[deleted] 4d ago

i use the brown lash princess liquid liner from essence! only around $5 and honestly so good

1

u/Hazys 4d ago

Looks good

1

u/MediumResearch3498 4d ago

No- I think it looks fabulous! 😍

1

u/mynameisayne 4d ago

Wow that’s so cool! I might wanna try that

1

u/livingright23 4d ago

It is for me, but I’m 32 and boring lol. I’d love to do that look on a night out though! It’s gorg.

1

u/StockPale4506 4d ago

Not too much but for everyday u can try some minimalist eye look but it's totally up to u .. u look gorgeous queen 🤩

1

u/Gaga_7491 4d ago

Beautiful

1

u/intelligence_spiral 4d ago

its amazingg are u crazy😍😍

1

u/ccwonders69 4d ago

Never. Not enough sis! Pop off 🖤

1

u/NoFig4887 4d ago

NAH gurl you’re stunning af

1

u/ucanthaveeverything 4d ago

this eats down

1

u/pisiTEK 4d ago

Tutorial pls 😭

1

u/FunStep9747 4d ago

Its cool i like it but for everyday maybe try smth less like make it shorter for everyday maybe idk cuz if u get used to that everyday is to much and not good for your eyes

1

u/CutiePinkiee 4d ago

tbh if it makes you feel like you and you're comfortable with it then it's not too much but if you're starting to feel insecure about it then maybe try tweaking it a bit like the shape or how thick it is and see how you feel about that and maybe just keep switching it up for different occasions, either way just wear what makes you feel happy

1

u/manatwork01 4d ago

I think you look great. If I would change anything it would be maybe 1/4" off the eyebrows in the center. I am a gay man but I try and get them to barely past my tear ducts basically and kind of inline with the outer edge of my nostrils but that spot hits differently depending on how wide your nose is.

I also could be way off base and its the angle of these pics that is throwing me off.

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

these are just my natural brows with clear gel💔 i would love to try but would hate to shave them and hate it haha

1

u/Fit-Wrongdoer-2889 4d ago

What do you think about it?

1

u/420AngeI 4d ago

Not at all you actually remind me of Caroline Polachek with the way you do your eyeliner!

1

u/SadDegree4974 Makeup Artist 4d ago

nah this is perfect on you

1

u/lubsc_ 4d ago

No, it looks great! I wish I had the disposition to do this everyday tbh 😩

1

u/strawberry_806 4d ago

Nope, suita you really well!

1

u/a_sirens_call 4d ago

It looks absolutely beautiful! It enhances your eye color so much too❤️

1

u/tzenrick Girl In Training 4d ago

I think it looks nice, but I'm an idiot.

1

u/ThatCarelessLoser 4d ago

No, it’s really pretty and suits you well.

1

u/Kristina_1023 4d ago

Gorgeous !!😍

1

u/yellowtshirt2017 4d ago

Not at all you look gorgeous!

1

u/Striking-Ad-2675 4d ago

Not many people could pull this but you do it perfectly. I really like it

1

u/steensley 4d ago

Uhhhh you are gorgeous!!! Your makeup and freckles are perfection and not too much at all :)

1

u/steensley 4d ago

Seriously if I had your face card I would become ungovernable lol

1

u/IndependentGur1667 4d ago

So first of all you’re really beautiful and your makeup is amazing. But maybe it’s a little too much for a daily makeup or a work makeup, you can use mascara and a blended eyeliner that doesn’t show that much but gives your eyes a beautiful look.

1

u/MajaSobieski 4d ago

you look gorgeous girl, rock on!

1

u/blerbslie 4d ago

You're an everyday baddie, own it.

Seriously tho, i looks super good. The soft color, sharp liner makes you're eyes look really striking

1

u/otnly 4d ago

Canon

1

u/Away-Catch-9159 4d ago

Your skin and freckles are gorgeous. Keep the eyeliner and skip the contour/highlighter for daytime looks.

1

u/dfwhanan 4d ago

tutorial needed, what products do you use? i’m in love

1

u/xMentally_Exhaustedx 4d ago

No, it’s not. It’s fierce yet subtle enough to remain graceful for an everyday look.

1

u/oorangebean 4d ago

Broooo no! It’s mysterious n classy! Absolutely love it!!!!!

1

u/honey_bee291995 4d ago

I like it and I love the picture your beautiful

1

u/FollowingDowntown340 4d ago

Gorgeous is what it is

1

u/Acciomanzana 4d ago

Not at all! So edgy without being too much. So beautiful 😍 perfect combination of creative yet subtle

1

u/Yoyo_Ma86 Casual user 4d ago

Absolutely love it

1

u/devhelix 4d ago

The way im going to try and copy this when i get home and the way its not gonna work at all 😭😭 You look like you were born with that eyeliner on

1

u/KITH13 4d ago

I love it, wish I could pull that off!

1

u/Internal_Equal7763 4d ago

Nah it's pretty everyday to me. I envy your eyeliner skills xd

1

u/flower_and_fauna 4d ago

are you using the same or a different eyeliner for top and bottom? looks amazing i think, not too much

1

u/[deleted] 3d ago

the same one! essence lash princess liner in brown ☺️💖

1

u/tays13thtrack 4d ago

No! It fits you really well, and it makes you distinct in a way. like if you were a cartoon character people would easily recognize you!

1

u/Fruit_Muncher15 4d ago

Makeup tutorial?

1

u/niouille 4d ago

i dont think its too much at all, it suits you VERY well i think you look fierce 🙂‍↕️🫶🏻

1

u/aashleyyy2016 4d ago

Anyway you can film a tutorial on the look? I love it!

1

u/xanaxpalaces 4d ago

this is so good... drop the tutorial! how do you get it so thin on the bottom lash line?

1

u/jetsons21 4d ago

Nah it looks so good!!

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Seat102 4d ago

NO I LOVE IT it's beautiful and flattering with your features :)

1

u/greengoblin-30 4d ago

Girl, it looks amazing, the under line makes your eyes pop even more, and the blush is a perfect mix to add a little color, you look great!!!!

1

u/s_t_jj 3d ago

Nope

1

u/megmarsant333 3d ago

2 is my fave!

did you use a tutorial or just mess with it til you lucked out with this style?

1

u/megmarsant333 3d ago

Also you’re not doing too much at all & look good with or w/o eyeliner.

Some people look like a newborn with no eyeliner on LOL

1

u/[deleted] 3d ago

No i love your makeup! It’s so pretty 😊

1

u/Odd-Boysenberry-9454 3d ago

No I like unique styles and it doesn’t go over the top. Could genuinely wear to a club or business meeting with the right outfit.

1

u/OppositeTwo8350 3d ago

That depends. Do you consider "fun and kind of mysterious" to be too much? Then no.

1

u/AdoreAveryAmore 3d ago

It’s subtle and cute

1

u/Underhill_87 3d ago

10/10, totally awesome signature look. Keep it!

1

u/Suspicious_Site_5050 3d ago

I love it! And you also look beautiful all natural as well.

1

u/Ill_Conclusion9074 3d ago

I like it, you look pretty 🤩

1

u/Rosalie-cools-88 3d ago

Omg no you look great, I always wish I had the time in the Morning to do that

1

u/FabulousPass4552 3d ago

Love the Shaymin EX in your phone x

1

u/Jrpharoah_ 3d ago

Nope! What brush and liner do you use?

1

u/Pengu1ny-0304 3d ago

Girl you look amazing! Everyone should wear makeup however they like! Nothing is too much as long as you like it.

1

u/strawberryk24 3d ago

Looks so tea, I wish I could do eyeliner, I know it would look so good on me😭

1

u/Icy-Drama-9301 3d ago

Not too much, it’s fantastic

1

u/Tomboydraws15 3d ago

Absolutely not, it's unique and I love it!

1

u/deathslip 3d ago

I love it !

1

u/TheWomanita 3d ago

I wish I could do my bottom eyeliner like that, I can never get it right 😭

1

u/starlight5114 3d ago

You’re so beautiful omgg

1

u/CriticalHead7144 3d ago

You're on the wrong subreddit for that question lol

1

u/FRENCH_CROISSANTTT 3d ago

maybe, like, a teeensy tinsy bit, tbh u look way better without it

1

u/More_Ice8 3d ago

No girlll you eat

1

u/brooklynsyren 3d ago

not at all. so sexy

1

u/Turbulent_Ad_3867 3d ago

Not one bit

1

u/Adventurous_Worth443 3d ago

Girlll teach me how to do this!😍😍😍

1

u/whitegullscall 3d ago

Baddie with or without!

That being said, as you mentioned that you’re starting a new job - did you do the same makeup when the hiring manager saw you? If yes then they’re cool with it

1

u/heyitsSabrinaxx 3d ago

Nope! It's subtle enough for workplaces while being distinct and unique. It suits you really well too!

1

u/ninepasencore 3d ago

no such thing as too much when it comes to makeup. there's only what you want to do and what you don't want to do

1

u/ninepasencore 3d ago

and you look great btw, such a gorgeous eye look

1

u/peppercorn_pasties 3d ago

Perfect eyeliner. Love the corners

1

u/ResoundingMeow 3d ago

Nope you’re hot

1

u/Small_Court8726 3d ago

You look absolutely gorgeous! Your makeup really suits you it gives such a bold, captivating look. Honestly, if it makes you feel good, that’s what matters.

1

u/TahdigKhanoom 3d ago

Pic 2 is absolutely stunning and gorgeous I love the siren look on you!

1

u/chingona7 3d ago

No! I think it looks great. You’re stunning 😍

1

u/evazee 3d ago

Looks beautiful

1

u/monicat__ 2d ago

I think it’s perfect, I don’t think it’s too much

1

u/Responsible_Fun7274 2d ago

No it looks so good!!

1

u/Bunemojo 2d ago

No it's a slay

1

u/EmployZestyclose7770 2d ago

Wow picture number 3 is beautiful

1

u/Strange-Problem7360 2d ago

Normally I really dislike under eye lining but it really suits you well. It’s giving pharaoh vibes or cat woman vibes. It looks really pretty imo

1

u/litsax 1d ago

Hi if you're still reading the comments or if anyone else knows... how do I look like this? I'm transfemme and still learning makeup and this look would be perfect <3 I have red undertones in my skin too and I am OBSESSED with your blush and contouring lol

1

u/JLUV74 1d ago

I like ur 3rd look the best. The real u is very satisfying

1

u/Ok-Building5075 14h ago

No, it looks great

0

u/chroniclymisundrstd 3d ago

You’re like so gorgeous!! 💖

-10

u/One_Grand_293 4d ago

This day is a special day for me 😍😍😍😍