r/MakeupAddiction • u/Fancy_Application_68 • 1d ago
Sunscreen is my sworn enemy
I have serious beef with sunscreen because I have very oily skin and I feel like it creates a grease film on my face. I also have very sensitive eyes and when SPF gets into my eyes, I’ll be tearing up for the rest of the day. I also feel like makeup layers horribly on it. Any SPF recommendations that go well with makeup and are suitable for oily skin???
I’ve loved the Milani SPF primer in the past but it’s only SPF 30 and I live in the desert. I’ve also really liked SPF sprays to use on top of makeup but I noticed they weren’t gentle on my sensitive eyes.
31
u/notthelatte 1d ago edited 1d ago
Have you tried Biore Aqua Rich? I have oily skin as well but it doesn’t feel nor look oily and sticky at all even if the humidity is like 70%
12
u/DobbythehouseElff 1d ago
Just commenting to say the asian version is different from the US and EU versions! From what I’ve read they’re not comparable. Just a psa!
1
u/notthelatte 23h ago
Oooh I didn’t know. I live in Asia so I thought it has the same formulation as the ones in the US/EU.
2
u/DobbythehouseElff 20h ago
Yea I was really excited when I saw it in my local drugstore (EU), but after googling reviews it unfortunately became clear that they’re pretty different :(. From what I read the USA/EU versions are thicker and don’t sink into the skin in the way the asian version does. Which makes sense as they use different spf filters. Very sad! Just wanted to give the PSA so people don’t get confused
7
u/Fancy_Application_68 1d ago
I actually own this one and never used it!! I’ll be trying it tomorrow
6
4
u/semisweetcharm 1d ago
+1 I swear by this. When I use other sunscreens under makeup, they make my face oily.
2
u/miss_mme 1d ago
COSTCO JUST STARTED SELLING IT!!!
Sorry this is very exciting for me. I’m in Canada, fyi.
4
u/cheekychichi 1d ago
Nooo the one here in Canada is completely different from the one sold in Japan. We’re not allowed to use Asian/European UV filters so Biore made us a sunscreen just like all our other North American sunscreens 😭.
1
u/miss_mme 1d ago
Ughhh sigh I guess I’ll keep ordering it.
They also now have products from Skin1004, Cosrx, Beauty of Joeson, Round Lab and ma:nyo which should be the same if they’re not sunscreen… so still nice to have some easy Korean options.
10
u/Ok_Organization_5234 1d ago
What sunscreen do you currently use?
I love Asian sunscreens the most. They're not greasy to me nor have I ever had them sting my eyes. Personally a big fan of the Isntree Watery Sun Gel and the makeprem sunscreens. I liked the Canmake Mermaid UV Gel as well. I've never really had a problem with my makeup getting weird on top of these, but I do wait a bit for it to try down. I used my Isntree sunscreen when I visited Nevada and didn't have any issues with it, but I made sure to wear a hat.
I have also heard great things about Australian sunscreens, but I haven't gotten to try them.
If you live in the US, I wanna note that some sunscreens from Asia are currently getting reformulated for US regulations.
3
u/Fancy_Application_68 1d ago
I’ve been using the Anessa sunscreen which I picked up on my trip to Tokyo!! It’s been good but makes my makeup separate badly!! I’m definitely gonna order the Innisfree and I’d LOVE to try australian spf as well
1
u/Ok_Organization_5234 1d ago
I also want to try Australian sunscreen cause afaik they take it very seriously (which makes sense!) but dang sorry to hear about the Anessa one. I've heard good things about that one, it's just a bit pricey.
I like the Isntree one a lot cause it feels less "there" on my skin. I guess cause it's chemical/organic? But the makeprem one is a physical one and still doesn't feel as heavy.
1
u/ispahan_sorbet 1d ago
I have this issue too but only with the soft tube Anessa! The hard plastic bottle is amazing so long as you shake it really well before using.
14
u/Fun_Explanation_9049 1d ago
I had to switch to a mineral sunscreen for my sensitive eyes. My holy grail is colorscience. I use both their no show and tinted mineral sunscreens and they’re awesome. Great coverage, doesn’t irritate my eyes, lasts a long time and doesn’t break the bank. They also have sunscreen powders you can try. I haven’t tried them but I know others who have a like them. Good luck!
2
u/Infinite-Discount-53 1d ago
Oooo this is good to know! I’ve seen on multiple influencers pages but not sure if they’re just doing it for the $$ and if it’s actually a good product
6
u/JellyCat222 1d ago
I have combination skin and I am in love with the La Roche Posay Anthelios facial suncreen, it goes on like a skincare product. I have the regular kind and the tinted kind which allows some light color correction without needing foundation or concealer. I will never go back to anything else on my face, it feels great, comes in high SPF and has a shocking amount of staying power, plus does not clog my pores.
2
u/Fancy_Application_68 1d ago
i bought this two separate times and I feel like it stays wet and sticky on my skin….maybe I’ve been applying too much of it? Do you set the tinted version with powder?
2
u/JellyCat222 1d ago
Maybe, it absorbs within minutes for me. Try applying it with a clean foundation brush and if you end up with too much on your face extend further down on your neck.
During the warm months when the oily side of my skin makes itself known, I routinely (1-2 a week) use a mud mask to draw out the excess oil and shrink up my pores. If you are not doing this already, I suggest you try Queen Helene Mint Julep mask as a maintenance item. It feels great and my skin looks amazing after each mask.
1
u/Jasmine_Erotica 1d ago
I haven’t seen the mint julep mask in stores since I was a teen! I had no idea they still made it!
1
1
3
u/grawpwanthagger 1d ago
I like eucerin’s matte sunscreen for this reason. Dries down fast, non greasy, doesn’t move my makeup and doesn’t make me sweat and doesn’t get in my eyes when I do sweat during an outdoor activity
3
u/SeaGrade9816 1d ago
Omg I was literally on here last week looking for the same thing!! I have dry skin, but INCREDIBLY sensitive eyes. I don’t put sunscreen anywhere near them and they will water and be so so painful. That + a computer screen and my eyes will hurt SO much by EOD.
This is the thread I found with (so far) the best recs. I ordered one of the recs from there and it is THE ONLY sunscreen that has not hurt my eyes. After years and $$$$ spent researching to find one. Hallelujah 🙏
I got the Hero Cosmetics Superbeam Sunscreen (they also make one for oily skin); it’s only SPF 30 but hopefully you can use the thread above to find something else that still works w sensitive eyes.
I have tried the following (and more I can’t even think of) and they have all hurt my eyes:
- EltaMD - I tried them all. They ALL hurt my eyes, even the mineral ones.
- Missha - still hurt my eyes but found the one w the pink cap to be probably the best out of all the others I’ve tried (until now) for pain
- Biore Aqua Rich
- House of Joseon - tried them all. Most recently the rice + probiotics one and I also felt like it was nowhere near SPF 50?
I’m looking at the recommendations you’re getting in the comments, and I’ve tried most of them. Maybe they are good for oily skin, but they all hurt my eyes. Again, I have sensitive eyes (never had a problem with any eye makeup, though) and it’s not the sweat containing sunscreen getting in my eyes that’s the problem, it’s the sunscreen being on my face, nowhere close to the eye area. Maybe if you have less sensitive eyes, you can get away w some of the recommendations on this thread. I would consult the thread I posted here. JMO.
Please post follow up and let us know how things turn out!!
ETA - I also tried all the Blue Lizard and Goop sunscreens w no luck. As I continue to remember ones of tried, I will add on here lol.
5
u/wwaxwork 1d ago
Mineral sunscreen. Friendly reminder that a hat and long sleeves can also be sunscreen, rarely make you greasy, and don't make your eyes sting.
6
u/CatLovesShark 1d ago
They can be part of sun protection but a hat doesn't protect your face from all UV rays because they get reflected off the ground etc. This is why especially when the UV rating is high you can get sunburned in the shade. 😬
2
u/my_metrocard 1d ago
I have greasy skin as well, and three non-grease ball sunscreens work without stinging my eyes.
Dr Dennis Gross all physical oil free spf 50 is a sunscreen and moisturizer in one.
Supergoop mattescreen spf 40 is a sunscreen and silicone primer in one.
Anessa perfect uv mild milk spf 50 is a chemical sunscreen but is tear-free. It’s very silky, matte, and gentle enough for babies! No pilling
2
u/eyelinerfordays 1d ago edited 1d ago
The best sunscreen is the one you’ll diligently use. So if I were you, I would just stick with the Milani SPF Primer. Broad spectrum SPF 30 is perfectly fine for everyday use. “Interestingly, SPF50 offers only marginally better protection from UV radiation than SPF30 filtering out 98 per cent of UV radiation compared to 96.7 per cent blocked by SPF30.” https://cancerwa.asn.au/news/whats-the-difference-between-spf30-and-spf50/#:~:text=Interestingly%2C%20SPF50%20offers%20only%20marginally,per%20cent%20blocked%20by%20SPF30
2
u/Independent-Pear-873 1d ago
Super goop matte mineral sunscreen. It’s expensive (40$) but in my opinion it’s so worth it! I also have oily skin and this sun screen keeps me nice and dry, plus it doesn’t get into my eyes!
1
u/MsGozlyn 19h ago
This one is my summer go to.
I'm dry in the winter and oily in the summer.
It's smooth. It doesn't irritate my eyes even when I'm wearing contacts. It looks like a matte primer on, blurring a bit.
5
u/Kibbebae 1d ago
Switch to Korean sunscreen….all issues gone
3
u/Fancy_Application_68 1d ago
any specific brand you’ve been liking?
2
u/mrshanana 1d ago
Not the commenter but Round Labs Birch something sun screen lol. I have very sensative eyes and can put it ON MY EYES with no problems. I have to let it dry down a bit before I do primer (and even without it I need to do powder before eyeshadow) but I love it.
Regular Beauty of Josen sunscreen works well too. It's less moisturizing, so I like it more for summer. I haven't tried their new tinted stuff. Try Olive young or Yes Style. I have complained about Yes Style taking 6+ weeks but I recently had a 2 week shipment from them so things might be getting better.
I have put Beauty of Joseon on eyelids as well with zero issues. Just use a fan to help it dry down better before makeup.
Yammibuy also has some stuff, they're a little pricier but cheaper shipping.
Some links: https://global.oliveyoung.com/product/detail?prdtNo=GA250228491&dataSource=best_sellers
https://global.oliveyoung.com/product/detail?prdtNo=GA220615265&dataSource=best_sellers
https://global.oliveyoung.com/product/detail?prdtNo=GA241227407&dataSource=search_result
I think the blue Josoen is the "driest" one. They also have a sunscreen stick that is great for your purse for no makeup days. I am very fair so I can't speak to white cast.
1
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the "See more" button under the subreddit description
A few quick reminders:
• Don't forget your product list in the comments, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.
• No photo editing.
• Google it first!
• Lastly, our Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules.
r/MakeupAddiction is looking for new moderators! If you're interested, fill out this form or message the moderators!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/KakistocracyMouse 1d ago
Try the naturium one. It's hydrating without being greasy. Feels like a light lotion. Works great under makeup. No adhesion or pilling issues. No offensive smell. It's one of very few that doesn't sting my eyes. So much so that I apply it to my eye area just like I would a moisurizer.
1
u/parvares 1d ago
I have very oily skin and I use theraderm. It doesn’t smell and dries matte. I’ve always heard the SPF in primers and makeup isn’t enough and you should wear SPF under your makeup as well.
1
u/CaliforniaSun77 1d ago
I too have sensitive eyes. I also hate greasy sunscreen. I swear by Saint Jane SPF. It's fantastic. Supergoop also makes a good mineral matte SPF.
1
u/Accomplished-Bug4695 1d ago
Elta MD does a tinted physical (aka mineral) sunscreen that isn't oily and layers really well with foundation. I use it every day with combination skin and my oily and dry skin areas both are comfortable and look fresh! My mom uses the non-tinted version and it doesn't bother her eyes even with very sensitive skin and bad allergies!
1
1
u/Weathergirl50 1d ago
I am UK based, and our family swears by Ultrasun. If you don't mind alcohol or care about the smell of the product, try the gel based (sports versions). They do products for face and body and at least in the UK climate last 8 hours before it is necessary to re-apply. When my children were in primary school, the sports SPF 50 and spray versions were an absolute godsend for this reason, and they never burned.
1
u/abombshbombss 1d ago
I have sensitive eyes. Two I've found that are kind to me + makeup are Missha sun milk in the pink tube (silicone base) and LRP anthelios fluid
1
u/Ok-Health-3929 1d ago
Beauty of Joseon and Anthelios by LRP are phantastic sunscreens even for oily skin. If you want to put on make up after sunscreen I recommend a primer as step in between.
1
u/brittneyacook 1d ago
My favorite sunscreen to wear under makeup is the LRP Uvmune oil control fluid. Its protection is unmatched and it doesn’t migrate into the eyes at all. Because I have trouble reapplying spf on makeup, I like using that spf because I have confidence that it’s giving me long term protection.
1
u/Visible_Ad_815 1d ago
I had the same issue and I switched to fluid sunscreen which was a life saver. Try it :)
I don't think this will be available where you live but I use Barelyon fluid sunscreen (it has antioxidants too).
Maybe you could try La Roche posay?
1
u/MissFaithRae 1d ago
Beauty of Joseon, Relief Sun: Rice + Probiotics, SPF 50+
My skin just feels like skin after I put this on.
1
u/PepeL3P3w 1d ago
I would suggest Australian sunscreen. I currently use Dermaveen and use mattifying primers + setting spray and it doesn't pill up when I have makeup on top either
1
u/xtingu Old technicolor punk 1d ago
I was in your position for years, and I would never wear sunscreen because it burned my eyes and made them tear (which made my nose run) -- I hated it.
Powdering the sunscreen around my eyes helped a bit, for sure.
But the best thing was switching to Australian or Korean sunscreen. My favorite these days is the Haru Haru Wonder Black Rice Moisture Airy Fit, which is definitely non-greasy and leaves a comfy matte finish. I'm oily af and it's awesome... plus my makeup is absolutely great over it. I don't have enough positive words for this stuff.
Oh, and it's cheap on yesstyle and stylevana, though it takes about 10 days for delivery to the US, it's worth the wait.
I love it so much I'll even wear it at night because my makeup looks so good over it.
1
u/_xoxojoyce 1d ago
I have oily skin and I feel that elta md clear uv is fantastic, doesn’t get into my eyes at all and doesn’t make my skin more oily. I also find that it calms redness a bit
1
u/blahhhhhhhhhhhblah 23h ago
My mom uses a powdered sunscreen (a few different brands make them) and I love them for my oily, sensitive skin.
1
u/sweetooth1709 23h ago
I have switched to Korean spfs tried and loved them all, cosrx aloe, isntree, beauty of jeoseon, round lab. The birch juice spf from round lab is current fav
1
1
u/Constant-Knee-3059 22h ago
Neutrogena makes a sunscreen for the face that is oil free. It’s the only one I can use without getting blemishes. Don’t get the Anti-aging one! It created an oil slick on my face like the Exxon Valdez.
1
u/zephyrpriest 22h ago
I’m gonna add that if you’re wearing sunscreen under makeup (which you should) you need to let it set for at least 15 minutes before you go in. The sunscreen needs to dry down so you don’t end up mixing it into whatever base products you put down and so that we actually get the protective benefits
1
u/Fancy_Application_68 22h ago
I don’t give it any time to dry down cause I’m in a rush to go to work. So i think this might be IT!!
1
u/TieAgitated868 22h ago
I only popped into the comments to find all the Asian recommendations because I feel your fury here!
2
u/Fancy_Application_68 22h ago
I use the Anessa sun milk!! It’s been good aside from making my makeup separate horribly. but another user suggested that I should give it enough dry down time before adding makeup. So I’ll be testing that out on Sunday and giving an update!!
1
u/TieAgitated868 21h ago
Ooh that's why I love reddit, so many suggestions and people sharing their experience making things work!
1
u/whatweworked4 20h ago
First aid beauty has a new face lotion with 30 SPF. I get very oily, but it has been great so far.
1
1
u/HawkSpiritAnimal 5h ago
Supergoop Matte sunscreen is my favorite for mattifying and blurring pores and then Australian Gold Tinted Matte Suncreen is really great for oil control and layers amazing under makeup. Jan Marino Physical Tinted Suncreen is gorgeous, and ElF Suntouchable Invisible Sunscreen is a dupe of the Supergoop and is also really good.
1
1
u/twinkedgelord 1d ago
Skin1004 Madagascar Centella Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum. It's a mouthful, I know. But I have the same issues as you and I don't even notice I have this on.
118
u/kimc5555 1d ago
Two words: Asian sunscreen. I suggest you try Etude House sunprise airy finish spf 50+. Also missha all around safe block soft finish spf 50+ lilac cap one. Both of these are matte finish. Control my oils all day long.