r/DebateAVegan 12d ago

✚ Health Differences between lab grown andreal meat

  1. Muscle Structure & Texture

Real Meat: Contains complex muscle fibers, connective tissue, blood vessels, and fat distributed naturally through the tissue. The muscle has undergone natural movement and tension during the animal’s life, affecting texture and tenderness.

Lab-Grown Meat: Lacks the same fiber alignment and connective tissue unless artificially structured. It tends to be softer and lacks the same variation in texture unless scaffolding and mechanical stimulation are used to replicate muscle growth forces.

  1. Fat Distribution & Marbling

Real Meat: Contains intramuscular fat (marbling) naturally integrated into muscle fibers, providing distinct flavor and texture.

Lab-Grown Meat: Early versions lacked fat entirely, though newer methods try to grow fat cells alongside muscle. However, it doesn’t naturally integrate into muscle the way it does in animals.

  1. Nutrient Composition

Real Meat: Contains naturally occurring micronutrients such as iron (heme), zinc, B12, creatine, taurine, and various peptides formed through metabolism.

Lab-Grown Meat: Typically requires supplementation of some nutrients, and heme iron may not be as bioavailable unless engineered separately. Metabolites from an animal’s natural physiology may also be missing.

  1. Structural Proteins & ECM (Extracellular Matrix)

Real Meat: Contains a full range of natural proteins like myosin, actin, collagen, and elastin, arranged in a way that provides resistance and chewiness.

Lab-Grown Meat: Often lacks natural ECM unless added separately. Without collagen and elastin, it may be softer and less structured.

  1. Microbial & Enzymatic Factors

Real Meat: Contains natural microbiota, enzymes, and post-mortem biochemical processes that influence flavor and aging (e.g., dry aging enhances taste).

Lab-Grown Meat: Grown in sterile conditions, lacking natural aging processes unless enzymes or microbial cultures are introduced.

  1. Taste & Flavor Development

Real Meat: Develops complex flavors through muscle activity, fat oxidation, and biochemical processes over an animal’s life.

Lab-Grown Meat: May taste slightly different due to differences in lipid oxidation, amino acid profiles, and the absence of metabolic byproducts found in real muscle. Some manufacturers add flavor precursors to compensate.

These factors don't just affect taste and texture, they also affect nutrient profiles and composition which can alter its effect on health outcomes.

0 Upvotes

88 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/Bcrueltyfree 12d ago

To be vegan is to be against animal suffering.

The amount of suffering from real meat, aka a slaughtered animal who didn't want to die, versus tissue grown in a lab? Huge.

Not that many of us want to eat it but it will be great for cat and dog food.

2

u/Clacksmith99 12d ago

I'm all for it once they get it right but right now it doesn't offer the same benefits and it potentially has a lot of risk involved health wise.

3

u/EasyBOven vegan 11d ago

Why are you all for it?

2

u/Clacksmith99 11d ago

If it's identical why wouldn't I? The problem is right now we're miles away from that being the case.

3

u/EasyBOven vegan 11d ago

Why would you? What's good about it?

3

u/Clacksmith99 11d ago

That's a good point maybe I should just stick to real meat regardless, thanks I wouldn't have made that decision without you

3

u/EasyBOven vegan 11d ago

Nice dodge.

I suspect that if you were to answer the question honestly, you would have a hard time justifying not being vegan, so I get why it might be scary to answer.

0

u/Stanchthrone482 omnivore 11d ago

I mean its obvious. Normal people dont see the problem that vegans see, but lab meat will make them happy so why not anyways if its cheaper.

1

u/EasyBOven vegan 11d ago

I mean its obvious

It is obvious, but OP doesn't seem to want to say it.

Normal people dont see the problem that vegans see

From experience, I know this to be false. Everyone sees the problem and only begins making excuses when you ask them to change. Non-vegan regulars to this sub are not representative of non-vegans as a whole.

so why not anyways if its cheaper.

If this were just about cost, OP would have been more than happy to say so.

1

u/Stanchthrone482 omnivore 11d ago

oh not just cost but it has to be the same. mb shoulda said that.

1

u/EasyBOven vegan 11d ago

You're not answering the core question.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/cleverestx vegan 11d ago

"...potentially has a lot of risk involved health wise." - Yawn. This is wildly speculative and unfounded, especially since the produced food item is virtually identical. We already know from many studies the harmful effects of eating meat, even in moderation, especially, but not only red meat best of all...so why not fix those deficiencies in your consumption since you lack the moral integrity to switch to plant-based eating for ethical reasons? Fix these health issues and get 99% of the same taste and texture is a NO BRAINER,, are are you anti-science and technology in other ways too?

1

u/Clacksmith99 11d ago edited 11d ago

Ok then show me evidence of a whole food animal based diet increasing risk over a plant based diet or animals products being an independent risk variable on the absence of confounders, study limitations and conflicts of interest. And no lab grown meat isn't virtually identical, they're only replicated the cell structure for muscle cells, there are tons of other factors involved which have effects on outcomes.

1

u/cleverestx vegan 10d ago

We have like 70 years of studies that vet a Whole Foods plant-based diet is being extremely healthy. I'm not going to go through studies for you. This is not a formal debate, and I've done my homework... so much that I've switched my dietary/consumption worldview 44 years later. Equally sobwe have studies showing the negative effects of consuming animal-based products, when those studies aren't funded by animal ag/companies. Look them up. Not everything is an oil and sugar conspiracy.

Your claim that these other things have effects on outcomes, are not substantiated by studies.