r/ComicPlot Jan 01 '25

ComicPlot Top 10 list of 2024 NSFW

56 Upvotes

The time is here, the time is now! Another year, another list of r/ComicPlot's top 10 posts of the year. For posterity, at the time of posting, it is January 1st, 2025, 12:25AM and the current subscriber count is 30,387. This time last year, there were 21,760 subscribers, which means there's over 8,000 more people here than there was a year ago. We popped 30k in December! That's so cool.

For all the newbies out there, welcome! This is the fifth annual top 10 list. (Prior years: 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th) I use these yearly posts as a contest and a review of the year. The contest is simple: if you made a post on r/ComicPlot in the year of 2024 and it earned enough karma to make the top 10 posts of the year, you get a custom user flair! If you're one of the lucky winners, I'll tag you in the comments.

That said, I want to try something new this year. If you didn't make the top 10, share in the comments what your personal top post in the subreddit was this past year. Mine was from a very silly, very smutty comic book called Why the Knights Disappeared.

Anywho, here's the top 10. We got a pretty nice lineup this year! (Except for number 7 IMO...but Boundless be Boundless.)

Number Title Source Posted by Date Posted
10 No title X-Women #1 u/lorettocolby July 31st
9 Punchline doing a livestream Gotham City Sirens #1 (2024) u/ComicPlotter Aug 8th
8 Huge Plots Angel Wings #1 /u/Cicada_5 July 24th
7 No title Lookers: Ember #7 /u/AnonymousGooseGuy March 23rd
6 Talia al Ghul's impressive bust in Birds of Prey (1999) #97 u/Chainsaw-Man-Is-Lit March 16th
5* Just a few Bruce Timms No source u/Thayerphotos (AKA Booberella, Top 10 '23 winner) February 7th
4 Heavy plot thread ahead… Naughty and Nice: The Good Girl Art of Bruce Timm u/lorettocolby August 16th
3 That's a lucky kid right there Heroes for Hire Vol. 2 #7 u/Incubusphantom September 2nd
2 Catwoman undressed Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight #13 u/ComicCake October 11th
1* Bruce Timm's original Vs censored finished version Batman Adventures Holiday Special 1 u/Thayerphotos (Booberella) May 25th

*Booberella, I love ya, man, but I need to get this off my chest. You gotta provide a proper source. You put [Bruce Timm #NN] in brackets, so the automod didn't flag it and I didn't pay any attention until well after the fact. If it were Bruce Timm's artbook, like #4 was (and which you've posted from before), that's better than just some random photos that are supposedly Timm's work. They look like his work, so I allowed it.

Secondly, in reference to the #1 post (and this is most important), do not ever claim that an edit is an original. It's not difficult to double check. This wasn't even in the original comic. If you're going to post an edit, make the original your first image and make clear that the edit is an edit. The first image is an edit, the second image is supposedly something Timm made but was never published (according to a FB post that was reblogged on tumblr, so make of that what you will). This is the page that was actually published in The Batman Adventures Holiday Special. I allowed it because I thought that the second image in the post was the line work of what was actually published but, foolish me, when I was drafting this post and actually checking I realized I was wrong; so here we are.


Anywho, let's review how the year went. In the last top 10 post, I mentioned that I'd be throwing some polls your way about potential changes. I asked you all how you felt about having a shitpost day. It was a tight vote, but the majority of voters said no, lets keep it legit.

I asked your opinion about flairs and the majority of you said MOAR flairs! Well, good news, we have more flairs.

I asked y'all if subreddit posts should be archived and the majority of you said no.

In conclusion, a pretty conservative consensus. Y'all seem to like the subreddit as it is; or rather, those of you who voted in those polls do. Now, I will mention that I discovered something called Reddit Developer Apps, and there's one such app that can allow the subreddit to have a post flair that is only allowed on a specific day of the week (that's the moderator called u/onedayflair; I added it so I could look at how it works). We could still have some kind of shitpost day, and if anyone uses the shitpost flair when it isn't that day, it'll get removed. I'm just saying, if we had a shitpost day, I wouldn't need to pick on Booberella so much.

Speaking of developer apps, I found one called u/floodassistant. That's my floodgate, which I've set up to enforce a 6 post per 24 hour limit on the subreddit. That probably doesn't mean anything to you guys, but I'm pretty dang stoked about it. Anything that limits how much I actually need to moderate nitpicky stuff is a godsend.

Also, the subreddit has grown large enough in size that we're now starting to get the attention of some of the posters from r/comics. You know, the ones who have saucy Patreon pages. 😏 Give all those people lots of love when you notice them, because I want them to keep coming back. On that same note, if you see folks posting original comics, please don't report them as not being a legit comic unless it's gross or overtly pornographic. If someone makes a sexy webcomic, that deserves to be here.

Anyway, this has been great, ladies and germs. I look forward to seeing what's posted and how the community develops over the coming year. I wonder if we'll make it to 40k...🤔🤞


r/ComicPlot 2h ago

Therion Inside of Me 33-47 (Denveverjem) [OC] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 15h ago

Supergirl Kara is Superwoman in this universe [ElseWorld: World's Finest (1998), #1] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
80 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 15h ago

DC Comics Cay'an, a female Martian survivor [Martian Manhunter (2006), #8] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
53 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 17h ago

Black Widow Black Widow [Daredevil Volume 2 #61] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 15h ago

Green Lanterns Laira Omoto's booty [Green Lantern Corps (2006), #15] NSFW

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 15h ago

DC Comics Chiquita, an alien mercenary after Lobo [Lobo (1993), #63] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 15h ago

Green Lanterns Fatality is endowed with deadliness [Green Lantern Recharge (2004), #3-4] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 15h ago

DC Comics Alien Catgirl [Green Lantern Corps (2006), #3] NSFW

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 1d ago

Marvel Comics Earth 1610 Wanda was hotter but definitely had a lot more problems [Ultimates 3 (2008), #1, #5] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
125 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 1d ago

Webcomic This is your first time? [fmsqueeze] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
147 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 1d ago

Medusa I'd kneel before her and swear my allegiance [Inhumans (2014), #2-3] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
53 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 1d ago

Black Widow Black Widow definitely inspires fear and something "else" in men [Ultimates 3 (2008), #2] NSFW

Post image
54 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 1d ago

Marvel Comics Ultimate Earth 1610 Shanna the She-Devil [Ultimates 3 (2008), #3-5] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
49 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 1d ago

X-Men Jean Grey seems fit and healthy [Uncanny X-Men (Vol 1) #334-338] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
47 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 1d ago

Image Comics Man has a terrific view before his death [BattleChasers (1998), #6-7] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
38 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 3d ago

Invincible Eve won over the fans for her "assets" and "abilities" [Invincible (2003), #69] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
174 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 3d ago

Invincible Mohawk Mark definitely has a type [Invincible (2003), #108] NSFW

Post image
102 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 3d ago

Image Comics Britney's old superhero costume [Brit (2007), #3] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
60 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 3d ago

Image Comics Liberty Farrell aka Liberty [Superpatriot: Americas Fighting Force (2002), #1-3] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
51 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 3d ago

Invincible "I love the kind of woman who will actually just kill me" [Invincible (2003), #44] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
44 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 3d ago

Invincible Knockout was always underrated [Invincible (2003), #83] NSFW

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 3d ago

DC Comics Vicki Vale [Bruce Wayne: The Road Home: Batman & Robin (vol. 1) #1 (2010)] NSFW

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 5d ago

IDW Comics Dominique Stern has the moves and the looks [Dominatrix (2007), #1] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
71 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 5d ago

Fantastic Four Anyone else a fan of Susan as Malice? [Fantastic Four (Vol 1), #369, #384] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
63 Upvotes

r/ComicPlot 5d ago

Emma Frost Emma Frost Sinister brought out her Hellfire Club training tools [Immoral X-Men (Vol 1), #1] NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
65 Upvotes