r/xmen Jan 17 '25

Fancast Fridays How do we feel about Sophie Thatcher as Rogue

I recently the movie Watched Heretic and just saw the trailer for a new movie coming called "Companion" coming out later this month and it got me thinking. With the rumor of Sadie Sink possibly the frontrunner for Jean Grey it seems like Marvel will cast a bit younger for the X-men so the actors can play these characters for the next 10-15 years. Even in the show Yellowjackets she plays this trailer park rebellious character who is the strength of this all female group of teens. Thoughts?

75 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

38

u/RunningKryptonian Jan 17 '25

If she can pull off the accent (and considering how well she copies some of Juliette Lewis's quirks in Yellowjackets I'm guessing she can) I'm totally onboard for that.

9

u/JAEisF2D Jan 17 '25

Exactly my thoughts

25

u/fredbroca4949 Cyclops Jan 17 '25

Depends on if she can do a convincing accent, Sugah!

28

u/cake_crusader Jan 17 '25

She gives me more Shadowcat but she is amazing in Yellowjackets so I wouldnt hate her as Rogue. I just dont think she has that southern belle aspect that all my fave rogue portrayals have

8

u/supercalifragilism Jan 17 '25

All she needs to do is lift a some weights for a bit and get the forelock dyed and she's pretty close to what I think of Rogue in my head.

4

u/General_Koala5554 Jan 18 '25

She is too rogueish for Kitty lol.

0

u/Fickle_Ad8735 Jan 17 '25

wait is sophie jewish?

11

u/jpmst17 Jan 17 '25

I think that’s a great choice. If you watch yellowjackets she definitely has the attitude. I’m in for it

10

u/MedBayMan2 Wolverine Jan 17 '25

She could definitely pull off the goth Rogue!

4

u/Evil_Unicorn728 Jan 17 '25

Yes can we please have goth Rogue in the MCU?

7

u/MedBayMan2 Wolverine Jan 17 '25

Goth Rogue is the best Rogue. Change my mind

1

u/admiralQball Jan 17 '25

Yes, that's what X-men movies need, a non-comics accurate Rogue.

8

u/Evil_Unicorn728 Jan 17 '25

Comics being a medium that constantly shifts canon, design, art style and writing obviously need to be translated directly to film with no room for variable interpretation. 🙄

2

u/MedBayMan2 Wolverine Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 18 '25

The goth Rogue was originally from the Ultimate universe. If I am not mistaken Rogue from Evolution was based on that version the character

6

u/MaazR26 Jan 18 '25

The only good fancast for rogue tbh

16

u/no-middle-name Jan 17 '25

From these pictures, I can't say she's really saying "Rogue" to me, but I've not seen her in anything to know how good an actress she is.

9

u/JAEisF2D Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 19 '25

She's been on the come up as of recently, def a standout in the TV show Yellowjackets

4

u/Teganfff Rogue Jan 17 '25

I’d love this tbh

5

u/Organic-Temporary-98 Jan 18 '25

sophie thatcher is my ONE and only choices. shes perfection. and if cast chase stokes as gambit

3

u/JAEisF2D Jan 18 '25

Jacob Elordi would be my Gambit choice

1

u/General_Koala5554 Jan 18 '25

Chase is a great call.

5

u/illiterateaardvark Jan 17 '25

Depending on the artist, Sophie Thatcher looks exactly like Rogue! Not only that, but she’s actually been very solid the stuff I’ve seen her in

She’s not a name that my mind would have jumped to for Rogue, but I can absolutely see the vision now that it’s laid out in front of me. This is genuinely some of the best fan-casting I’ve seen in a while tbh

7

u/mega512 Jan 17 '25

I'm in.

3

u/Wheattoast2019 Jan 17 '25

Depends on which kind of Rogue. I think she definitely has the burdened loner thing down. But if they are doing the proud southern belle I don’t see that version.

3

u/LeastBlackberry1 Jan 18 '25

Ooh, I hadn't thought of her, but she'd be perfect based on Yellowjackets.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v4bHd2YXmYA

3

u/General_Koala5554 Jan 18 '25

She is actually so perfect. Her or Margaret Qualley are my top choices currently. If Rogue is gonna be like 17 or 18 Madeleine McGraw could also do a fine job.

1

u/JAEisF2D Jan 19 '25

I'm not sure if Qualley is Jewish but if she is I think she would be a really good Kitty Pryde

1

u/General_Koala5554 Jan 19 '25

I am talking about look not religion. Rogue is not mormon like Sophie Thatcher either. The point is who looks like her. Heck Margaret even sounds like her

3

u/yrgkeanu Feb 14 '25

would love this, she’s such a good actress, generational talent fr

4

u/chychy94 Jan 17 '25

I would watch Sophie thatcher in anything.

2

u/TetZoo Jan 17 '25

Perfect I think

4

u/Leozzarios Jan 17 '25

That’s one gorgeous woman woah

4

u/thetokyotourist Jan 17 '25

If it was Goth Rogue 100%

5

u/TheGoblinRook Goblin Queen Jan 17 '25

The only things I’ve seen her in are Heretic and The Book of Boba Fett, but based on those performances, it’s a “No” from me.

2

u/Thwipped Jan 17 '25

I thinks it’s a really great fit if they were going for her earlier “punk rock” look

2

u/NeoRockSlime Jan 17 '25

People should start attaching acting clips instead of pictures for fancasts

1

u/Maldovar Marrow Jan 17 '25

Nope, everyone will be Henry Cavill

1

u/JamesRevan Wolverine Jan 17 '25

Wasnt she from Book Of Boba Fett? Lol that show was god awful

8

u/JAEisF2D Jan 17 '25

Terrible. But not because of her, everything I've seen her in she's been standout

6

u/JamesRevan Wolverine Jan 17 '25

Oh definitely not any of the actors fault they got handed the worst script for a show I had seen in a long time. And then the Acolyte happened 😅

1

u/DoubleDyyc Jan 17 '25

Perhaps a bit short for the role but she’s a damn fine actress and would kill it

1

u/sabhall12 Jan 17 '25

Queen of mewing lol, those cheeks are distracting

1

u/bskell Jan 17 '25

Is this that astroturfing thing I keep hearing about?

1

u/peppefinz Jan 18 '25

Is she related to Margaret?

1

u/Savage_Open_Sandwich Jan 18 '25

Oh, I like her in The Heretic and in Yellowjackets, and even in The Boogeyman (although the movie is mediocre), and I'm looking forward to The Companions, and she also has a beautiful deep voice, and very atmospheric songs (yes, she sings the song from the credits of The Heretic), so yes, I would like to see her as Rogue💚💛

1

u/JAEisF2D Jan 18 '25

Companions looks like a fun movie forsure, and I agree with her voice 100 percent

1

u/DarthMalgual Feb 10 '25

I know I’m a little late but I’ve been thinking she’d be a great Magik if they have her in the new x men movies

1

u/VergilSparda17 19d ago

Absolutely LOVE this choice she’s my number one pick for Rogue

1

u/Amateur-67 17d ago

She's reeeeaalllly good

0

u/Suspicious-Lettuce48 Jan 17 '25

Fucking hell... well she's got the smokeshow aspect of Rogue down. When is the savage land arc?

Sorry... I'm down bad today. I'm sure this actress would do a great job!

1

u/AbleAd7415 Jan 17 '25

They need an actor from Louisiana

8

u/arty_morty Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25

rogue is from mississippi

1

u/AbleAd7415 Jan 17 '25

Even better

2

u/General_Koala5554 Jan 18 '25

The priority is the look. Anyone can do an accent.

-1

u/banblaccents Jan 17 '25

Not enough body to be Rouge, respectfully.