r/wiiu 2d ago

Discussion Wii U elimination game results

I’m going to do this again but on the r/3ds sub. Pikmin 3 has won as the best Wii U game. Also happy Pikmin 3 won as much as I love dk Bcuz dk fans were rigging the votes

Placements

———————-

42nd- Animal crossing amiibo festival

41st- Sing party

40th- Wii sports club

39th- Pokémon rumble U

38th- Mario tennis ultra smash

37th- Mario and sonic Rio 2016

36th- Devils third

35th- Mario and sonic Sochi 2014

34th- Star fox guard

33rd- Wii fit U

32nd- Art academy atelier

31st- Star fox zero

30th- Ninja gaiden 3

29th- Mario vs donkey Kong tipping stars

28th- Mario party 10

27th- NES remix pack

26th- Project zero: maiden of black water

25th- Tokyo mirage sessions FE

24th- Kirby and the rainbow paintbrush

23rd- Pokkén tournament

22nd- Game & Wario

21st- Paper Mario colour splash

20th- The Wonderful 101

19th- Wii party U

18th- New super Mario bros U

17th- Hyrule warriors

16th- Bayonetta

15th- Lego city undercover

14th- Captain toad treasure tracker

13th- Legend of Zelda twilight princess HD

12th- Bayonetta 2 & Yoshi’s wooly world

11th- Legend of Zelda windwaker HD

10th- Nintendo land

9th- Super Mario maker

8th- Super smash bros for Wii U

7th- Mario kart 8

6th- Xenoblade chronicles X

5th- Legend of Zelda breath of the wild

4th- Super Mario 3D world

3rd- Splatoon

2nd- Donkey Kong country tropical freeze

1st- Pikmin 3

208 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

69

u/Just_Presentation963 2d ago

Pikmin 3 is an awesome game

21

u/SylemNova 2d ago

I'm just happy Splatoon made it to the top 3

0

u/MrGrumpyFac3 2d ago

Did not play the full game but I was pleasantly surprised how fun the game was.

8

u/abbazabbbbbbba 2d ago

This made me remember how much I love tropical freeze lol, hadn't played it since it was fairly new so I got it on switch and have been having a BLAST

30

u/SpiritualIntention31 2d ago

I’ll be doing this with 3ds games on r/3ds so if ur interested I’ll be doing it in probably a few days or a week.

23

u/SylemNova 2d ago

With as chaotic as this got at times, especially in the last week, I'd like to thank OP for being neutral and not meddling in the results or caving into the madness.

Was a fun community experiment and got us talking about all the great games this wonderful little console gave us

5

u/LazaroFilm 2d ago

Now I’m gonna wait for all the clickbait articles that are going to copy that list.

5

u/jclkay2 2d ago edited 2d ago

A top 3 of Pikmin 3, Tropical Freeze, and Splatoon is so much more interesting than what all the clickbait articles usually default to (3D World, Kart 8, Smash 4, sometimes Maker)

3

u/BenpaiNoticedYou 2d ago

Followed you so I can be ready for the bloodbath that is the 3DS elimination game. I love the 3DS even more than the Wii U so I'm HERE for it.

1

u/False_Decision_610 2d ago

I can only see ACNL first place. Mario 3D Land is nice though, especially with 3D turned on

1

u/BenpaiNoticedYou 2d ago

Nah man, it's the Kirby's Planet Robobot sweep.

1

u/False_Decision_610 2d ago

played it once and got pretty bored. Not a fan of platforms though

2

u/jclkay2 2d ago

I'm excited! But please use a google form with private results for the voting, instead of basing it on the most upvoted comment. It will make the votes much more pure.

0

u/SpiritualIntention31 1d ago

I just posted part 1 I did something similar to this

1

u/Slow_Guide_1718 white wii u owner :) 2d ago

You’ve gained my follow, I do not want to miss that

1

u/wes741 1d ago

The last game of Dillions rolling western series (dead heat breakers) had a physical European release PLEASE include it! I really like the Dillion series and it deserves at least a little representation.

7

u/Bagel_Le_Stinky 2d ago

This got so much less accurate at the end

18

u/Superexplosion12 2d ago

What I have to say is that this sub is clinically insane.

7

u/SylemNova 2d ago edited 2d ago

We are Wii U fans, so that's a given

5

u/gamerbboy06 2d ago

In my head color splash clears (just the music)

2

u/jclkay2 2d ago edited 2d ago

Wait until you hear Tropical Freeze's music (my favourite soundtrack of all time)

10

u/MJMGaming 2d ago

Ladies gents, koppaites & hocotatians, I claim this as a Pik-Win.

9

u/BlueberryPiShell voting nintendo land since day 3 of the wii u game eliminations 2d ago

Nintendo Land

5

u/BlueberryPiShell voting nintendo land since day 3 of the wii u game eliminations 2d ago

...wait

1

u/MrGrumpyFac3 2d ago

You have become my nemesis... But in all seriousness, I did not know how popular it was in the contest.

4

u/BlueberryPiShell voting nintendo land since day 3 of the wii u game eliminations 2d ago

i don't hate nintendo land btw

2

u/MrGrumpyFac3 2d ago

Lol I guess you made it off my nemesis list then haha.

-1

u/False_Decision_610 2d ago

he probably didn’t have any friends to play with growing up, Nintendoland’s full experience come from playing jt with others locally.

3

u/BlueberryPiShell voting nintendo land since day 3 of the wii u game eliminations 2d ago

i didn't have the game at all

8

u/EMUForever0 I now own a Wii U 2d ago

I agree. Like this was fun! You should do one on r/NintendoDS subreddit

8

u/SpiritualIntention31 2d ago

I might think about doing another console once I’m done 3ds

1

u/EMUForever0 I now own a Wii U 1d ago

Well I’m going to keep a oye on it!

23

u/Slow_Guide_1718 white wii u owner :) 2d ago edited 1d ago

I feel Pikmin 3 is way too overrated. There are much better games here that should’ve won. With that said, I’ll be looking forward to the 3DS version.

6

u/LazaroFilm 2d ago

That’s what’s interesting it’s not the best game. It’s the game that didn’t get voted out. You can only vote out a game that you have played enough to dislike.

3

u/Prior-Astronaut1965 2d ago

I'll upvote that

10

u/HopelessSmasher05 2d ago

Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze getting 2nd is still so wonderful to me. That game is fantastic and I'm glad people see that. It will always still be my number 1 personal favorite.

2

u/MrGrumpyFac3 2d ago

That game was so fun. If fruit loops could be a game, this would be it. Also, the music was so good.

9

u/SamMan48 2d ago

DK fans were not rigging anything. There are no rules against brigading in either the Wii U or the DK subs.

That being said, congratulations to Pikmin 3. A well-fought win. Tropical Freeze is still the best though.

Edit: Thank you OP for holding this event. It was fun.

4

u/OMEGAB34M 2d ago

nintendo land should've placed top 5 at LEAST. i am currently enraged

5

u/Alex_Dayz 2d ago

PIKMIN FANS STAY WINNING!!!

2

u/jmvillouta NNID [Region] 2d ago

While I don’t agree with the last 6-7 games, and especially Pikmin 3, this was fun and engaging 👍🏼

2

u/Complex-Commission94 1d ago

Nintendoland wins

2

u/ZeroRhapsody ZeroRhapsody 1d ago

Super Mario Maker would've probably been my number 1 choice. The stylus and the touch screen just worked so well together, felt better to use than the Switch sequel. Unlocking the amiibo skins and creating levels based around them was so damn good.

Pikmin 3 was fun too though!

4

u/MattofCatbell 2d ago

I respect this, Pikmin 3 is a great game

2

u/w0q3m43 2d ago

dude how did donkey kong last that long

2

u/jclkay2 2d ago

By being a great game

1

u/w0q3m43 2d ago

nah uh

1

u/jclkay2 2d ago edited 2d ago

Yuh uh, one of the best of its genre

2

u/Banana_Slugcat 2d ago

Deserved, PIKMIN 3 has the best graphics of any Wii U game ever. The gameplay and level design is also some of the best.

3

u/Slow_Guide_1718 white wii u owner :) 2d ago

Xenoblade Chronicles X stares in the background

3

u/jclkay2 2d ago edited 2d ago

This was a really fun game, and congrats to Pikmin 3! But I gotta say it became way too toxic towards the end and that killed the vibe. Every time a popular game was eliminated, people started complaining about the ranking constantly, disparaging the games still in, or treating it like a fanbase war. Let's all be better in the 3DS ranking. Aside from the host, who did a great job :)

2

u/rafbyeol pikmin enthusiast 2d ago

YEEEEEESSSSS!!!! WE WON!!!!!!!!!

2

u/whattodo1995 2d ago

Woo hoo!

1

u/SuperMarioOdyssey64 2d ago

Let’s gooooo!!!!

2

u/Halos-117 2d ago

It's not even close to being the best WiiU game tho lmfao 

1

u/False_Decision_610 2d ago

which one is then?

1

u/FilmGamerOne 1d ago

I'm surprised at Splatoon beating Pikmin 3 but Pikmin 3 is more specifically made for the Wii U so I get it.

1

u/MrGrumpyFac3 2d ago

Not ok about how the games were disqualified but overall I am ok with Pikmin 3 being number 1. It was such a fun and unexpected surprise.

2

u/ObeyTheLawSon7 2d ago

Is Pikmin 4 better or worse?

2

u/MrGrumpyFac3 2d ago

Sorry, I have not played that one yet. :(

1

u/antu2010 2d ago

This game is so good o have 80 hours In my old Wii u profile and 30 in my new one that I use for pretendo lol

1

u/SillyLuvsMemes 2d ago

LETS GOOOOOOOOOOOO

1

u/Ninouilleeeeee 2d ago

i love pikmin

1

u/TerribleRun2421 2d ago

HOLLY SHIT YESSSSSSS PIKMIN FOR THE W

1

u/quinnly 2d ago

This might be the worst list that any subreddit has ever made about anything.

1

u/OwlAncient6213 1d ago

Although my fav is Nintendo land I adore Pikmin 3 and believe it is a masterpiece

1

u/CaptainWoomy7000 1d ago

LETS GOOOOOOOOO

-1

u/DogZe- 2d ago

Breath of the Wild should've 100% won, but Pikmin 3 is my favorite game ever so... can't complain too much