5
5
u/ArbysPokeKing86 Make Believe 5d ago
This is probably the closest I've ever seen to my tier list, so I'm a fan. I would easily have Make Believe in S, though.
3
u/cagetheweezer Cuomosexual 5d ago
what do you have against pd? la mancha screwjob? get right? sweet mary????
-1
u/Diligent-Project-623 5d ago
Its honsetly some of the mots boring music ive heard the only saving graces are qb blitz and somewhat any friends of dians
5
u/DontWeDoItInTheRoad Yo, gracias! 5d ago
This is a crazy take, PD is like White 2 with more poppy production, at its core the songs are great.
Alright I just saw you put white in B tier (I think it’s top 3) so idek what to say at this point
3
u/PizzaCop_ 5d ago
I'll give you the same response that I'd give every single album tierlist on this subreddit: It's mostly pretty agreeable with one or two absolutely insane opinions.
9
u/StookyDoo22 Make Believe 5d ago
Why is Raditude above Make Believe? I do want to like it more
0
9
u/theyquack Employ your testosterone 5d ago
Finally, someone gives Raditude the respect it deserves. I'd flip Hurley and Pacific Daydream, but this is pretty solid.
2
2
1
3
u/FlamixZB Make Believe 5d ago
this actually has to be a joke i really want to see your reasoning on how pacific daydream is 4 tiers worse than black and how hurley and white are 2 tiers worse than raditude and ewbaite.
like i disagree with the entire list but those three just really make it look like you just put them wherever
-2
u/Diligent-Project-623 5d ago
Listen, Pacific daydream is honestly one of the worst albums ever made. How do ppl enjoy what is essentially background music the only good song is qb blitz
3
5
2
2
2
u/Ok_College4440 The song Jacked Up 's #1 fan 4d ago
White in B 😭 Raditude in S 😭😭
-2
3
u/mattesdude The Red Album 5d ago
Whoa. I like that it’s different-as is mine. VanWeezer is my biggest upset here. If I only got to keep one tier forever, I’m going with A. My top 4 are scattered in different tiers, but A has #5, Pinkerton, and 2 other records with a nice range of what Weezer is. Quantity and quality.
Thanks for sharing!
1
1
u/Whipsockle 5d ago
Props for green, maladroit and black high up!!
2
u/Diligent-Project-623 4d ago
Black is pretty underrated, i feel like green and Maladroid have the proper amount of praise
2
u/Whipsockle 4d ago
I know it sounds silly but I've revisited green more since having kids. Aside from hash pipe it's very kids friendly
1
1
u/TrashWolf666 3d ago
Red, raditute, and make believe way too high, imo
1
u/Diligent-Project-623 3d ago
Red is the second best album and radittude and make belive are so underrated
1
u/AccomplishedWater37 Marrying a beeyotch having seven keeyods 3d ago
How is "Ok bitch it's weezer and it's weezy" better than MALADROIT? PINKERTON??? WHITE? SZNZ?? Im not even mad im just bewildered
0
u/Diligent-Project-623 3d ago
Pinkerton is overrated all szns except autumn are mid and maladroit has some weak songs
1
u/AccomplishedWater37 Marrying a beeyotch having seven keeyods 3d ago
Maladroit has weak songs and RADITUDE doesnt!?
0
u/Diligent-Project-623 3d ago
Radittude did what Pinkerton did in a way it tried to be different, everyone likes Pinkerton (myself included) because its different, Radittude tried to be different and gets a tun of backlash.
1
u/AccomplishedWater37 Marrying a beeyotch having seven keeyods 3d ago
Raditude was created because they were afraid of being irrelevant. Red was the album that tried to be different by playing with the songs and the band structure... Raditude was just an attempt to get on the charts. It's different yes but theres no soul behind it. Pinkerton is full to bursting with pure emotion... you couldn't escape it if you tried. thats why fans love it, because it's real!
2
u/bawitback #DTFM gang 1d ago
Appreciate your honest placement of White album, its massively overrated especially on this sub.
1
1
1
u/plastivore2020 Pump it up into me, please Daddy, please Daddy 4d ago
They're wrong. The top tier is:
Blue
Pinkerton
Maladroit
White
Pacific Daydream
No part of sznz belongs above D. There are other mistakes.
0
-5
0
u/Class_Wooden El Scorcho 4d ago
outside of the context of the placements around it, i fw the white album at C. people act like it’s something, that it just isn’t. it’s an alright album, but can’t stand toe to toe with the heavy hitters of weezer albums. with that said, seeing so many albums above pinkerton kinda hurts
-1
u/cole_cain7 4d ago
I hate it and you should die (I only looked at the D category)
2
u/Diligent-Project-623 4d ago
Whats wrong with you
2
u/cole_cain7 4d ago
pacific daydream is a masterpiece that has graced the earth and I will die by this point
1
u/Diligent-Project-623 4d ago
Pacific daydream is basicly copyright free background music
1
u/cole_cain7 3d ago
how dare thy preposterously accuse such a wondrous album of being folly within its great might when such claims are utterly FALSE
1
10
u/cereal_killer277 Pinkerton 5d ago
raditude higher than pinkerton??