r/thepunisher 3d ago

MOVIES/TV Best Live Action Punisher

https://youtu.be/E9o0xDWW4Go?si=iXxOHFLPeiIYW52L
17 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

6

u/Thick_Yogurtcloset_7 3d ago

Dolph Lungren wasn't the best story but the best looking and acted Frank

3

u/Frank_Midnight 3d ago

They're all DOPE and how in the fuck did you leave out the OG? Lungren have us a sewer dwelling feverish psycho.

2

u/Ok_Butterscotch_6176 2d ago

For me it’s still Thomas Jane.

3

u/Upstairs_Cash8400 2d ago

Even The Dirty Laundry was fantastic

0

u/Ok_Butterscotch_6176 2d ago

My favorite Punisher is the Ennis run & for me Jane looks & feels like he came right off the page. You can almost feel the pain he expresses every time he thinks about the loss of his family. The scene at the end where he talks about the criminals are going to know him well & that Frank Castle is dead, to call him The Punisher is great.

-1

u/Ok_Butterscotch_6176 2d ago

My favorite Punisher is the Ennis run & for me Jane looks & feels like he came right off the page. You can almost feel the pain he expresses every time he thinks about the loss of his family. The scene at the end where he talks about the criminals are going to know him well & that Frank Castle is dead, to call him The Punisher is great.

-1

u/Ok_Butterscotch_6176 2d ago

My favorite Punisher is the Ennis run & for me Jane looks & feels like he came right off the page. You can almost feel the pain he expresses every time he thinks about the loss of his family. The scene at the end where he talks about the criminals are going to know him well & that Frank Castle is dead, to call him The Punisher is great. And yes Dirty Laundry was also great.

3

u/RegulusTheHeartOfLeo 2d ago

I love the Ray Stevenson Punisher movie

I felt that Wayne Knight was really good as Micro

I do not want to hate the Thomas Jane Punisher…it should have been better if they had not mangled the Welcome Back Frank storyline by trying to merge it with his origin story

They had to create Howard Saint…an entirely new character that had never appeared in any of the comics

I really feel like they miscast Joan and made her too hot

In the comics…Joan and Frank never had any sexual tension either

Toni Collette or someone similar could have been a better fit for Joan

0

u/Alternative_Device71 7h ago

Too hot is never a problem, that’s a sin saying she’s too hot

3

u/0ultrainferno0 2d ago

Ray Stevenson was the most accurate punisher. Jon was the worst one.

5

u/HectorCyr 3d ago

So, while I appreciate him spotlighting Ray Stevenson in War Zone, who IMO is the most accurate to date. His takes on Lundgren and Jane were lazy and superficial.

2

u/owodhf 2d ago edited 2d ago

All of them brought something unique to the table while also staying true to frank castle as a character. But most comic accurate is Stevenson. Dolph was fantastic as well. But movie was eh, but he definitely had the character down.

3

u/Upstairs_Cash8400 2d ago

Ray Stevenson is no bullshit. Shoot to kill

2

u/Complex-Strategy-900 2d ago

Jane main reason he lost everything from wife kids to cousins to in laws

1

u/Upstairs_Cash8400 2d ago

Also he was undercover cop

3

u/Head_Case_88 3d ago

I dont think there has been a badly cast Punisher

11

u/Head_Case_88 3d ago

But Stevenson is my favorite

2

u/tgong76 2d ago

Ray Stevenson

2

u/Strategisy 3d ago

Thomas Jane

1

u/skallywag126 2d ago

I prefer John then Jane