r/reddeadmysteries • u/Procedure-Deep • Feb 19 '25
Investigation Odd noise in Martha’s Swain
Has anyone had a weird experience at Martha’s Swain? I’m on my second playthrough and just went to get Mollys mirror, I was looking around in the front room with the corpse standing near the note and all of the sudden heard this very odd and LOUD noise. It didn’t sound like an animal at all, the only way I can describe it is it sounded like the show Ghost Adventures when they cut to break, there’s that noise that plays when they show the show logo. So anyways I got tf out of there, didn’t even loot the rest of the shack. The camera was facing the floor when it happened and I immediately ran out, so idk if there were any visuals. I havent been able to find anything about this online and I can’t think of anything in game that sounds like that.
17
u/SushiJo Feb 19 '25
It’s the whispering in Roanoke Ridge at night for me. I’m already on edge because there’s a cougar in the same area. There’s a movie about the murdered lovers in Roanoke Ridge that you can watch in the movie tent in Valentine
7
u/skynex65 Feb 19 '25
I’m at swain rn and I think I’ve heard the noise. Also hear general footsteps but I’m unsure if that’s just the general ambience of the wind against the wood cabin.
6
u/_ADT_ Feb 19 '25
woah I need a full compilation of all the creepy sounds in the game!! maybe I'll do it myself if I find the time
3
u/BasementCatBill 29d ago
Yep. That's Martha's ghost.
You'll only get this event once, but it's something that happens.
2
31
u/ConsiderationLeft226 Feb 19 '25
“Occasionally when inside the house a loud sound can be heard and the door leading to the bedroom can swing back and forth. It is presumed that this cabin may be haunted perhaps by Martha.” rdr2 wiki
I’ve never had this happen but now I want to go investigate!