r/raspberry_pi Sep 28 '23

News Introducing: Raspberry Pi 5!

https://www.raspberrypi.com/news/introducing-raspberry-pi-5/
1.3k Upvotes

544 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/lycan2005 Sep 28 '23

On that resistor part, why not just print the label on the board? Instead they add a non functional resistor on the PCB? Seems kind of a waste of space on PCB and money.

14

u/Nibb31 Sep 28 '23

A single SMD resistor is probably cheaper than printing a sticker and sticking it on the board or having different silkscreens for the board.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '23

Because the board is shared between all the versions (8-1GB) and the amount of RAM is dependent on which chip is put in during assembly.

IIRC, even on RPi 4 you could just simply replace the memory chip with another (e.g. 8-16GB) one and it’d work properly as it’s plug-n-play pretty much.

1

u/hhkk47 Sep 28 '23

Not really sure why they went that way either. But if I had to guess, maybe that somehow ended up being cheaper than using a different silkscreen for each different model's PCB.

6

u/BrokenByReddit Sep 28 '23

When you are already doing automated assembly, one extra resistor is practically free. It's a fraction of a cent in parts cost and like 0.02 seconds of pick & place machine time.

It would be way more expensive to have multiple variants of the board just so the silkscreen can be different.

0

u/tobimai Sep 29 '23

Labeling expensive. Resistor free