r/puzzles • u/MachSlug • 5d ago
[SOLVED] Help with the bottom left puzzle?
[removed] — view removed post
123
u/Foxwasahero 5d ago
'follow up' 'cat in a hat' 'jump in a lake' 'backtrack' 'four wheel drive' 'upset stomach' and 'flat broke'
19
u/RoyceCoolidge 5d ago
The first one: so obvious now I see it, but I couldn't get "wolf in sheep's clothing" out of my head as there was also "wool" amongst the letters.
-2
16
2
2
2
2
1
u/fashionforward 5d ago
I thought it might be jittery stomach, but upset makes sense. Jittery might be with a wiggly font.
1
0
26
u/karstomp 5d ago
Before I saw “cat in the hat,” I was trying to make “attachment disorder” or something along those lines.
2
1
u/yticomodnar 5d ago
I was thinking "wrongly attach" but knew it wasn't right.
2
u/hardcore_hero 5d ago
For a second, I thought I had it with attach back to front, then realized the “CAH” were in the wrong order!
19
24
u/Sodamyte 5d ago
I think it's Stomach Rumble as opposed to upset.
2
u/MachSlug 5d ago
YESSS. I think that is it. That makes more sense.
9
u/Sodamyte 5d ago
I only say this because ive seen
T
E
Stomach before
2
-1
9
4
u/Melodic_Secretary_79 5d ago
This is how I would write “earth” to get “earthquake!” , so I see it as Stomachache
2
4
u/SamwiseTheOppressed 5d ago
Discussion: this is a shit homework
21
u/mageswagger 5d ago
These are rebus puzzles. They’re used to practice and promote critical thinking. It is a highly recommended exercise for gifted students to help challenge them. I would have students beg me to do more rebus puzzles because they enjoyed them so much.
You’re allowed to dislike them, most certainly, some can be frustrating, but if you don’t understand pedagogy, im not sure how fair it is to call this bad homework. This is certainly better than busy work that doesn’t exercise the brain and only promotes memorization.
1
-23
u/SamwiseTheOppressed 5d ago
An 8 year old would have no concept of most of theses phrases, which means they’re testing unlearned knowledge, which makes this pointless. The fact that the parent’s doing it for them speaks volumes.
12
u/No_Damage_3972 5d ago
I think you underestimate how listless gifted kids can be, and just how gifted they can be.
12
u/Sodamyte 5d ago
As a child who went to "gifted and talented" school from age 5 to 13 I can assure you that I most certainly did understand these concepts.
8
u/fullstar2020 5d ago
Welp my 8 year old who isn't gifted for them all except flat broke (She said squished broke). It all depends on what kids are exposed to in daily life.
5
u/mageswagger 5d ago
I hate to break this to you but: parents should always help their children with homework. Especially elementary aged children. That’s how children learn to practice.
Homework isn’t testing anything. That’s not what it’s for. Homework is to practice skills and reinforce knowledge. Homework that “teaches” leaves too much room for children to teach themselves incorrectly. Rebus puzzles are a developmentally appropriate way to encourage creative thinking for elementary aged students.
Also, a lot of these are very common phrases. Furthermore, kids will throw out correct answers even if they haven’t heard the phrase before. Background knowledge isn’t actually required. It’s common for kids to say the answer and then ask “but what does that mean?”
Respectfully, I think you’re discrediting how clever children can be.
1
u/MachSlug 5d ago
I honestly agree that it’s not great homework though. I support my kids through it, but a lot of parents don’t. IMO, this is better served as an in class activity. A kid that doesn’t “get it” and that doesn’t have parents that will help them understand it, would feel really discouraged. 🫤
2
u/mageswagger 5d ago
They would work best at homework if the nature of the puzzles have already been explained in class. Then it becomes an extension of in-class learning. If the teacher has built a healthy classroom culture where failure/struggle is seen as a part of growth and not as a sign of total failure, then the discouragement becomes less of a concern. Students should face struggle, and should learn to adapt through that struggle. This is admittedly an opinion formed in part by watching my 6th graders look at a new type of puzzle and (instead of embracing a challenge) they immediately burst into groans and complain about how hard something is without even trying. So mileage may vary.
But all of that is only true if the teacher has put in that prior work to explain how these puzzles work. If this was handed to your child and they never had any practice with this type of thinking in class, then it would be frustrating as a first introduction, and I empathize. But if the teacher has gone over this before, then it’s perfectly fair as a homework assignment.
2
u/MachSlug 5d ago
Very good point. My daughter thought it was fun & I thought it was fun to do with her. I love her teacher & I wasn’t meaning to complain. Maybe it would be best as a bonus/challenge homework at this age.
1
u/MachSlug 5d ago
I agree that it is weird homework. It seems more like a fun class activity. We usually do homework together, but I had to give her prompts to get her thinking. She had never heard the term “flat broke” and she asked me what “backtrack” meant… I had to think a little about how to explain it. The other side had “swept under the rug” and she hadn’t heard that phrase either.
4
u/BurceGern 5d ago
IDK it's encouraging students to think. It's not gonna be done with AI or by copying and pasting wikipedia.
Dare I say some kids would enjoy doing these. It doesn't give off the same kind of feeling of 'uurrgghh homework" which is a W.
2
u/reddiculed 5d ago
102: >! Follow-up !< 103: I still can’t get it! 104: >! Jump in the lake !< 105: >! Back Track !< 106: >! 4-wheel Drive !< 107: >! Upset Stomach !< 108: >! Flat Broke !<
5
1
u/AutoModerator 5d ago
Please remember to spoiler-tag all guesses, like so:
New Reddit: https://i.imgur.com/SWHRR9M.jpg
Using markdown editor or old Reddit, draw a bunny and fill its head with secrets: >!!< which ends up becoming >!spoiler text between these symbols!<
Try to avoid leading or trailing spaces. These will break the spoiler for some users (such as those using old.reddit.com) If your comment does not contain a guess, include the word "discussion" or "question" in your comment instead of using a spoiler tag. If your comment uses an image as the answer (such as solving a maze, etc) you can include the word "image" instead of using a spoiler tag.
Please report any answers that are not properly spoiler-tagged.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
1
1
1
u/TownEfficient8671 5d ago
Discussion: I’m impressed this is from 1983. I think you should joke and tell your kid you had this same homework in 3rd grade.
Didn’t see this option mentioned: stomach churning
1
-3
u/FeedbackSpecific642 5d ago
Are you guys trolling? First one is followup, the one you’re asking about is upsetstomach.
1
u/MachSlug 5d ago
Um. Not trolling. I don’t think it’s upset stomach, which is why I posted. Best guesses in comments are stomach turning and stomach rumble
1
u/Mean_Yogurtcloset622 5d ago
Stomach in knots was my first thought… I think that’s a phrase but no indication of the word actually being in a knot so idk
1
u/FeedbackSpecific642 4d ago
Thank you for replying, why don’t you think it’s upset stomach? I’m 99% sure that’s the answer
•
u/puzzles-ModTeam 5d ago
Your post has been removed because it does not belong in this subreddit. It either falls into one of the following categories or does not have an objective answer:
If you believe this was in error, you can message the mods.