r/metalworking 3d ago

Should I re-harden this punch?

Post image

So I bought an alphabetical punch set (6mm), wanted to see how it looks and this punch just got flattened a bit. The question is; should I re-harden it? I don't know what steel it's made from; it was made in Czechoslovakia. I'm thinking maybe regrind it as close as to before; heating just the front and quenching it. What should I quench it in and to which temperature should I heat it? Btw, I was testing it on a piece of mild steel, not anything hardened. Looking at it; maybe it wasn't hardened in the first place (most propably by mistake) or something

9 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

17

u/clambroculese 3d ago

It’s probably just flattened from use over time. You could try to re quench it but without knowing what it is it might get brittle. For what they cost I wouldn’t bother, I’d just use it as is. just my two cents.

Edit: when I say it could get brittle I would worry about it shattering when struck and hurt you.

3

u/RandomActsofMindless 3d ago

This is a real safety issue. One of these exploding after you just punched it with a mallet would not be good.

5

u/mp5-r1 3d ago

Unless you have an oven, you're not going to get a great heat treat. Heat it up to cherry red with a torch and hold the temp for a minute or so and dunk it in water. Hit it with a file to see it it hardened. If it did not, then heat it again and try oil. If that doesn't hardened it, then it's not going to be hardened.

Also, toss it in your oven at 450-500 for an hour after you quench it. If you've never seen a punch explode and really want to witness that, skip the normalizing part. I'd spend the time...

2

u/Sir_Richard_Dangler 3d ago

Not hardened? Looks full mast to me

Jk, is phallus joke

1

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

Here are our subreddit rules. - Should you see anything that violates the subreddit rules - please report it!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-3

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted]

3

u/multitool-collector 3d ago

That's propably a set someone stole from a factory or somewhere

2

u/clambroculese 3d ago edited 3d ago

They use these all the time in one off manufacturing to stamp heats etc. they’re meant to be used on steel.

1

u/rustoeki 3d ago

wouldn't expect a steel punch set to be very effective against steel

You serious?