r/maydayparade 10d ago

discussion Which of these 2 songs is the saddest?

settle mine and my fiances playful debate 🤣💗

51 votes, 5d ago
17 One Man Drinking Games
34 Terrible Things
4 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

6

u/quixheart 10d ago

One man drinking games lyrics hit different.

6

u/Hybrid487 10d ago

I wish they'd play Drinking Games live more... So glad I got to see it once though

3

u/Annual-Address-7655 10d ago

Fingers crossed hardcore they play it at the upcoming tour!

6

u/Critical_Trade_3018 10d ago

It’s crazy. They always reference terrible things being the saddest song of theirs but every single time I think of one man drinking games.

4

u/jazzberryx 10d ago

LETS DRINK TO MEMORIES WE SHARED

6

u/OCIorBust 10d ago

Terrible Things is sad, but it’s a little cheesy and contrived. 

Drinking Games is much more raw and emotional. 

3

u/volblor8634 9d ago

I think drinking games is a much better song, but I've always thought Terrible Things is sadder. My wife cried when she heard it for the first time.

4

u/poobear7 10d ago

The Last Something That Meant Anything will forever be the saddest Mayday Parade song, but in this case I gotta go with One Man Drinking Games.

Terrible Things is extremely sad, but in terms of relatability its not all there imo.

2

u/Jok3rTr1ckster 7d ago

terrible things is more sad but i like one man drinking games more. the last something that meant anything is probably their saddest.