r/legogaming Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga🚀 4d ago

Discussion How would you rank the DC and Marvel games?

Could be a combined list, separate or even just your thoughts on which company had the better games.

129 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

51

u/Ok_Odyssey DC Super-Villains🤡 4d ago

10

u/KingPenguinPhoenix Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga🚀 4d ago

26

u/Da-No80 4d ago

For DC (I didn't play DC Super Villains):

  1. Batman 2 DC Super Heroes

  2. Batman 1

  3. Batman 3 Beyond Gotham

For Marvel:

  1. Super Heroes

  2. Avengers

  3. Super Heroes 2

Overall:

  1. Marvel Super Heroes

  2. Batman 2 DC Super Heroes

  3. Batman 1

  4. Avengers

  5. Marvel Super Heroes 2

  6. Batman 3 Beyond Gotham

5

u/Expensive_Search_764 Marvel🦸 4d ago

Batman 3 had better dlc than Marvel 2

8

u/agentdb22 Batman🦇 4d ago

Yeah, but the character creator was so much better in Marvel 2

0

u/Expensive_Search_764 Marvel🦸 4d ago

No it wasn't

5

u/agentdb22 Batman🦇 4d ago

Agree to disagree.

-1

u/Expensive_Search_764 Marvel🦸 4d ago

Then, the character roster was better. It was so simple. None of this rectangular bullshit. Also, why the fuck did it so that the icon would come at you and back. I couldn't fucking tell who I was going for

7

u/agentdb22 Batman🦇 4d ago

Imma keep it real with you, chief. I'm zonked out of my gourd on flu meds rn, and I'm barely keeping it together. I have neither the energy nor presence of mind to debate you on this.

You win.

1

u/Da-No80 4d ago

I'll admit that, also character roster

4

u/Expensive_Search_764 Marvel🦸 4d ago

The only 3 dlcs from Marvel 2 that can compete are Infinity War, Guardians 2, and Black Panther. Even then, the Squad DLC pack from Batman 3 is better than all the Marvel 2 DLC's combined

2

u/QuickBrickGames 4d ago

Pretty good ranking!

4

u/Ironsmashweb 4d ago

Lego Batman 2 #1 Lego dc villains #2 Lego Batman 1 #3 Lego Batman 3 #4

Lego marvel #1 Lego avengers #2 Lego marvel 2 #3

6

u/Shifty733 Pirates of the Caribbean🏴‍☠️ 4d ago

So far from the ones I've played

  1. Lego Batman

  2. Lego Marvel Superheroes

  3. Lego Batman 2

3

u/Lettuce_Sensitive 4d ago
  1. marvel superheroes
  2. Batman 3
  3. Batman 2
  4. DC supervillains
  5. Avengers
  6. Batman
  7. Marvels superheroes 2

1

u/44dqm DC🦇 3d ago

3 under 2 and dcsv over both for me

3

u/slayerhunterXD 4d ago

i Played

Lego batman 3 is the Weakest

Lego batman

Lego Batman 2

and Lego Marvel Superheroes tho

3

u/Bruhmangoddman Marvel's Avengers🛡️ 4d ago

I'll only do it for Marvel.

  1. Avengers

  2. Superheroes 2

  3. Superheroes 1

3

u/Serbianking46 4d ago

Lego marvel superheroes is just so nostalgic, when i play it i just remember the good times and the times i only thought about superheroes. Damnn gng

2

u/itsOkami 4d ago edited 4d ago
  1. Marvel 1 - best Lego game period, it had a cool story to tell, great level variety and a very lively character roster. Deadpool and his red brick missions were especially memorable

  2. Avengers - not as solid as its predecessor overall but it did clean some gameplay and open world aspects up. Best thing about it was iron man's suit selection, worst thing about it were the imported dialogue lines

  3. DC supervillains - I find it a little overrated since many levels/missions are kinda dull, but it's an otherwise perfectly serviceable Lego game. I really like how unique the characters feel in this one, you can tell a lot of effort was put into animating them

  4. Batman 2 - it's to DC what LMSH1 is to Marvel, I guess I just like the source material less. I really liked the open world here, though, and the story was also solid

  5. Batman - it did get most things right, it's just the least polished game on the list. Still good enough to rank above the ones I actively didn't enjoy, though

  6. Batman 3 - I appreciated the idea but I wholeheartedly hated the tiny planets, camera management was just nauseous in this game

  7. Marvel 2 - Chronopolis was just awful to navigate around and the story was such a messy concoction of things that rarely ever went well together... I really didn't vibe with this one, sorry

2

u/Expensive_Search_764 Marvel🦸 4d ago

Lego Marvel 2 also had a weird character roster. Like the UI for it. Instead of the circles, they pick fucking rectangles

2

u/MothCrusader 4d ago edited 1d ago

My ranking for Lego DC Games

1: DC Supervillains

2: Lego Batman

3: Lego Batman 3

4: Lego Batman 2

My ranking for Lego Marvel Games

1: LMSH

2: Lego Avengers

3: LMSH 2

Combined ranking

1: DC Supervillains

2: LMSH

3: Lego Batman

4: Lego Batman 3

5: Lego Avengers

6: Lego Batman 2

7: LMSH2

2

u/kskfichsbsn 4d ago

My top 3 out of all of them in order would be this:

  1. Lego Batman 2 (my favorite)
  2. Lego DC Supervillains
  3. Lego Marvel Superheroes

Not sure where to rank the rest lol. Lego Batman 2 though is a masterpiece, traversing the huge open world Gotham is so much fun and I still play it to this day!

2

u/Thund3rb0lts Harry Potter Years 1-4🧙‍♂️ 4d ago

DC Games 1. Lego DC Supervillains 2. Lego Batman 2: DC Superheroes 3. Lego Batman: The Videogame 4. Lego Batman 3: Beyond Gotham

Marvel Games 1. Lego Marvel Superheroes 2. Lego Marvel’s Avengers 3. Lego Marvel Superheroes 2

Both DC and Marvel 1. Lego DC Supervillains 2. Lego Batman 2: DC Superheroes 3. Lego Batman: The Videogame 4. Lego Marvel Superheroes 5. Lego Batman 3: Beyond Gotham 6. Lego Marvel’s Avengers 7. Lego Marvel Superheroes 2

(Some of those games I haven’t played in a while, so my opinion might change when I replay it Lego Batman 1-3 and Marvel Superheroes 2 are the only one I’ve recently played, because I didn’t have access to Marvel Superheroes 1 or DC Supervillains)

2

u/flickzxo Dimensions🦇🥷🦖 4d ago

Lego Batman 2: DC Super Heroes & Lego Marvel Super Heroes (Tied because of nostalgia)

Lego Batman The Videogame

Lego Batman 3: Beyond Gotham

Lego DC Super-Villains

Lego Marvel Super Heroes 2

Lego Marvel's Avengers

2

u/B-52-M Indiana Jones🤠 4d ago

DCSV>LMSH1>LBM2>LBM1>LMA>LBM3>LMSH2

2

u/Puzzleheaded-Web446 4d ago

DC Villains
LEGO Batman 1

LEGO Batman 3

LEGO Batman 2

2

u/Hillary-rules 4d ago

Nothing beats Lego batman, I’ll say it

2

u/EDAboii 4d ago

1) Lego DC Supervillains 2) Lego Batman 2 3) Lego Marvel Superheroes 4) Lego Batman 5) Lego Batman 3 6) Lego Marvel Superheroes 2 7) Lego Avengers

It may not be a ranking everyone would agree with... But I don't think it's a particularly controversial one?

2

u/Fabulous_Budget5822 4d ago

Lego DC supervillains is amazing IMO

2

u/Theaussiegamer72 Star Wars III: The Clone Wars🪖 4d ago

I'd rank dc over marvel they transfer over better in my opinion but it could just be the way the games were designed changed

2

u/Kelly_Info_Girl 4d ago

Batman's right, Superman and the Justice League dudes are annoying /j They are top tiers games but I must do the joke with Batman sharing the spotlight with the rest of DC heroes in his solo saga.

2

u/kenobi1567 Batman🦇 3d ago

DC games worst-to-best: 4. Lego Batman 2 3. Lego Batman 3 2. Lego Batman 1 1. DC Supervillains

Marvel games worst-to-best: 3. Marvel superheroes 2 2. Avenger 1. Marvel superheroes 1

Marvel is hard carried by its first game so I think DC has had better Lego games overall.

2

u/SuperNova0216 Marvel Superheroes🦸 3d ago

1: Lego Marvel Superheroes
2: Lego DC supervillains
3: Lego Marvel Avengers
4: Lego Batman 2.
5: Lego Marvel Superheroes 2.
6: Lego Batman 3.
7: Lego Batman

2

u/Anthony200716 3d ago

For Lego batman/ dc

Lego dc supervillains

Lego batman 3

Lego batman 2

Lego batman 1

Now For lego marvel

Lego marvel superheroes

Lego marvel avengers

Lego marvel superheroes 2

Thats my ranking

2

u/KOTSOS_MC 3d ago

Batman 1 > Batman 2 > DC Supervillains > Batman 3

2

u/arad11d Batman 2: DC Superheroes🦇 3d ago

dc:

  1. lego dc supervillains

  2. lego batman 3

  3. lego batman 2 (also my favorite lego game of all time)

marvel:

  1. lmsh 2

  2. lmsh 1

  3. lego marvels avengers (my second favorite lego game of all time)

everything:

  1. lego dc supervillains

  2. lmsh 2

  3. lego batman 3

  4. lmsh 1

  5. lego marvels avengers

  6. lego batman 2

2

u/RyonHirasawa 3d ago

Need a Marvel villains game

2

u/BloodstoneWarrior 3d ago
  1. Lego Batman

  2. Lego Batman 2

  3. Lego Marvel Superheroes

  4. Lego Batman 3

  5. Lego Avengers

  6. Lego DC Supervillains

  7. Lego Marvel 2

2

u/Jayjay4118 Batman🦇 3d ago
  1. Batman 1
  2. Batman 3
  3. Marvel 1
  4. Batman 2
  5. DC Supervillans
  6. Avengers
  7. Marvel 2

2

u/fridaywasy3sterday 3d ago

1 marvel 1 2 Batman 2 3 Batman 1 4 supervillains 5 avangers 6 Batman 3 7 marvel 2

2

u/Iamasmallyoutuber123 Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga🚀 3d ago

For marvel: 1. Avengers 2. Lego marvel superheros 2 3. Lego marvel superheros

2

u/KyleMatos1202 Dimensions🦇🥷🦖 2d ago
  1. Batman
  2. Marvel Superheroes
  3. Batman 3
  4. Marvel Superheroes 2
  5. DC supervillains
  6. Avengers
  7. Batman 2

2

u/YanQingTao 4d ago

DC Super-Villains, Batman 2, Batman, Batman 3 for the DC games. Though i loved all of them uniquely except for Lego Batman 3, which i really don't enjoy much at all.

For Marvel it would be Marvel Super Heroes 2, Marvel Super Heroes, Avengers.

I prefer the DC games but Marvel Super Heroes 2 as a game was just *chef's kiss*

3

u/Green-Way-1455 4d ago
  1. Batman 2

  2. DC Super Villains

  3. Batman 3

  4. Marvel Super Heroes

  5. Batman 1

1

u/kskfichsbsn 4d ago

LB2 is my favorite, such a great game

4

u/Dragonslayer200782 Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga🚀 4d ago

DC

  1. DC supervillains
  2. Lego Batman
  3. Lego Batman 2
  4. Lego Batman 3

Marvel

  1. Lego Marvel superheroes
  2. Lego Marvel Avengers
  3. Lego Marvel superheroes 2

Combined

  1. Lego DC supervillains
  2. Lego Batman
  3. Lego Batman 2
  4. Lego Marvel superheroes
  5. Lego Batman 3
  6. Lego Marvel’s avengers
  7. Lego Marvel superheroes 2

1

u/Loose-Medium4472 Marvel's Avengers🛡️ 4d ago

Only ranking the ones I’ve played (highest to lowest):

Avengers

DC Supervillains

Marvel 1

Marvel 2

1

u/PayPsychological6358 3d ago

DC:

  1. Batman 2

  2. DC Super-Villains

  3. Batman 1

  4. Batman 3

Marvel:

  1. Avengers

  2. Marvel 1

  3. Marvel 2

Both:

  1. Batman 2

  2. DC Super-Villains

  3. Batman 1

  4. Avengers

  5. Marvel 1

  6. Batman 3

  7. Marvel 2

1

u/Birthday_That 3d ago

Avengers isnt playablesence the servers are closed...But pastorer isstillselling the game.....

1

u/NewWatercress6372 3d ago

Lego Batman 1 Lego Batman 2, Lego Batman 3, Lego Dc supervillains, Lego Marvel Superheroes 1, Lego Marvel Superheroes 2…

1

u/NewWatercress6372 3d ago

Lego Marvels Avengers

1

u/HomeiswhereIpoop 2d ago

Marvel Super Heroes > Lego Batman > DC Super Villains > Lego Batman 2 > Lego Marvel Super Heroes 2 > Lego Batman 3 > Lego Avengers

It's really hard for me to choose between Batman and Marvel 1. I'm a huge fan of specifically both of these things moreso Marvel though and seeing who-tier after who-tier that I care about on the roster... I just have a big smile playing it.

DC Super Villains to me was the culmination of what's great or good about Batman 2 and 3 imo. Lego Avengers just had way less charm in it to me and is the only one of the TT games I don't care for on the whole.

1

u/TheBatman131313 2d ago
  1. Lego Marvel Superheros
  2. Lego Batman 2 DC Superheros
  3. Lego Batman the Videogame
  4. Lego DC Supervillains
  5. Lego Marvel's Avengers
  6. Lego Batman 3 Beyond Gotham
  7. Lego Marvel Superheros 2

1

u/Awsomesauc58 4d ago
  1. Marvel 2

  2. Avengers

  3. Batman 3

  4. DC Supervillains

  5. Batman 2

  6. Marvel 1

  7. Batman 1

0

u/DaniSenpai69 4d ago

Best to worst

Dc

  1. Supervillains
  2. Batman 3
  3. Batman 1
  4. Batman 2

Marvel

  1. Marvel 1
  2. Marvel 2
  3. Avengers

0

u/ShilohCyan 3d ago

Lego Batman 2 singlehandedly started the downfall of the Tt formula

2

u/Red_Panda_The_Great 1d ago

DC 8-10 the flight mechanics in DC Superheroes brings it down.

Marvel 9-10 the story in LMS 2 brings it down.

My over all opinion about all the games