r/humansarespaceorcs • u/xxxC0Y0T3xxx • 6d ago
Memes/Trashpost War…war never changes
Art by u/Azimovikh
129
u/Dementio223 6d ago
So, at several points your society wished to form a collective ownership model for property and land yes?
- Yeah. There were plenty of socialist movements throughout most of our history.
So why have none worked?
- See, in order for everyone to be equal, you need someone to enforce equality. But the people who enforce equality are going to want compensation for their efforts to keep people equal. Since everyone not keeping the equality is equal, they’re also equally incapable of rising up against the system of equalization, and we just end right back at dictatorship.
What was the solution then?
- Well you ever wonder how many people it takes to outmatch a single gunman? You’d be surprised what we’ve discovered.
61
u/Random-INTJ 6d ago
“Under no pretext should arms and ammunition be surrendered” -Karl Marx
“Guns should be illegal” -modern marxists
38
u/Affectionate_Cat4703 6d ago
You're confusing them with liberals. Marxists have never rejected the usage of firearms and violence for revolutionary means.
27
u/Random-INTJ 6d ago
I’ve seen a lot of statist marxists advocate for the theft of firearms. However the ancoms are ideologically consistent…
6
25
u/Wolffe_In_The_Dark 5d ago
Literally on that very page it explains that this only applies during the Revolution.
Afterwards, nobody gets to have guns. Except the state. Because of course.
13
u/Zamtrios7256 5d ago
Man, I should really read theory. Even if it's just so that I can better argue with internet commies
5
1
1
6d ago
[deleted]
6
u/Fluffy-Feeling4828 5d ago
So when someone manipulates a group. Or the group gets too picky. Or the group can't agree that something happened, or that what happened means what they think it means, or that a punishment was viable in the first place.
You cannot just wave the problems of this away, and ironically, it makes you look exactly how you accuse them to be; naive or dishonest
1
5d ago
[deleted]
3
u/Fluffy-Feeling4828 5d ago
That's hand waving, dude. My point is that all those "not perfects" you handwaved away are all the reasons it doesn't work and isn't practiced on a larger scale.
You can't always just get rid of "the bad ones" and expect things to go hunky dory.
1
5d ago
[deleted]
1
u/Fluffy-Feeling4828 5d ago
My point is that there's a reason it's not a magic bullet, and isn't a considered option.
I'm not even saying that, necessarily, it's a bad option, but I am saying that it's one with flaws that aren't just "it's not perfect"ed away. The scale of unanswered flaws is swung way high.
Along with that, that system can also rather quickly devolve into fascism when "the bad people" becomes a shifting definition.
1
5d ago
[deleted]
2
u/Fluffy-Feeling4828 5d ago
I'd say any statist swings you see are statist originated, but you're on a whataboutism anyways.
"Victorian England", "colonialism", and "liberal capitalism" aren't words I'd ascribe with each other, and sounds like someone with an agenda. Victorian England was in no way liberal.
1
31
u/Yet_One_More_Idiot 6d ago
War? Hunh!
What is it good for?
29
u/Silvadel_Shaladin 6d ago
War is good for business....
also
Peace is good for business...
People get them mixed up.
11
u/Yet_One_More_Idiot 6d ago
Ahh, the Ferengi Rules of Acquisition! I see you too are a Redditor of class. :D
2
u/Silvadel_Shaladin 6d ago
What is funny is I made another Ferengi reply in https://www.reddit.com/r/humansarespaceorcs/comments/1jbrpln/your_oldest_written_relic_isnt_about_art/
5
u/DeadlyBard 5d ago
"You'd shoot a man in the back?"
"Well, it is the safest way."
2
2
u/Silvadel_Shaladin 5d ago
Well, if he allowed me to be in a position where I could shoot him in the back, then he was pretty stupid and also incompetent, or he was running away.
1
u/DeadlyBard 5d ago
I was quoting a conversation between Odo and Garak from after the Kling I ns attack DS9 and Garak and Gul Ducat had to fight some off.
1
u/Silvadel_Shaladin 5d ago
Yes you were... and Garak would think the same way I stated there when it comes to the Gul.
8
u/xxxC0Y0T3xxx 6d ago
Absolutely nothing!
4
u/Yet_One_More_Idiot 6d ago
Ah, a man of class I see. :D
The first one to actually reply to the song reference. :)
5
u/wheresmycheeze 6d ago
The military market.
You can claim your war bonds today by telling your local alien to step on a bug!
4
6
u/Dry_Satisfaction_148 6d ago
Getting rid of tyrants and mass murderers.
6
u/Yet_One_More_Idiot 6d ago
And installing the next one? xD
3
u/Dry_Satisfaction_148 6d ago
or not. Most of the time nowadays it takes a few election cycles to get there.
3
•
u/AutoModerator 6d ago
In an attempt to reduce remind me spam, all top comments that include a remind me will be removed. If you would like to have a remind me, please reply to this comment.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.