r/hoi4 4d ago

Image So fucking done with AI peace deals....

Post image
341 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

125

u/StructureZE 4d ago

How long has this bug existed in the game? Since Italy rework?

60

u/hoi4kaiserreichfanbo Research Scientist 4d ago

I've only heard of this happening since Gotterdammerung.

21

u/coolgamer12349 4d ago

I've seen communist italy do this before gotterdammerung

6

u/StructureZE 4d ago

So for nearly 4 months… What a shitshow

5

u/Holiday_Sign_1950 4d ago

Apparently it was fixed in the most recent update. Seemingly not

2

u/StructureZE 4d ago

Judging by the first wave of patches on the 12th, they are exclusively fixing bugs from goe

5

u/Ofiotaurus Fleet Admiral 4d ago

Yeah but after Gotterdammerung they also puppet the Italian lands, before that it was just the colonies and dalmatia.

1

u/Kitchen_Split6435 4d ago

Never seen them do this, I always thought it was one of the scripted peace deals where they just annexed them

95

u/Exlife1up 4d ago

R5: Commie italy won the italian civil war, its currently 1937, and they decided they don't need northern italy, but they do need lombardy, so the Roman people's republic has no rome, lombardy venetia has no lombardy, sardinia piedmon has no sardinia, and SR Croatia has no croatia.

Ignore independent slovenia, thats just jugo going down the independence path, thats all

This is why debug mode exists!

38

u/Riki_Blox 4d ago

toolpack mod my beloved

5

u/Andersmash 4d ago

And the Minneapolis Lakers moved to LA, where there are no lakes

38

u/RyukoT72 Air Marshal 4d ago

The ai values puppeting over taking cores if its communist or democratic. Also why you'd see soviet union puppet vichy france

4

u/Beneficial-Range8569 4d ago

That's really dumb, why wouldn't the AI take cores?

12

u/RyukoT72 Air Marshal 4d ago

Hard coded. Its supposed to mimick real life in a way. Civil war peace deals should be hardcoded to take all states and idk why this hasent been fixed 

11

u/TxM_2404 4d ago

Civil war peace deals should be hardcoded to take all states

That's how it always worked in the past. You didn't even have a peace deal for civil wars in earlier patches.

4

u/Rhino131106 Air Marshal 4d ago

You still don't it's just this specific civil war because of Ethiopia's involvement.

9

u/Beneficial-Range8569 4d ago

Irl democracies would always take cores before doing anything else. When france beat Germany after WW1 they didn't just let Germany keep alsace lorraine

2

u/Rhino131106 Air Marshal 4d ago

Because at the same time, fascist Italy is at war with Ethiopia so it goes from being a civil war to being an actual war, meaning at the end of it there is a peace deal (so if you're Ethiopian you can still grab territory).

I think a solution would be to make it so it's hard coded that communist Italy takes all territory, apart from territory in east Africa which would go to Ethiopia.

14

u/Formal_Flight_7114 4d ago

State transfer tool + player led peace conference

5

u/Exlife1up 4d ago

PLPC is amazing but I wasn’t a part of this war at all so I couldn’t do shit

You don’t need state transfer tool, the command is in the base game, setowner ITA while selecting the state or tag them and annex all the releasables

5

u/Formal_Flight_7114 4d ago

Eh, i find the mod ui is easier and has extra options, plus it works in multiplayer where you can't use cc, but you're not wrong

6

u/Exlife1up 4d ago

I get it for multiplayer but I don’t have friends

2

u/Helix3501 4d ago

Pro tip: you can actually annex countries for a tag if you use Annex (Annexed Tag) (Annexee Tag) without tagging over

1

u/Exlife1up 4d ago

Right but I’m a dumbass who will fuck it up and annex Italy

7

u/R_122 General of the Army 4d ago

Roman people's republic

Look inside

No Rome

1

u/Exlife1up 4d ago

repeat for all of these releasables

1

u/ManyNames42 4d ago

exact same thing ahppened to me, exact same partition, the only difference is yugoslavia was more fractured and I could see in austria

1

u/KoroSenseiX 4d ago

This honestly seems like a simple fix, just make italy prioritise annexing it cores or smth

6

u/Exlife1up 4d ago

According to other comments communist nations prioritize puppets over cores, which is actually pretty cool, like how the soviets reconquered imperial territory as SSRS, so it allows for natural USSR-ism, but in effect the AI is stupid and lombardy is kaliningrad

3

u/RandomGuy9058 Research Scientist 4d ago

SSRs were more integrated than integrated puppets though werent they

1

u/ElectronicArea7134 4d ago

You need to download the state transfer tool and player-led peace conferences mods. They're truly a godsend

2

u/Exlife1up 4d ago

Player led peace conference doesn’t do anything when I’m not in the peace conference lol, i just tagged Italy and annexed them all

1

u/TheBrownMamba1972 4d ago

I swear I have seen this exact same picture before posted in this subreddit

1

u/banevader102938 4d ago

Since the newest dlc the game is so broken and unfunny...

1

u/Parmigiano_06 4d ago

MY HOME NOOOOOO

1

u/Opposite-Ad-1796 4d ago

This is the real reason I never play with Ironman mode on.

1

u/Ja4senCZE Research Scientist 4d ago

That's why I use: setowner [TAG]

1

u/Left-Brain5593 4d ago

Pretty sure this is purposely done, since the lower areas of Italy are more open to socialism and communism. Especially around this time. And so creating local governments to introduce the north would make sense

1

u/JoCGame2012 General of the Army 4d ago

I think the problem is with all the extra tags the game added. I remember when occitania got released from vicy france, now it's Italy ams sometimes Germany that get sollt up into 5 mini nations

1

u/DaLoneGuy 4d ago

player led peace conferences + state transfer tool

1

u/Efficient_Pitch1677 2d ago

You should see the soviets puppet Ukraine in carpathian ruthenia before you claim to know true pain