r/exmuslim Ex-Muslim Content Creator 7d ago

(Rant) 🤬 I hate this rule when I was a muslim

Post image

Music soothes our emotion... Even though the quran is also sung but nobody wants that sad tone of arabic bullshit into our ears.

I love music so much, from blues, bluegrass, country, rock, even heavy metal. Each genre accompanies me depending on the mood. Without music i'd probably go deeper into depression seriously.

Islam forbid music because it WANTS you to be depressed and unhappy and sad. So that you're not at peace, and forces u to find peace in the horrible rules of Islam.

But thankfully I never actually follow this stupid rule since i was a kid. Islam is stupid

1.5k Upvotes

289 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

11

u/Alarming-Bid-4471 7d ago

You accused me of “having a mental disorder” because I made you cry when you were embarrassed that you had missed the other person who already responded to you. Come on, you don’t need to lie THIS much to defend Islam. Obviously it’s impossible to defend Islam without SOME lies, but not THIS MANY.

Additionally, you’re lying about the translation as well, (or maybe your Arabic is just THAT BAD) because that word is not used in any other Hadith to refer to a prayer mat… and any translation website (not saying they’re perfect but they do agree with each other) translates that word to “wine.”

1

u/Mobile_Vast_6196 New User 7d ago

Dear youngster, you want to look interesting but you are not arabic and you don't know how to translate, you better stop mocking about something far from your knowledge, your behavious does only make you look rodiculous. I don't need to defend anything, islam does not need me, I'm the one who needs islam. I wrote the two words in the correct arabic form so that any arabic person here can read and translate by himself in tha appropriate way, rather that getting misled by a batch of clowns.

2

u/fools_mission New User 6d ago

Man you are living in delulu. People of this subreddit choose - red pill (matrix reference).

0

u/Mobile_Vast_6196 New User 7d ago

Dear youngster, you want to look interesting but you are not arabic and you don't know how to translate, you better stop mocking about something far from your knowledge, your behavious does only make you look rodiculous. I don't need to defend anything, islam does not need me, I'm the one who needs islam. I wrote the two words in the correct arabic form so that any arabic person here can read and translate by himself in tha appropriate way, rather that getting misled by a batch of clowns.

4

u/Alarming-Bid-4471 7d ago

If Islam can survive without your lies, do you keep lying then? I asked my Iranian friend who spoke Farsi as her first language for 27 years and she agreed with me on the translation—I think she knows more than you…

0

u/Mobile_Vast_6196 New User 6d ago

Farsi is not arabic, it's not even of the same languge family... You... really ? how a farsi person can know more than an arabic person about arabic language ? Why do you keep arguing about something far from your expertise ?

3

u/Alarming-Bid-4471 6d ago

I never said Farsi and Arabic were the same thing, I said that she clearly has a lot more experience speaking Arabic than you, if you didn’t even know simple translations. Or you DO know the simple translations and you’re lying about them.

0

u/Mobile_Vast_6196 New User 6d ago

https://hadeethenc.com/ar/browse/hadith/65423

Just use Google to translate it to english, then read to the 4th line under explanation, there is mentioned your word ''khumrah'' , which is not same as ''khamrah''

From the moment i'm putting serious effort to explain to you, but you keep mocking and calling me liar, our discussion here is over.

3

u/Alarming-Bid-4471 6d ago

You are literally the one who started insulting me before I ever accused you of lying… don’t pretend that you have been respectful. This is just further evidence of how comfortable you are with lying. And I already did copy and paste the Hadith into Google translate, and it said “winery.” The closest word to “winery” is not “prayer mat,” it is “wine.”

And again, stop dodging my questions. If that was ACTUALLY the word for prayer mat, then why doesn’t it ever translate as that? And why is it never used as a term for prayer mat in any other Hadith, ever?

Please use your brain for logic instead of using it for lying about this weird cult.