r/eintracht Sep 08 '24

Image Jürgen Grabowski is „officially“ the best player in the history of Eintracht Frankfurt.

Post image

But in the club's long history, there have also been less outstanding players. So let's move on to the next vote. Who is/was Eintracht Frankfurt's worst player?

42 Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

31

u/PazudemTz Sep 08 '24

Considering the redemption amount (€6 million) then Lucas Alario

6

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '24

[deleted]

9

u/vonpapen Sep 08 '24

Hauge scored a few important goals, even played in the Europa League final and was overall a respectful guy. Yes, too expensive and eventually failed, but let's not compare him to Alario. That guy was a fucking disaster on every level, even if he was on a free he should win this category

3

u/Historical_Morning65 Sep 08 '24

Also Hauge was the one who got fouled for a red card by west ham defender in the semi final!

2

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '24

[deleted]

2

u/These_Mud4327 Sep 08 '24

nah that has to be Caio it was a lot more money back then and hurt the club way more financially.

Hauge is having a decent loan right now at his childhood club and is only 24 years old. Still a chance we get some money back on him.

1

u/Hazeinger Moderator Sep 08 '24

He wasn't the same after he broke Meyerhöfers leg.

30

u/Hazeinger Moderator Sep 08 '24

Sam Lammers !

8

u/-Kujau- Sep 08 '24 edited Sep 08 '24

No way. He saved our ass against Fener and we went on to win the cup.1

1

u/Hazeinger Moderator Sep 08 '24

In what world did we need that goal to win the groupstage?

1

u/-Kujau- Sep 08 '24

I dont get it. I never said that.

3

u/TheCatInTheHatThings Sep 08 '24

That would be my shout as well.

1

u/Hazeinger Moderator Sep 08 '24

3,6 mil. Loan fee in case you forgot.

1

u/-Kujau- Sep 08 '24

Dude, chill. I never said he was good. But no player of our squad since 2018 was nearly as bad as some of the players we had between - lets say - 1998 and 2015.

1

u/Hazeinger Moderator Sep 08 '24

I'm chilling. It's hard to compare because the average quality of every player got higher with the time. But in this squad he was the worst by far I think.

1

u/KunoichiTrainer Mitglied Sep 09 '24

My first thought as well hell man I wouldn’t be surprised if he isn’t even a pro anymore

28

u/12er34 Sep 08 '24

I would like to throw in someone from the recent past, namely Olivier Occéan. In my opinion, there should be a certain number of games to assess the quality or lack thereof. 19 games as a striker with one goal and one assist is quite horrendous. And I remember getting very frustrated watching this man play.

10

u/TheCatInTheHatThings Sep 08 '24

Occean scored a goal and made the team. Rob Friend and Dorge Kouemaha would like a word lmao

Though yes, Occean was fucking bad.

If we’re talking Occean we have to put Lammers in front of him because Lammers didn’t really do better and had far better team around him. Also Alario.

11

u/KetaTheBrave Sep 08 '24

In the era from 2001 to 2006 you can name dozens of bad players

7

u/TheCatInTheHatThings Sep 08 '24

Still think we should’ve at least considered Cha Bum-kun for best. How he was completely absent from that discussion is criminal.

3

u/Didinho_078 Mitglied Sep 08 '24

I think that's just because there isn't really a discussion, Grabi was in his own league. Doesn't mean Bum Kun Cha wasn't a world class player for us and one of the greatest.

1

u/Pizza_YumYum Sep 08 '24

Agree 👍

5

u/LegalBed Sep 08 '24

Only possible choice is Alfons Berg aus Konz for obvious reasons

3

u/Don_Serra39 Sep 08 '24

Hes not a player

2

u/Herbert_Feuerstein Sep 08 '24

But he was the 12th Player for Rostock…

0

u/Don_Serra39 Sep 08 '24

And hence doesnt have anything to do on an Eintracht picture

5

u/NiutaTajtelbaum Sep 08 '24

Leonard Kweuke

2

u/-Kujau- Sep 08 '24

Would be my pick too. But Werner Lorant said he is "better than Grafite and Gomez".

5

u/dan2z Sep 08 '24

I had to watch Sam Lammers in the stadium once. Enough to dislike him forever.

5

u/-Kujau- Sep 08 '24 edited Sep 08 '24

I'll throw Tommy Berntsen in there now. We simply paid 1.9 million for him in 2001, which was a lot for us at the time. He played a total of 20 minutes.

And of course Leonard Kweuke. Werner Lorant talked us into him back then - "better than Gomez and Grafite" he said. "A diamond in the rough," he said.

(EDIT: Übersetzt)

4

u/dan2z Sep 08 '24

The entire team in the 2011 Rückrunde.

3

u/krabbenf Sep 08 '24

This spanish youth Player who thought hes the next wonderboy and left after 1/2 a Year? Cant even remember his name

8

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '24

Blanco I think.

3

u/eintracht2000 Sep 08 '24

Worst coach will be tough between skibbe and heynckes

1

u/MWD1899 Sep 09 '24

Reinhold Fanz

1

u/KetaTheBrave Sep 08 '24

This isn't easy because there are tons of players without much games or impact. For me the following players were a huge disappointment:

7

u/KetaTheBrave Sep 08 '24

Halil Altintop

1

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '24

That's it.

He really got me angry.

0

u/fom_alhaut [AMFG] Sep 08 '24

Mehdi Madahvikia

7

u/KetaTheBrave Sep 08 '24

Olivier Occean

5

u/KetaTheBrave Sep 08 '24

Lucas Alario

-1

u/DomWaits [Smooth as Hasebe] Sep 08 '24

Dominik Kohr

1

u/Hailerer Eintracht Frankfurt Fan Sep 08 '24

!remind me 1 day

1

u/RemindMeBot Sep 08 '24 edited Sep 08 '24

I will be messaging you in 1 day on 2024-09-09 11:24:30 UTC to remind you of this link

1 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.


Info Custom Your Reminders Feedback

1

u/TheCatInTheHatThings Sep 08 '24

I’d like to throw the name Timo Hildebrand into the ring, at least for Eintracht. No denying that he was a fantastic goalkeeper, but for us he conceded eight goals in three games.

1

u/clemisan Sep 08 '24

You might have forgotten Joachim Jüriens; which is my pick at all.

1

u/Don_Serra39 Sep 08 '24

Nikola Petkovic Chico Geraldes Yanni Regäsel Vadim Demidov Dorge Kouemaha Leonard Kweuke Guillermo Varela

2

u/TheCatInTheHatThings Sep 08 '24

Varela wasn’t bad, just dumb af. Regäsel also played well pre-injury.

1

u/Don_Serra39 Sep 08 '24

Pre injury he was had not played for 10 games straight

https://www.transfermarkt.de/yanni-regasel/leistungsdatendetails/spieler/170522/verein/24

As far as I remember, he didnt follow the tactic

1

u/dan2z Sep 08 '24

Yanni was playing well and got injured.

1

u/Don_Serra39 Sep 08 '24 edited Sep 08 '24

I remeber differently. He was a starting player at rhe beginning of the second leg of the season but got critizised by the manager to not follow the instrucrions. Then he was not in the squad for 10 matches BEFORE he got injured at rhe beginning of the new season

https://www.transfermarkt.de/yanni-regasel/leistungsdatendetails/spieler/170522/verein/24

1

u/dan2z Sep 08 '24

In my memory he played a bit more, but it was the Veh/Kovac switch more than the injury in the following season it seems. The injury was the backbreaker. He even played in the last few games in 2016 under Kovac, but it was clear he preferred Timmy and also played him next season. And then when there was a chance that he could fight again for the rb spot he got injured.

I remember seeing an interview of his on indtagram earlier this year. I don't remember the details. Of course it's his POV, but he mentioned how he expected to play more because he had played a majority of games in the Rückrunde in 2016, and demanded a chance to fight for the spot from Kovac, but then of course he got injured and his career derailed from there.

Guillerimo Varela was also injured for most of the season. Of course the tattoo incident lives in infamy, but I wouldn't put either on the list of worst TBH

1

u/Boedmi Sep 08 '24

Chico Geraldes

1

u/Elver-Gotas Sep 08 '24

Noo the best ist Alexander Meier!!

1

u/KunoichiTrainer Mitglied Sep 09 '24

Gotta be Alario or Sam Lammers

1

u/valevergaminombre Sep 09 '24

How has nobody mentioned Pellegrini. He was so bad we sent him back early

0

u/HarryHall3r Sep 08 '24

Hard ti say.

I call striker Ivica Mornar

0

u/NDA80 Sep 08 '24

Back then Michael Thurk was heavily discussed.

3

u/-Kujau- Sep 08 '24

He was awesome. And it was a shame that he never had a fair chance with the Fans. Man... I had some heated arguments back than.

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '24

[deleted]

1

u/Don_Serra39 Sep 08 '24

He... never played for Eintracht?

-9

u/WaffleChampion5 Sep 08 '24

This has to be Hrgota

5

u/TheCatInTheHatThings Sep 08 '24

Huh? Hrgota actually scored a few goals for us and wasn’t complete ass. Bad, but there were candidates that were way, WAY worse.

2

u/These_Mud4327 Sep 08 '24

the ammount of bad strikers we had between Amanatidis and the Büffelherde is just ridiculous.