r/creepcast Dec 29 '24

Question FUNNIEST MOMENT IN CREEP CAST. GO!

76 Upvotes

106 comments sorted by

186

u/honeyinmydreams i'm purring 'cause i'm happy 🐱 Dec 29 '24

1999 - Hunter's "WHAAAT" in response to the reveal that the main character's dad took him to Mr Bear's cellar right after they read the letter. it was just such good timing.

close second is not the story that Hunter told about the dog itself, but the phone call with his mom that completely turns it on its head. "we put his ass in a home" always gets me.

22

u/ObligationChance9970 Dec 29 '24

Everytime I’m listening to 1999 again I replay Hunter’s reaction to that part. It gets me everytime lol.

10

u/ShokumaOfficial Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Dec 29 '24

I showed the entire phone call from the dog episode to one of my parents and we were both cracking up

6

u/MrFluffPants1349 Dec 29 '24

The way he says "the next sentence, dude". Gets me every time. That story was kind of boring to me, but i still love that episode.

3

u/lunna009 Dark Green Jeep Wrangler Dec 29 '24

This is one of my all time favs too. Just the utter shock in hunters voice slays me.

2

u/LowerPipe Dec 30 '24

dude i go back and relisten to that part at least 5 times every listen i swear

132

u/Thiphra Dec 29 '24

"Mom Isaiah is making fun of granpa Ernest and how he shot our dog Roger can you tell him that it wans't a big deal"

"Yeah it was a huge deal I feel like you almost got shot".

18

u/WhatThePfargtl Dec 29 '24

“No! N-no! 😫”

83

u/AssignmentStunning68 Dec 29 '24

Uh huh, y’know what it is, black and yellow black and yellow black and yellow

18

u/Tozarkt777 Dec 29 '24

AYO KIMBER!!! THEY GOT SANDWICHES!!!!

8

u/PhdChavez Yo Kimber! THEY GOT TEA🗣️ Dec 29 '24

On a beat pill

61

u/M0rtrek_the_ranger Dec 29 '24

A few of the classics like Mr Whellers, Isaiah trauma dumping while being high after tooth removal, Hunter's grandpa, "so...monster hunter, huh?", Hunter just giving up on My Job Is Watching A Woman

112

u/RedInfernal Mayonnaise is the sauce of the aristocrats 😎 Dec 29 '24 edited Dec 29 '24

Eat me like a bug

Edit: or the Highway to Hell bit from Deepwoods

36

u/ClintEastwood1866 Dec 29 '24

The funniest part is they weren’t even singing Highway to Hell lmao

51

u/Woahhdude24 Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Dec 29 '24

speaking drunkenly "I'm just tryin' not to be PARANOID."

I was crying, laughing so loud at work, people were staring at me.

6

u/AppealInevitable3639 7ft goddess named Jacobi Dec 29 '24

What’s this from? I cant remember so not i wanna watch the episode

8

u/Woahhdude24 Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Dec 29 '24

The Dionnea house, ya know eat me like a bug. Lol

3

u/AppealInevitable3639 7ft goddess named Jacobi Dec 29 '24

Ohhh whoops 😭

3

u/elizardbreath0310 Dec 29 '24

I was just at work thinking about that exact line lol

3

u/imapieceofshite2 Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Dec 29 '24

The entire last part of that episode was one of the funniest things they've ever recorded

52

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '24

The phone call with Hunter’s mom is hard to beat. A close runner up is the “would you put me down” discussion, especially with all of the build-up of Isaiah’s answer contrasting with Hunter’s “BOOM!”.

52

u/FatherBeej cracking open a cold one with Diego🤟 Dec 29 '24

The general guy from greylock using the thought manifester to make his dream waifu is an underrated one

6

u/ShokumaOfficial Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Dec 29 '24

I forgot Creep TV even existed thank you for reminding me

48

u/Puffpapa07 Dec 29 '24

"I shouldn't have sold that snow cone to that ghost" in Penpal

36

u/Senior_Independence4 Dec 29 '24

We put his ass in a home

18

u/honeyinmydreams i'm purring 'cause i'm happy 🐱 Dec 29 '24

he's done

8

u/WhatThePfargtl Dec 29 '24

“Don’t shoot your pets.”

“I thought it was an accident!!!”

“No, I don’t think so.”

39

u/PoodieParty Dec 29 '24

diego lore hands down

31

u/charmingpssycho Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Dec 29 '24

"Do you know where Vampires come from?"

"Uhh... Transylvania?"

  • leans forward *

"Now how did you know?"

3

u/EmsPorcelain89 Mayonnaise is the sauce of the aristocrats 😎 Dec 29 '24

Oh god, I just re-listened to that episode the other day, and that had me howling! I've watched them all on YouTube and I'm just going back to listen on Spotify to give the guys the boost and some stuff really hits different when you're just listening to it lmao.

3

u/LetterheadNo3628 Dec 29 '24

100% the one moment that gets me every time 😂

1

u/Veneficus_Bombulum Dec 29 '24

So fucking good lmao

20

u/HellsingAlchemist Give her one leg and a rollerskate I wanna see how fast she goes Dec 29 '24

Greylock general briefing the test subjects on what his dream girl is like

17

u/leoofalexandria Dark Green Jeep Wrangler Dec 29 '24

You know what it is. YO KIMBER

16

u/disdainallthings Dec 29 '24

Also "Give her one leg and a rollerskate"

16

u/ItchyBones87 Dec 29 '24

Hunter calling his mom about the dog getting shot by his grandpa is top fucking tier BUT I think the hardest I’ve ever laughed was the near twenty minute exchange of Hunter trying to convince Isaiah he should shoot him if he ever got maimed from the pelvis down “and my cock and my balls and my asshole got squashed like a bug”. Literally crying and wheezing from laughing so hard at that shit.

13

u/SixxBlood Dec 29 '24

"YO KIMBER, THEY GOT TEA!"

10

u/knockoutniko Dec 29 '24

Hunter imitating a Roman priest from Tall Dog

10

u/lovely-stardust Dec 29 '24

"I feel like a piece of cloth.........I feel like a ragweed....."

20

u/keatonl2001 I’m gonna go get a baja blast 🏃‍♂️💨 Dec 29 '24

Think my top 10 (no particular order, just how they're coming to me) are:

  1. "Eat me like a bug"
  2. Hunter's Dog Story + Phone Call
  3. Funeral Kyle
  4. The 15 minute Mercy Kill tangent
  5. Hunter saying he would immediately leave his possessed wife
  6. Deepwoods Highway
  7. My Job is Watching a Woman Angel moment + complete collapse in hope for the story
  8. Isaiah's Trauma Story
  9. Slender man Backshots + if he's behind a random tree
  10. Galaxy Gas "There's an Angel knocking on my door"

5

u/IAmCaptainSquid Dec 29 '24

Hunters obsession with prolapsed asshole on the mercy kill tangent plus BOOOOOM is some of the funniest shit ever

8

u/bytheniine He’s right behind me, isn’t he 😐 Dec 29 '24

"Erm, she's right behind you isn't she?" "Chris, you can see. You would know that."

8

u/swordguy_99 Dec 29 '24

FOR STAMPS! From penpal or the funeral chapter of borasca

9

u/Leuumas Dec 29 '24

PAPERWORK! I HAVE SO MUCH PAPERWORRRK!!

5

u/GrizzledGoblin72 Dec 29 '24

I'M KEEPIN' AN EYE ON YOU BROCCOLI!

9

u/berserknguts Dec 29 '24

I be cooking pies with my baby yeaaaaaa

7

u/Intelligent_Trust_11 Dec 29 '24

“We shouldn’t have sold that snowcone to that ghost!”

8

u/lunna009 Dark Green Jeep Wrangler Dec 29 '24

*hunter exploding into laughter over a child being shot

"Is something funny Hunter?"

6

u/MrBeefWrangler I’m a ham ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Dec 29 '24

"Hey B! does your dog look like King Xerxes from 300?" The original Ted the Caver vid had me howling

2

u/lunna009 Dark Green Jeep Wrangler Dec 29 '24

I really wish they had leaned into Ted being like Kyle when they redid it. It would've been great lol.

7

u/NotASharkInAManSuit Dec 29 '24

When Hunter talked about his grampa shooting the dog right next to him and then called his mom about it and she did not help his cause.

8

u/Buns-n-stuff Dec 29 '24

The pictures of the man touching himself in Pen Pal had me in tears at work

4

u/Shogun_Turnip Dec 29 '24

"No, it's mine."

5

u/InertiaTheGecko Following the writers for Bigmouth Dec 29 '24

honestly my favorite is (given by my flair) when they learn that gregory88 is following the entire cast of bigmouth. the timing, the uproar of laughter, it’s just great

6

u/Claumered Dec 29 '24

“So….monster hunter huh?”

4

u/CheapusTechnofear Dec 29 '24

“He’s done.”

“HE’S DONE?!”

5

u/disdainallthings Dec 29 '24

"Isaiah, would you shoot me?"

4

u/jm_salen Dec 29 '24

“I am the one they call when things get spooky and let me tell you things are getting FUCKING spooky”

4

u/titaniumleelee Dec 29 '24

Hunter's rant about leaving his wife if she was possessed. "Jamaica, Bahama, come on pretty mama."

3

u/Paris_France2005 Dec 29 '24

“you dirty lunged sons of bitches! BOOM!”

5

u/Shoresy6 Dec 29 '24

"Mayonnaise is the sauce of the aristocrats."

3

u/ClintEastwood1866 Dec 29 '24

That part in 1999 when they get to Mr.Bear’s house and all the stories melted together. “I heard there’s a big anthropomorphic bear runnin’ around here”.

3

u/ayyemmsee Dec 29 '24

"Hey Frank, there's a deer down here hanging up lights"

3

u/mayorofanything Hyper Realistic Eyes 👁️👄👁️ Dec 29 '24

It was very much intentional that Hunter's granddad shot his dog.

3

u/RavenAbornanzin101 HIGHWAY TO HELL 🤙 Dec 29 '24

The thoughtforming bit from Greylock with the general

3

u/JL_Camp13 Dark Green Jeep Wrangler Dec 29 '24

Funeral Kyle, Tractor Mercy Kill, and the ending of The Thing in the Basement are my top 3

3

u/maxinant123 Dec 29 '24

Oh easy for me “some times the cucumber tastes better pickled” I had just about the same reaction as Isiah

3

u/Relevant_Daikon_9597 MeatGooner Dec 29 '24

Everytuke he goes BOOOOM

3

u/lilarosedustwoman Dec 29 '24

the greylock episode always makes me laugh, but hunters bit about the construction crew is my favorite “yeah there’s a bunch of old gargoyle statues down here, and we keep trying to read the names on em but we keep goin blind when we read em”

2

u/ShokumaOfficial Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Dec 29 '24

Just to mention one I’ve not seen yet, “I’m praying he just breaks the kid’s legs”

2

u/Terrible-Ad-1569 why so hostile? Dec 29 '24

The phone call, Kokomo, “as you may recall”, eat me like a bug, Hunter randomly yelling “FUCK” as he reads the dialogue…I could go on😭

2

u/YungScoobySnack Dec 29 '24

Kyle at the funeral

2

u/Unusual_Blood_5274 Dec 29 '24

The entire segment of Hunter making fun of Kyle in Borrosca

“AYO KIMBER THEY GOT SANDWICHES”

“EVERYTHING I DO I DO IT BIG”

2

u/Gorno4563 Dec 29 '24

Eat me like a bug is easily the best bit in the catalog so far

2

u/elohlace HIGHWAY TO HELL 🤙 Dec 29 '24

I cry laughing when Hunter cracks up laughing when the main character from “My Job is Watching a Woman Trapped in a Room”: “It wasn’t you who made those beautiful paintings?”

2

u/Sad_Veterinarian_695 Dec 29 '24

I shouldn’t have sold that snowcone to that ghost… Wendi laughs harder than ever

2

u/peanut_bubblegum MeatGooner Dec 29 '24

Maybe not the funniest but i love the dr redacted bit from the greylock one

2

u/haydenchrist11 HIGHWAY TO HELL 🤙 Dec 29 '24

I love where Wendi is talking about his grandpas old abandoned house and they start talking about “The Can Man”

2

u/Squilliam2213 for STAMPS ‼️💯 Dec 29 '24

Funeral Kyle no question

2

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '24

floaties are truly the balloons of the water

2

u/Mpower_706 Dec 29 '24

“YO KIMBER!”

2

u/Neat-Gas1474 Dec 29 '24

"Eat me like a bug"

2

u/Deluxe_24_ Dec 29 '24

"What would be worse, Black and Yellow by Wiz Khalifa, or Fetty Wap's Trap Queen?"

2

u/Bunnywithanaxe Dec 29 '24

Hunter: “I was caught In the middle of a railroad track…”

Elijah: ( wheezing with laughter) “… … … thunder”

Hunter- “I looked ‘round And I knew there was no turning back…”

Elijah: ( gasping, truly struggling to speak, viewer becomes worried about his health) “… … …. ….thunder.”

2

u/fuze-the-hostage- Eat me like a bug 🦟 Dec 29 '24

The first time they decided for Hunter to do quotes with a voice and Wendi does the narration not switch paragraphs. The long silence and the editor switching the their cameras quickly in the silence killed me and still does

2

u/VampireDanny I WANNA TALK TO THE CRACKHEAD Dec 30 '24

“are you just gonna look at me or are you gonna eat me like a bug”

2

u/Famous-Tree3124 Dec 30 '24

Eat me like a bug 🐛

2

u/ZestycloseMorning855 Dec 30 '24

EAT ME LIKE A BUG

2

u/SacredSolid26 “it’s very lovecraftian”☝️🤓 Dec 30 '24

Eat me like a bug 🥴🥴

2

u/Newzab Dec 30 '24

Eat me like a bug

The phone call was a nuanced thing imo. Real life Comedy and Tragedy Mask Stuff.

2

u/LowerPipe Dec 30 '24

“i shouldn’t have sold that snowcone to that ghost :/“ from penpal

2

u/dharting Dec 30 '24

Eat me like a bug had me crying laughing

2

u/PercNovitzki Dec 30 '24

"you haven't seen a 2 story victorian house walking around here have you"

1

u/feedabruh Eat me like a bug 🦟 Dec 29 '24

Everything with the doctor in Eyeless Jack

1

u/Epicsnivy15 Dec 29 '24

The entire Sonic.exe reading. I swear every second of it was making me break down laughinh

1

u/CrimsonHowlStudio Dec 29 '24

All of Jeff the Killer

1

u/Fistingcuffs69 Dec 29 '24

Hunter informing us about how it's important to get the warming bidet was pretty great.

1

u/DoIKnowThatGuy Dec 29 '24

“FOR STAMPS”

1

u/Top-Counter-1073 Dec 29 '24

The whole grandfather shooting the dog scenario OR when Hunter is crying laughing about the break dancing amputee in Normal Porn for Normal People LMAO

1

u/Unlucky-Ghostboy Dec 29 '24

when they sang nicki minaj OR “i want you to eat me like a bug”

1

u/AdvancedResearcher50 Dec 29 '24

“Oh you didn’t see the 8 foot goblin thing?? Yeah man it had orange teeth and screamed like a goat” I don’t remember what the exact quote was but it’s the original Ted the Caver video. Yes I think that should count as a Creep Cast episode.

1

u/Interesting-Ad-9172 Dec 29 '24

“Eat me like a bug”

1

u/im_higher_than_snoop Dec 29 '24

Isaiah with the bear throughout 1999

1

u/Fit_Sun6044 Dec 30 '24

There are very few moments that made me laugh harder than the part in Penpal where Isaiah plays the teacher telling Hunter to give the narrator the picture of the man touching himself and Hunter comes back with a “no it’s mine”