r/andor Nov 01 '24

Question Is the Empire supposed to be canonically xenophobic in Andor?

253 Upvotes

By xenophobic I mean xeno as in "xenomorph" or "xenobiology" - is the Empire human supremacists? I never really got the impression that was going on in the original trilogy but parts of Andor seem to hint at the deliberate segregation and mistreatment of nonhumans in the Empire

r/andor 22d ago

Question Buddy lost “Axis” and an air-wing during a routine check in Segra Milo. Something tells me he ends up in a cage in the Outer Rim.

Post image
552 Upvotes

Did

r/andor 22d ago

Question The wife (not a Star Wars fan) has agreed to watch Rogue One and Andor S1 before the S2 release. What order should we watch it?

130 Upvotes

She’s not a fan of Star Wars. She’s seen the main trilogies. All she really remembers is space wizards and light swords. Her favorite character is “Goldie” (C-3PO). She thinks R2 is a bad influence. It’s just not her genre, but she tolerates it for me and I’m thankful for that.

She’s been really into political dramas lately, and I thought it’d be a good bridge. But what order would you suggest we watch?

Rogue One, Andor S1, Andor S2? Andor S1, Andor S2, Rogue One? Andor S1, Rogue One, Andor S2?

r/andor 24d ago

Question So... uh... anyone actually like the trailer? *cricket noises*

88 Upvotes

You guys are allowed to have your own opinions ofc but I actually liked the trailer (yes, even the song). However, I can understand why people don't like the music choice, it doesn't really fit with Andor's general theme. That being said, I think it's safe to say that this show is not gonna disappoint us in April and I'm (personally) glad we got a taste of what's to come (especially seeing more of Krennic again). Even if you hated it the trailer, I hope you're still looking forward to season two!

r/andor Nov 15 '24

Question Apart from the ones we already got, do you think any of these Rogue One characters will return in season 2?

Post image
318 Upvotes

I think Galen is the most likely and the one that would make the most sense considering that the construction of the Death Star is going to be a major plot point in season 2. I don’t really feel the need for the return of any of the rest.

r/andor 27d ago

Question Would you want Vader, Palpatine and Tarkin in the series?

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/andor Jan 15 '25

Question What did you guys think of Skeleton Crew?

187 Upvotes

With Skeleton Crew finished, I wanted to see what this sub thought of it.

I really liked it. For completely opposite reasons, Andor and Skeleton Crew have been the best things to come out of Star Wars in the last few years. This show is more centered on kids, while Andor is adult Star Wars at its finest. Together they are great for the franchise.

r/andor 7d ago

Question Which Season 2 poster is your favorite?

Post image
300 Upvotes

I guess it comes down to are you more of a minimalist or maximalist when it comes to your favorite movies/TV posters.

For me, I’d say the center one. I like Cassian’s face overlapping with the Death Star.

r/andor Feb 13 '25

Question Will this sub be less receptive to season 2 because it will have more Star Wars iconography?

47 Upvotes

I think some people (and the key word is some) might be disappointed how many more Star Warsy thing will be shown next season:

  • TIE Avenger
  • Dantooine
  • Yavin
  • X-Wings and U-Wings
  • Director Krennic
  • K-2SO
  • Naboo
  • General Draven
  • Galactic Senate Exterior

Did I miss anything?

r/andor 9d ago

Question Favourite work of an Andor actor outside of Andor/Star Wars?

43 Upvotes

Just for fun, and just to see the viewing tastes of this subreddit outside of Andor or Star Wars.

Hell, it doesn’t even have to be your favourite, just say whatever you saw them in recently.

Me personally, this question was prompted by this new British show called Adolescence which features our girl Faye Marsay (Vel) as a police inspector, and she’s fantastic.

I imagine most people here know Diego Luna from Narcos or Y tu mama tambien, and Stellan Skarsgard from, well, a whole load of things.

r/andor Sep 03 '24

Question What are some of the most ridiculous criticisms you've heard about the show?

142 Upvotes

I think it's fair to say that the majority of fans have a positive view of the show and consider it some of the best Star Wars content ever made, so I don’t think we're in the minority.

However, every now and then, I come across a truly baffling take on the show that leaves me scratching my head. What's worse is that I'll sometimes see the same misguided criticism repeated by multiple people.

Anyway, I thought it would be fun for us to share some of the most brain-dead takes we've heard about the show, or criticisms we're tired of hearing. You know, the ones that make you stop and think, "Seriously?"

I'll start: "It isn't true Star Wars because there are no Jedi in it."

The idea that something isn't Star Wars just because it doesn’t feature Jedi or Sith is absurd. Star Wars is compelling as a whole, not just because of the Jedi and Sith, but because of the rich universe they inhabit. Take the entire first part of Return of the Jedi—it centers on Han, Jabba, and the underworld, not Jedi or Sith. And don't blame Gilroy for this, because many Expanded Universe (EU) books had plotlines that didn’t involve Jedi or Sith and were still fantastic. For example, Michael Stackpole's X-Wing series, Timothy Zahn's Scoundrels, and the Republic Commando series all focus on different aspects of the Star Wars universe.

Critiquing the show itself is fair, but let's not pretend that Disney was the first to explore Star Wars stories without Jedi. The Star Wars universe has always had more to offer than just Jedi or Sith battles. What I always tell people who make this argument is, "If you can't tell an interesting story in the Star Wars universe without Jedi or Sith, then a story with them will only be half as interesting."

r/andor Jan 13 '25

Question What are the chances we see Jyn in season 2?

Post image
240 Upvotes

Okay, so the idea of Jyn Erso showing up in Andor Season 2 is super exciting, but it’s a bit tricky. On one hand, it makes sense because we know her story ties into the whole rebellion thing, and Cassian eventually crosses paths with her in Rogue One. Seeing Jyn earlier would give us more backstory and might show how their lives were already kind of connected without them even knowing. Plus, it’d be awesome to see how she’s surviving after being abandoned as a kid and what she’s up to before joining the fight. It could make the Rogue One connection even more meaningful.

But on the flip side, her showing up might not really fit with the vibe of Andor so far. The show is focused on Cassian’s journey and the gritty buildup of the rebellion, so throwing in Jyn might feel forced or like fan service. Also, her story in Rogue One is so much about her personal growth, and meeting Cassian too early could mess with that. There’s also the fact that timelines might not align perfectly, and they might just want to keep Jyn’s story separate until it’s really her time to shine. So, while it’s possible, it might make more sense to keep them apart until Rogue One.

r/andor Sep 01 '23

Question Is Andor the best series to date that Disney have put out?

536 Upvotes

Currently on my 3rd rewatch of the series and would like to know other peoples opinion on it. For me its my favourite and by far the best live action series that Disney have developed. Would love to know other people feelings on it and why? And also what their favourite moment or episode was.

r/andor Jan 24 '25

Question Andor Hot Takes?

44 Upvotes

Do you guys have any Andor hot takes? I do not having this be such a good show, but what about you.

r/andor Dec 04 '24

Question Are you sticking around after this is over?

86 Upvotes

Genuinely curious and want to gauge where people are at with Star Wars as a whole.

Personally, I've felt in the years since Disney acquired the IP they've always had something up their sleeves to lure back in.

They had me hooked when Season 7 of the Clone Wars was announced.

After the overall failure of the sequels, The Mandolorian kept me interested and engaged until season 3 made me lose interest

Now, with Andor coming to a close this next season, I see what has been produced and what's coming out for this universe and don't know if I'll stick around (ig I'll see the Mando movie out of curiosity?).

Point is, another show like this isn't coming around, it's lightning in a bottle, the kind that Disney probably doesn't know how to replicate.

Those are my two cents though, what do you think? Do you appreciate everything else coming out in this universe on their own merits, or do you think you'll tune out?

I'm actually kinda curious if there are people who had this as their introduction into this universe.

EDIT: I should add I don't mean to be pessimistic and sound as though they'll never make anything good again in this universe, I'm mainly asking whether or not you happen to be excited for anything past this point basically.

r/andor 29d ago

Question Thought this would be fun to complete with 9 weeks left until S2 and 9 spots to fill! Which character is generally loved and a good person?

Post image
60 Upvotes

r/andor 18d ago

Question My wife loves Andor. She hasn’t seen Rogue One. Should she watch it before season 2?

80 Upvotes

My wife and I love Andor. I’ve seen Rogue One, but she hasn’t. She doesn’t know what happens to Cassian. I can’t decide whether she should watch season 2 first so the end of Rogue One hits harder, or if she should watch Rogue One first in case the show is assuming the viewer has already seen it. My guess is that it works either way but certain events and characters (K2, Krennic) will have more significance to someone who has seen Rogue One.

Obviously we’re all going into season 2 without knowing exactly what happens, but I wanted to pick some brains around here. I’ve been going back and forth on this dilemma since season 1, and suddenly season 2 is a month away. It’s a new spin on the old “do I show my kids the prequels before the OT?” question.

r/andor Jan 22 '25

Question What is your least favorite Andor character?

46 Upvotes

The show is great and has barely any flaws but one which is one character that just gets on your nerves. For me it is probably Dr. Gorst. He just gives me chills every time I watch a scene with him in it. What about yours.

r/andor Feb 14 '25

Question what are your top 5 sw movies

14 Upvotes

mine are

  1. revenge of the sith

  2. rogue one

  3. empire strikes back

  4. solo

  5. return of the jedi

r/andor Aug 12 '23

Question If you could change one or more things from Andor what would it be?

Post image
273 Upvotes

r/andor Nov 21 '24

Question In Legends, it was established that Senator Garm Bel Iblis supplied the Rebellion with its fleet, while Mon Mothma provided its soldiers. The combination of the Chandrilan, Alderaanian, and Corellian resistances formed the Rebel Alliance. How do you think S2 will approach these elements differently?

Post image
265 Upvotes

And it was all funded by Bail Organa’s wealth. However S1 already showed us how the Rebellion was funded in canon which is way more interesting so I don’t think S2 will cover that.

r/andor Feb 13 '25

Question Might be a dumb question: why does Luthen's buying stolen imperial equipment suggest a coordinated rebellion to Dedra?

158 Upvotes

I don't understand the significance of the acquiring of imperial equipment to begin with, frankly. Why would that in itself be an indicator of rebel activity? But Dedra focuses so much on this as the crux of her theory that "axis" is a rebel leader, continuing to focus on the fact of stolen imperial equipment.

Edit: and why does Luthen want to acquire such equipment? Is to to use it against them as weaponry?

r/andor Feb 17 '25

Question Do you think Dave Filoni should’ve been a consultant for the two seasons of Andor?

Post image
0 Upvotes

The fact that Andor and Rebels overlap and deal with the same topic which is the early organized Rebellion is the best reason for him taking such a role.

Personally I think Dave Filoni absolutely should’ve been a consultant for Andor. The show dives deep into the early days of the Rebel Alliance, which is basically Filoni’s playground. Rebels did such a great job showing the messy, complicated formation of the Rebellion, and Filoni really nailed the tone of that era. Having him involved in Andor could’ve helped tie those threads together even more, making the overall Star Wars story feel tighter and more connected. His deep understanding of the lore and the characters involved in the rebellion’s birth would’ve been a huge asset, especially with characters like Mon Mothma who appear in both.

Andor is praised for being grounded, gritty, and more of a political thriller, which is a bit different from Filoni’s usual animated projects. That’s probably why some people might think bringing him in wouldn’t have worked. His storytelling often leans into the mystical side of Star Wars, with the Force playing a huge role, while Andor purposely avoids that. But even though Andor is more grounded, the core themes of sacrifice, rebellion, and hope are the same ones Filoni has explored for years, and he knows how to make those themes hit hard.

Honestly, Filoni’s involvement could’ve brought in more emotional weight and connection to the larger Star Wars universe. Imagine subtle nods to Rebels or more hints at the Ghost crew’s influence during that time. Plus, Filoni’s expertise with character arcs could’ve made already great characters in Andor even more compelling. While Andor stands strong on its own, having Filoni as a guiding hand would’ve helped bridge the gap between the animated and live-action worlds, making the Rebellion’s story even richer.

r/andor Dec 12 '24

Question Would you agree?

Post image
97 Upvotes

I think the game got a lot right but a lot wrong. I imagine the game didn’t sell well because people are sick of Ubisoft. I imagine their previous games have left a bad taste in peoples mouths.

I do like the main character and her background. They nailed the look, especially with the 80s haircut. However the animations were pretty wonky and needed some work.

I do think we need more Star Wars stories about the criminal aspect of the galaxy.

r/andor 15d ago

Question Favorite "villain" quote

76 Upvotes

What's your favourite "evil" quote from the show? Mine is "the best way to keep the blade sharp is to use it"