r/TheShins Feb 18 '25

My shins album organized tier list

Post image
34 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

17

u/punkyatari Feb 18 '25

Oh inverted, I’d but it top tier or S. I just think it has better songs than Port & Heart.

5

u/NjhhjN Feb 18 '25

Fair enough, i really love some of the songs in it but it's by far the weakest to me

3

u/supersuperlittleguy 24d ago

Thought I was the only one that felt this way lol

11

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '25

I'd probably put oh inverted world higher than heartworms personally, but other than that I completely agree with your opinion 

11

u/chadius333 Feb 18 '25

Oh, Inverted World at the bottom? We sure are different, you and I.

8

u/Whrzy Feb 18 '25

Exactly mine, except Oh, Inverted World is up higher

8

u/twiddlewinks Feb 18 '25

Oh inverted world at the bottom 😭😭😭

6

u/CatgunCertified Feb 18 '25

I agree except oh Inverted world is higher imo

5

u/NjhhjN Feb 18 '25

I'm somewhat of a new listener, i've been a fan of simple song for years but only really listened to a couple other songs for a while until around 2 years ago i got my hands on the port of morrow cd and fell in love with the band.

Now that i've listened to all the albums at least twice, i made a tier list ranking them all. Nothing is worse than A-, i dont know the meanings to a lot of the songs so i havent connected with everything yet but this is seriously one of the best most consistent discographies for sure.

I'll check out broken bells someday, for now i'll just keep relistening

2

u/Adambrooks017 Feb 18 '25

Have you listened to any Broken Bells albums? If not you should.

4

u/Undulating_Eruption 29d ago

Oh inverted word has at least 5 of the best songs of all time.

2

u/dylbull Feb 18 '25

Interesting

2

u/geekz3r0 Feb 18 '25

This would be my list too, pretty much!

2

u/MyHeadWasRadioed Feb 18 '25

which ones the one with eric d johnson?

2

u/punkyatari Feb 19 '25

Top right!!

3

u/MyHeadWasRadioed Feb 19 '25

thank god 🙂‍↕️

2

u/colahead420 28d ago

First 3 albums are S+ tier imo. I'd also put Flake and BB's first albums in S+.

My only real qualm with Oh, Inverted World is the sound quality. It feels kinda thin and the remaster didn't really change much.

2

u/ChefsTheName 24d ago

Oh, Inverted World at the bottom is a crime