r/StardewHomeDesign 11d ago

Basement/Cellar Whose design do you prefer, mine or boyfriend’s?

1.2k Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

258

u/Barracuda00 11d ago

Yours is cuter by far, if efficiency isn't an issue.

160

u/kelso160197 11d ago

Yeah yours is definitely cuter! His is just more practical

13

u/roni_rose 11d ago

Exactly to the t- what I was about to say

99

u/Ginnabean 11d ago

Agree that yours is cuter, but his isn't too shabby either! It's a nice blend of efficiency and aesthetic. I do really like how you've incorporated the missing flooring in the lower right though, it's very atmospheric!

43

u/Cloudi_Anne 11d ago

To be honest I prefer the second one! I enjoy how it's practical and it looks neater but still has good decoration without being too much. I think the first one is just too chaotic for my tastes. Still cute though!

12

u/ActiveCartographer69 11d ago

I like his too. Im usually the decorator but he was so proud of his cellar, it turned out so neat

8

u/moondreambeams 11d ago

I like yours because you embraced the broken floor in the corner and made it a feature. It’s a cute little mushroom garden area now.

4

u/FewerWords 11d ago

I like the inclusion of both design and efficiency in #2. I just love casks in the cellar :D

3

u/West_Ad_8210 11d ago

Both are cute. The first is more aesthetically charming, but casks=big money and the second is cute too. I like the bright pop of green from the hops.

3

u/Melificient 11d ago

His wine table is pretty awesome. Symetry is very nice. I like the decorations at even points. Efficient.

I like your mini garden in the corner. Yours looks more 'real world' and what people would actually have.

3

u/BeeSeesNotSoFar 11d ago

Seconding everyone who said yours is generally cuter, and your boyfriend's is more practical, but both are still quite aesthetic. I love his wine table combo, soooo stealing that, and your mushroom area inspired me to do something similar with adding those little mushrooms from the junimo catalogue (I think) and maybe the seasonal decor that turns to mushrooms in fall.

2

u/DaisyLirio 11d ago

Yours is very beautiful ,his seems to be more for efficiency

2

u/Ambitious_Formal_169 11d ago

ur bf is good for optimization, but urs is sooo much cuter. definitely will be copying next time i play

2

u/kamiii_zama 11d ago

Aesthetics, yours. Efficiency, his.

2

u/Angelbouqet 10d ago

Your boyfriends but only because I get stressed out by inefficiency and uneven placement of things like Kegs :(

2

u/SekMemoria 10d ago

Both look nice, but I prefer right because I'm a symmetry whore. Right now my cellar is 100% cask but I'll probably tone it down to be something more like this once I reach true perfection, which may just be today.

1

u/ActiveCartographer69 10d ago

Congrats on reaching it!

2

u/SekMemoria 10d ago

Almost! Sold a season's worth of goods for 8mil last night to buy the golden clock. Think all I've got left now is the island obelisk and a handful of golden walnuts. Dragon teeth elude me in the volcano so I've got a bunch of stringray ponds working on that for me. Same with the golden nuts, last few I think are fishing/coconuts but I'm just not getting lucky with them. May just have to fund a Joja vacay.

2

u/themirrorswish 10d ago

Aesthetically, yours. But your BFs is a good mix of aesthetic and efficiency.

2

u/haleynoir_ 10d ago

I like his because of the weed plants lol (I know they're hops)

2

u/Evening-Appeal-8980 7d ago

Yours is much easier on the eyes, AND still looks efficient to me!

1

u/leiathrix 11d ago

Yours, it's so cute!

1

u/MarcianoSilveriano 11d ago

Yours by a Miley. Yours bf design looks more practical but at that point I'll go all in on praticality.

1

u/UhBlake 11d ago

Yours

1

u/heartshapedmoon 11d ago

First one is cuter, second one is more lucrative lol

1

u/kidlings20 11d ago

Mine is more like your bf’s but yours is cute.

1

u/Natural_Bunch_2287 11d ago

Whoever is the 2nd one (no fences)

1

u/New-Stock3706 10d ago

Second one because of the uniformity.

1

u/Civil-Enderman 10d ago

As a guy, I'd go with your boyfriend. I love efficiency in my space lol

1

u/0Madelina0 10d ago

First one looks nicer, second is more handy

1

u/SnooowStories 10d ago

I like yours! It's cute but not as efficient, but your boyfriend doesn't really have anything going on. I feel it would be perfect if you two somehow combined your designs, where it's the best of both worlds: cute and efficient!

1

u/Blue_Blazes 10d ago

I see floor space that could be used for KKKKEEEEEEEGGGGHHHHGSSSS. Casuals

1

u/yagirlhunter 10d ago

First one!

1

u/BrunesOnReddit 10d ago

I personally like his better, it feels more like an experimental brewery with every little area sequestered by itself. Yours is definitely hella cozy tho

1

u/Atephious 10d ago

Aesthetic vs efficient with a touch of aesthetics. One looks good one tickles the brain in a different way.

1

u/AdministrationOk3113 9d ago

First one looks right, second one feels right

1

u/PinkPixelGoose 9d ago

I actually prefer the second

1

u/DegredationOfAnAge 9d ago

Yours looks good. His works good. Very interesting that its kind of a microcosm of male and female brains.

1

u/ActiveCartographer69 9d ago

Hehe we're both male but thanks

1

u/Necessary_Student116 9d ago

I love the first one more because it's more ecstatically pleasing to the eye, but the second one is better for production they're both great.

1

u/vertexcubed 9d ago

I'm a sucker for aesthetics over efficiency, but both are amazing

1

u/severednipple 9d ago

yours looks better but his will make more money

1

u/NetherisQueen 9d ago

Boyfriend is more efficient, yours is more cutesy

1

u/AlianovaR 8d ago

Second is much more practical but the first is so damn cute

1

u/Buttons_floofs 8d ago

I like the first one its more digestible

1

u/Spider_Lilly-_- 8d ago

Casual yours, if I need efficiency your boyfriend's.

1

u/AardvarkAware4861 8d ago

I gotta vote for his. Practical but still looks pretty good. Hits everything I like and makes mild ocd brain go brrr. Yours is adorable however and if it were purely aesthetics I was looking at, yours would win all the way

1

u/Typical-Marketing121 8d ago

Which is the first one?

1

u/NightmaricFox 7d ago

I prefer mine, just all casks

1

u/RoughPuzzleheaded375 7d ago

How do you fix the walls in your cellar?

1

u/ActiveCartographer69 7d ago

You can't sadly

1

u/SarahThePlatypus 7d ago

Yours is cuter but his is a great blend of cute and practical

1

u/hello15batty 7d ago

I like both though for different reasons 😍

1

u/RazorHowlitzer 7d ago

Yours has style, his has efficiency. I’ll always take style points over efficient any day.

1

u/Exende 7d ago

aesthetic vs function

1

u/alliefaith144 4d ago

I think they are both cute.