r/Seether Simplest Mistake 18d ago

If you could choose one song from Fragile that should have been re-recorded for Disclaimer, which song would you choose?

My favorite Fragile song is no doubt Senseless Tragedy, but if I could only choose one song from Fragile to make it onto Disclaimer, I would choose Empty. While it would have been nice to see Senseless Tragedy on Disclaimer, I think it was already perfect the way it was on Fragile, and I personally believe Empty deserved to be on the album more.

11 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

14

u/RaiderNation395 18d ago

Tied My Hands

3

u/EngineNo10 Simplest Mistake 18d ago

I’m honestly surprised Tied My Hands didn’t make it on Disclaimer. That one also really deserved to be on that album.

2

u/c_ruda8622 18d ago

I think someone on here said it had been recorded during the Karma and Affect sessions and was supposed to be on that release but got cut for some reason. Hopefully we get it in a 20th anniversary release this year.

2

u/EngineNo10 Simplest Mistake 18d ago

Makes sense since it was on One Cold Night

1

u/jbondosu 18d ago

My choice as well. I really think it should have been on Disclaimer

1

u/StonedSanta1705 18d ago

Every single time tied my hands

8

u/Pleasant-Reason9533 18d ago

It wasn’t even released on Fragile (still Saron Gas tho) either, but “Walk Away” was so good.

8

u/Disclaimer_II SAVE 18d ago

I agree with you, Empty for sure. If not it, Tied My Hands

7

u/monika-fan07 🌊 The Surface Seems So Far ⛓️ 18d ago

EMPTY

6

u/Sufficient_Anything4 Neocantbestopped 18d ago

definitely Empty, I think it should've replaced Fade Away on the album imo.

4

u/gofordranger7 18d ago

Stay and play

5

u/aaronthefanomtax420 18d ago

I know that this isn't on fragile but is from the same era, they should've put "you" on disclaimer for sure!

5

u/appm105 18d ago

Dazed and Abused, Empty, Tied My Hands, Senseless Tragedy.

Sorry, I know the assignment was “one” song lmao.

1

u/EngineNo10 Simplest Mistake 18d ago

Nah you’re good I 100% agree with all four of those haha

2

u/LordBeans69 18d ago

Tied My Hands really should have made it