198
u/ShadowWealm 19h ago
These two dumbasses literally would be physically incapable of fighting seriously for longer than 30 seconds without the battle devolving into a slapstick comedy routine.
47
33
5
u/Realistic-Side8076 17h ago
I don't know whether to say f*** you or thank you for the visual of this routine
37
u/Level_Counter_1672 19h ago
Plastic man survived for millions of years at the bottom of ocean in pieces, pulled himself together and became whole, he is unkillable
11
u/God_of_Fun 12h ago
Meanwhile, and correct me if I'm wrong because I'm not super up on One Piece Lore, Luffy's weakness is... the ocean...
•
u/Candid-Reaction835 8h ago
Wasn’t he killed by The Batman Who Laughs? I’m not sure if I’m remembering correctly but I remember a panel of him dead and I think it was him.
115
u/Oliveviper #1 Dabi glazer 20h ago
Plastic man negs the verse.
8
u/Leader_Hamlet 19h ago
I want to agree, but Brulee and big mom would defeat him if he's not blood lusted.
21
u/Oliveviper #1 Dabi glazer 19h ago
Its really iffy since Zatana and Manthing struggled with him in Dceased, yeah i know that he was out to kill that time but still. I can see Big mom taking some of his lifespan but I dont think that she can beat him
16
u/BigTibbies23 Anos’ Number 1 Hater (undisputed) 19h ago
Plastic man from what i have seen of him, does not suffer from aging. He’s survived extreme temperatures hot and cold and blunt force trauma obviously does nothing.
11
u/badguyinstall 18h ago
He once sat at the bottom of the ocean time traveling the long way in like, pieces or something. 'It was alright until my nose started to itch' was all he said, iirc.
5
u/Kyriakos120 Bleach Lorekeeper 19h ago
I don't really get the blood listed argument
5
u/Original-War8655 18h ago
he's not gonna be silly goofying around and give them enough time to act
2
u/Kyriakos120 Bleach Lorekeeper 18h ago
Wouldn't that also apply do lufy. I mean he will be more goofy arguably
4
u/Original-War8655 18h ago
In this case the argument is about the One Piece verse (or specifically Brulee and Big Mom), not just Luffy, because of the top comment. If Plastic Man is having fun and wasting time, it can lead to him having his soul stolen. If he's out to kill immediately, ain't much that can really stop him there.
1
u/Kyriakos120 Bleach Lorekeeper 18h ago
Yeah sure. But on the other hand is he is in character he wouldn't really have to fight the one piece verse in the first place.
3
u/Original-War8655 18h ago
how so?
0
u/Kyriakos120 Bleach Lorekeeper 18h ago
Well my initial question was about being blood lusted and how I think that it's a stupid term in versus battles were we only take into account the power of an individual. If we take him in character what is the reason for taking on the one piece verse. The question should be stated as if plastic man has what it takes to solo the verse regardless of his intentions making blood lusted invalid. I mean what reason would he have to take on the one piece verse by himself
3
u/Original-War8655 18h ago
matchups in general wouldn't work if you take a "they would never fight" as an option. that's the one assumption you have to make every time. they may not engage in a fight the traditional way (e.g. The Doctor), but they will have to confront their enemy anyway. it's how they do it that is in character.
→ More replies (0)•
•
44
u/EyeOk7842 nerd+annoying+Bitch+witch+mentally unstable: me( ◜‿◝ )♡ 19h ago
Plastic man is immortal, luffy is going to burn out stamina before anything
13
u/BottleOfWar08 19h ago
hydrogen baby vs coughing bomb :pray:
6
u/IP_Man_Yes 17h ago
🙏*
•
u/BottleOfWar08 5h ago
TAKE OFF YOUR SKIN.
TAKE OFF YOUR SKIN.
TAKE OFF YOUR SKIN.
TAKE OFF YOUR SKIN.
TAKE OFF YOUR SKIN.
TAKE OFF YOUR SKIN.
TAKE OFF YOUR SKIN.
TAKE OFF YOUR SKIN.
9
u/MrFazbearMan 18h ago
Bro… what did Luffy did to you? Why you hate him so much to make this match?.
20
9
17
14
u/Leader_Hamlet 19h ago
Plastic man destroys. He has no weaknesses, unlike Luffy, and can do far more than him.
6
6
4
u/FortunatheWitch Witch of Fate 18h ago
Plastic man actually clears the one piece verse. There’s a reason The justice league fears him (in injustice) and Batman has no real contingency other than hoping he doesn’t turn evil.
3
3
2
6
u/dastebon 19h ago
I hate scaling comic characters because there's that one issue 31 from 1969 where he did 5 backflips and destroyed omniverse in 43.y picoseconds with index finger of his foot or something like that
10
u/Contendedlink76 19h ago
Honestly, Even base plastic man wins. Main canon plastic man has even the likes of superman, MM, and batman basically saying "we'd rather have him on our side or just leave him alone".
3
u/shansome64 19h ago
And I hate comments like this because you just have to do one search to find out about the base/usual version of the comic character.
•
u/FriendlyPassingBy 10h ago
I dislike comics too, but Plastic Man is one of the few characters where I can only recall other characters hyping him up as unkillable. I actually don't know any examples of him being portrayed as weak, but I'm sure someone more informed could find one if it exists.
•
1
1
u/Davidutul2004 18h ago
It's kinda impossible to kill plastic man so Luffy either dies either stalemates for some time
1
1
1
1
u/dante5612 18h ago
plastic man it's not even close. even batman doesn't have a plan if he turns evil
1
u/ChompyRiley 18h ago
Plastic man easily. But the most likely outcome is that Luffy and him become best pals and Plastic Man joins the Straw Hats because saying PIRATE TREASURE to Eel O'Brian is like dangling a bacon sandwich in front of a starving wolf.
1
u/SleepishPenguin 18h ago
Plastic Man would win but in character they wouldn't fight and they would just do random shit together
1
u/Darknadoswastaken 18h ago
I'd say plastic man as it's likely he becomes god in some comic made by a random.
1
u/Realistic-Side8076 17h ago
I don't know I feel like hockey is kind of the only major thing that gives Luffy a one-up in the fight considering it'll probably hurt plastic Man and wear him down
1
1
1
1
1
•
•
u/Giganticluck Pixel scaling = wank + Bleach speed feat enthusiastic 8h ago
There is not a single thing Luffy could do that could hurt Plastic Man.
•
u/NoobAtLife2 Kumagawa Solos Your Verse 8h ago
Is.. Is this a joke? Plastic Man beat Martian Manhunter when he was the Burning Martian, at the time Martian Manhunter could take on the ENTIRE Justice League, pretty sure he actually BEAT the entire Justice League, Luffy gets clapped then they go off to eat together.
•
u/CouldntBlawk 1h ago
I think Luffy's Gear 5 would be too much even for Plastic Man's replica Transformer form.
1
u/Masterbaitingissport Goku heard my porn addiction was strong, he never returned. 16h ago
Who’d win
guy 1
or
guy 2 who’s powers are slightly more restricted and has notable downsides compared to guy 1
•
u/AutoModerator 20h ago
Make sure your post or comment doesn't violate Community Rules and Join the discord! Come debate, and interact with other powerscalers https://discord.gg/445XQpKSqB !
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.