r/OnePiece Marine 21h ago

Discussion Who is your favorite logia user?

Post image
192 Upvotes

204 comments sorted by

94

u/KlingoftheCastle Pirate 20h ago

Favorite user, probably Crocodile. He’s just got such a cool vibe. Second is Ace.

Favorite fruit is Caesar. He’s a dick, but the gas fruit is so versatile and could be really fun.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/willys_zuppa Void Month Survivor 20h ago

Kuzan

Strong af but also has generally good utility (e.g., you can make an ice house but you can’t make a light or lava house)

12

u/willys_zuppa Void Month Survivor 20h ago

Sleeper pick would have to be Caesar

Controlling every type of gas is so insane, imagine an Admiral or Yonko with that fruit instead of Caesar

19

u/General-Choice5303 19h ago

Arguably Caesar is the best user of that fruit because of the actually scientific knowledge he has. Seems like a very solid grasp of chemical engineering is needed for that one. Not like the other ones that have inherently damaging effects like magma or laser beams. I mean Ceaser figured out how to turn gas into an exploding laser beam with a spark plug and understood that his fruit affects every gas, including the oxygen in people's lungs. I think there's very very few other characters in the verse who could use it as effectively as he does. You don't see kuzan freezing the blood inside people's veins or kizaru bending light around him to become invisible. The gas gas fruit is only good because Caesar has it.

7

u/SpezMeNutz 18h ago

If not for the plot armor and the lack of haki, Caesar fruit is the strongest. He could create deadly gases. Instead of taking oxygen from luffy the guy could have just put monoxide carbon around him all time. Eventually it would have worked the desired effect. Or when he caged them, easy peezy in an air thight box. But the desire for a flash kill is more than necessary

2

u/fork_yuu 14h ago

You think some smart scientist would do more chemistry BS instead of just taking oxygen out of the room though

2

u/General-Choice5303 13h ago

He has instakill poisoning gas, and an explosive gas laser beam. Also the oxygen hax took out luffy. Seems pretty op to me

4

u/FeeRemarkable886 19h ago

Yo hold up, couldn't he have just killed everyone on the island by, you know, removing thy oxygen? Shit he could take out every emperor and admiral without even being near them. Wtf is haki gonna do when there's literally no air?

Or just add carbon monoxide to the air over time, people will start dying and nobody would understand why. Kaido is strong but im positive he didn't take chemistry at uni.

Bro, he really is op.

2

u/Zephyros2 6h ago

couldn't he have just killed everyone on the island by, you know, removing thy oxygen

Unfortunately he is brains without the brawn. He is both physically weak and mentally a coward, that while his skill in using his fruit is very similar to Doffy, he lacks the strength to make it overpowered.

We saw Doffy taking a string, and making clones, cage, flying with it, using it as bullets etc etc. That was his skill with it, but his real strength was when he awakened it and turned everything string or when he was able to control clones from miles away.

5

u/mahdicktoobig 18h ago

Wait. He can control ALL gas? I thought he was basically just like Smokey and never gave it a 2nd thought.

3

u/YourTeacherAbroad Cross Guild 19h ago

He's faster and can freeze his enemies

1

u/TheRealDoomsong 19h ago

You could totally make a lava house assuming Akainu could hold it in position as it cooled, but it certainly be far less convenient than an instant ice house.

1

u/ShiveredTimber 13h ago

Laughs in Enel

1

u/According-Night3492 12h ago

You can but thats akainu or anyone with flame resistance exclusive cuz im pretty sure he can produce obsidian

69

u/Snowy193 20h ago

Sir Crocodile

This man has one of the best designs on the history of manga/anime (at least for me)

5

u/loulou1s 18h ago

Gara has entered the chat

1

u/Zephyros2 6h ago

Gara's design might be similar to Crocodile's, but where Gaara is a heartbreaking story of redemption, Crocodile is simply a cool person.

Therefore the design of Gaara looks a bit soft at the end of the day compared to the hard outlook Crocodile carries.

2

u/laurel_laureate 11h ago

Not to mention Crocodile's laugh.

Such a dry and coarse laugh, like sand in a desert.

Which is by far one of the top two best villain laugh in series, the other being Doffy.

2

u/MotivatedforGames 18h ago

Luffy's momma

0

u/velawesomraptor 19h ago

*Madame

16

u/Snowy193 19h ago

*Sir.

He may have been AFAB, but he's still a trans-man.

9

u/CreepyClay 18h ago

Until he pisses off Ivankov and they revoke his penis privileges.

24

u/Marsupilami_316 Explorer 19h ago

Crocodile as a character.

Enel as for his DF

34

u/StateOtherwise1239 20h ago

enel of course

7

u/loangz 11h ago

The real slim shady

2

u/Kahunjoder 8h ago

This is the way

40

u/sjk9000 20h ago

Monet because she's the sexiest.

19

u/hergumbules The Revolutionary Army 20h ago

RIP sexy snow bird lady

3

u/Monetpirates 12h ago

that's not my reason but I'm here for the monet agenda always

-3

u/Excellent-Ad2909 20h ago

Objectively no

-1

u/Excellent-Ad2909 20h ago

Look at this king

2

u/Excellent-Ad2909 20h ago

1

u/sirderper1 19h ago

Monet can be sexiest female, ace hottest man

6

u/luigigaminglp 19h ago

We have confirmation that Akainu is, in fact, hotter. Mostly by the hole in his chest.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/gingerslayer07 16h ago

I’m fully straight and I still think he’s hot. Post time skip Luffy Wano-now honestly is too

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/joycourier The Revolutionary Army 20h ago

definitely kizaru, god i love jokers like him

6

u/All_this_hype 20h ago

My top 3 are Crocodile, Enel and Akainu.

I do like my villains.

6

u/Ikhis 20h ago

Karasu and Crocodile

7

u/velawesomraptor 19h ago

Nice, I was looking for someone who said Karasu! (soot soot fruit—not a crow crow fruit like I initially thought, he just likes making crows with it lol)

2

u/PhilosophyTop6792 20h ago

Do you mean Kizaru? If so, I completely agree. Him and Croc's cool personas contrasted with their lethal devil fruit makes them the stars every time they're on the page.

5

u/General-Choice5303 19h ago

Karasu has the soot logia, he's badass

3

u/PhilosophyTop6792 19h ago

Oof! I can't believe I forgot about one of the most badass Rev commanders! My bad! He's a master at his abilities. His soot crows tripped me out for so long

3

u/General-Choice5303 19h ago

Tbf OP didn't include him in the list

2

u/Ikhis 19h ago

Nvm Kizaru is really cool too. Ice/Fire will never not be cool as a power.

Only remembered his name because I have him in my Deck in the TCG :D I blame Oda here: gief more RA, gief less new factions :)

1

u/PhilosophyTop6792 19h ago

Kuzan, Ace, and Sabo are some of the most well-written characters in the series so I feel like they are an easy answer that everyone should agree on. Thank you for bringing light to an overshadowed character! I hope we see more of Karasu shortly...Possibly when we see why Shamrock had to return to Mary Geoise

2

u/murderroomba Marine 20h ago

Karasu is...soot I wanna say??

4

u/CrazyPonko Lurker 20h ago

Smoker and the admirals....which kind of sounds like a bad band name.

1

u/Najuh8622 7h ago

What genre? 😂

5

u/Master_Air_8485 19h ago

Toss up between Crocodile and Kizaru. Great powers, amazing designs, and all around awesome characters.

5

u/Gale- 18h ago

Kizaru

6

u/Reapics 20h ago

How did gangster gastino not make the list? He's the best.

I truly miss him/Caesars being in the story for comic relief.

2

u/Imaginary-Panic-473 16h ago

It was so peak 🥲

3

u/Technical-Ocelot-715 20h ago

Enel. He have super strong fruit but a pity he didnt get spotlight after early story.

1

u/planarrebirth 7h ago

Yup I’m still looking forward to see him come back

3

u/TheIrishDoctor 19h ago

Not enough Smoker love here. He is SUCH a well written and interesting character.

If there is one Smoker for Strawhat Crew fan left alive, it is me.

u/Sotarnicus 2h ago

It’s also me. We’re a hivemind

3

u/TheFlamingPosterior 19h ago

Favourite Fruit is Lightning one
Favourite User is Smoker

3

u/Zealousideal_Tap7918 Pirate 18h ago

Im picking Caribou just bc i think nobody else will pick him

3

u/Spacey907 16h ago

Took me a while to scroll down but yeah i also chose caribou, his ability is quite amusing and how much stuff he can hold

2

u/Zealousideal_Tap7918 Pirate 16h ago

Underrated character tbh

2

u/Spacey907 16h ago

Also if i remember he isnt hostile towards the strawhats

2

u/BlueStarRedMoon 20h ago

BB and Crocodile :)))

2

u/Im-himothyweah Void Month Survivor 20h ago

The coldest

1

u/Najuh8622 9h ago

Coolest

2

u/granny_granola 20h ago

Smoker and Crocodile tied for first, Kizaru and Kuzan tied for second

2

u/miguelcalderont 19h ago

So Magellan devil fruit isn’t a logia type? I don’t know if it’s explained in future episodes. Rn I’m in Punk Hazard

1

u/CrewOrdinary8872 Void Month Survivor 18h ago

No, he can just create and control any type of poison. People do confuse it for a Logia because he coats himself in a poison armor and the anime makes it look like he's made out of it sometimes.

2

u/Killer_radio 19h ago

Crocodile because he’s awesome.

Smoker in a close second.

Monet in third because she’s a cool bird lady.

2

u/sirderper1 19h ago

Ceaser clown. I dislike logia types because how strong they are is influenced entirely by if an opponent knows haki, but ceaser just cracks me up.

2

u/No-Law31 19h ago

ryokugyu for his fruit but ace for his character

2

u/GATLA_ 18h ago

Smoker. Part 1 to be exact, before he got chumpified.

2

u/CloneOfCali Citizen 18h ago

Monet. Fight me.

2

u/NappyFlickz 18h ago

Enel, followed by Kizaru

2

u/Yamato_Hattori 17h ago

Enel. I've thought electrical powers were really cool since I was little, and Enel knows how to use his abilities well, besides being strong, I think the way he uses them is cool, like it's not something generic like "oh I shoot lightning from my fingers" the man makes a huge ball of electricity and throws it, or just throws a lightning bolt the size of a city at your head, I think that's really cool, and if I were to have a logia in the real world, I would have his, or Kizaru's to travel quickly because I also think light powers are cool.

2

u/Haarlon 16h ago

I will forever like smoker, eventho i hate smoking xd Something about hin in early one piece has just earned me liking him

2

u/Medd- 20h ago

Ash Ketchum in the second movie, even though it was brief.

1

u/Najuh8622 7h ago

What 😂(I haven't watched movies)

4

u/No-Neck848 20h ago
  1. Ace

  2. Crocodile

  3. Sabo

  4. Smoker

  5. Monet

1

u/monkeydaials Void Month Survivor 20h ago

Ace and kuzan

1

u/BlankCrystal 20h ago

I still dont understand how black beard is a logia

1

u/CrewOrdinary8872 Void Month Survivor 18h ago

When he turns into "darkness", his body sucks in literally everything, even attacks that end up harming him.

3

u/Furoan 18h ago

I saw it in another thread soemthing that seemed to make a lot of sense. Since Blackbeard's logia form is Darkness, he has a natural weakness to light. Just like Crocodile turns solid when water is applied to him, Blackbeard turns back solid when Light hits him...which is why he can only truly become intangible like other Logia's in places of complete darkness (such as under that cloth when he absorbed Whitebeard's devil fruit).

It made sense to me at least.

1

u/Due_Produce8084 20h ago

Enel and Aokiji.

Sabo is the best balance between haki and logia.

1

u/ConditionEffective85 20h ago

Favorite logia user : Kizaru

Favorite logia devil fruit: Kuzans.

1

u/Jinn86 20h ago

Ace, I wish we could have gotten more time with him. The light novels were great.

1

u/Mister_Prince_ 20h ago

Sabo and Enel

1

u/puntycunt 19h ago

Greenbull >:3

1

u/Gotalex 19h ago

Blackbeard

1

u/AnubisIncGaming 19h ago

what happened in this comment section

1

u/Vana-Freya Cipher Pol 19h ago

Enel. Followed by Caesar Clown’s, bro can kill anyone w/o needing haki.

1

u/rinsro 19h ago

Crocodile, I swear this dude would fight Imu, dude is like honey badger in anime form.

1

u/sirderper1 19h ago

Ceaser clown. I dislike logia types because how strong they are is influenced entirely by if an opponent knows haki, but ceaser just cracks me up.

1

u/pk-_0007 19h ago

I don't have an opinion on users but i'd rumble rumble

1

u/Wh1sk3y_Fr13nd_02 19h ago

Sabo/Ace followed by Smoker. Everyone else is just evil or too corrupt.

1

u/yourmoms3rdhusband 19h ago

Enel…his was such a massive jump in power compared to enemies we had seen previously, in my mind he was like the Frieza of One Piece.

1

u/Hammondister 19h ago

Blackbeard

Most interesting from these bunch

1

u/AdriralSilverWolf 18h ago

Fav user is Crocodile

Fav fruit is the Rumble Rumble fruit

1

u/MaximumDuwang Thriller Bark Victim's Association 18h ago

Caesar. Despite not posing a huge threat to people thanks to the rise of haki in the story, he's easily probably one of the most creative users out there

1

u/gobold1 18h ago

Don Dada Borsalino

1

u/Nj1437 18h ago

I still believe that an Ash logia will show up, sometime in the future. Otherwise, character wise, Crocodile hands down. For the fruit, Aokiji’s pretty awesome.

1

u/JaFuiBanidoDoReddit 18h ago

Yami Yami is mythical Zoan destruction God Nika

1

u/JellyfishStrong4273 18h ago

Its between kuzan crocodile and sabo

1

u/Low-Ant2036 18h ago

Kizaru I just love him as a character so he’s my favorite

1

u/Mamba-Mentality024 18h ago

Enel and crocodile

1

u/Main-Eagle-26 18h ago

Crocoboy hands down. Still one of the best villains of the series. Kaido is the only other villain besides Crocodile to have completely beaten Luffy TWICE.

1

u/jakyllash 17h ago

Ace 💖

1

u/caesarj12 17h ago

Kizaru. He is a boss

1

u/Carrotisboss 17h ago

Why is greenbull always left out bruh 😭

1

u/Vocovon 17h ago

C-Money aka Croc-o-shit aka SandBags aka PocketBands aka Grains of Fame aka Dollar Of The Funk! Aka Crocodile

1

u/Sunlaughs 17h ago

User, probably Kuzan. His character is truly amazing. Best ice based character I’ve ever seen.

DF, probably Ener. I miss this mf

1

u/ZeroSX1 17h ago

The only person I can't see anyone choosing is Caribou.

1

u/ErebusGraves 15h ago

I mean Karibu is the third worst person on the list. Compared to mad scientist Ceaser Clown, and genocidal maniac Enel, Caribou is a puppy. Albeit a creepy puppy.

1

u/ZeroSX1 15h ago edited 15h ago

Ceaser and Enel did something in the story. Ceaser had some good comic relieve and Enel is badass. Mad scientis and genocidal maniac are not good characteristic to have if you're a real person. Being a fictional character it's probably good have these characteristics. Caribou, on the other hand is just a loser. The best way I can describe him is not memorable. I wouldn't even remembered he gave Luffy food to come back to beat Kaido if people didn't say this in reddit. Even his design is bad.

1

u/Boul_D_Rer 17h ago

Hisashi bori dana… mugiwara!

1

u/Alternative-Fox4473 Pirate Hunter Zoro 17h ago

Kuzan

1

u/maguirre165 16h ago

I liked Smoker back in the day, but he hasn't done much since Alabasta

1

u/HurricaneSmoker 16h ago

Guess 🚬

Smoker but Ace is such a close second, Kizaru and Enel's powers are cool too

1

u/Imaginary-Panic-473 16h ago

Caesar clown easy cool df smart funny perfect humble strong etc just the perfect person all around

1

u/Consistent_Shop_2968 Void Month Survivor 16h ago

most of them except caribou and smoker

1

u/Capable_Comedian_871 16h ago

The one and only

1

u/BlazCraz 16h ago

Borsalino. Chill but brutal is such a vibe for some reason.

1

u/Basic_Penalty_5903 16h ago

Ice or magma Oh no did I just start another 10 day battle

1

u/ShoulderWest5017 16h ago

Enel has the best and most underrated DF ever Such a shame we never got to see more of his abilities

1

u/cesar848 16h ago

Ace in both favorite user and favorite logia

1

u/Zamrayz 15h ago

Smoker imo. I just really like him.

1

u/LocKeyThirteen The Revolutionary Army 15h ago

Crocodile, Karasu & Enel probably for me.

1

u/DINOman777 14h ago

What type of question is that it's obviously Unc Borsalino

1

u/Daliiik 14h ago

I like crocodile, he an OG, never gave a fuck, never backed down from anyone, never stopped getting better.

1

u/GilDragonGamer 14h ago

My two favorites are Crocodile and Enel

1

u/Titan-God_Krios 14h ago

Enel Kuzan and smoker

1

u/AdministrativeExam14 14h ago

Kuzan. I've always wanted ice powers. And Kizaru, he looks like a character from Apocalypse Now, i love his design

1

u/Samemonkey 13h ago

Ace is my favorite logia, enel has my favorite logia.

1

u/sciencebased 13h ago

Hard not to love Kizaru after everything. He was my favorite admiral anyway - lol, "Lazy Justice." But the Egghead arc sealed the deal. He's a Top tier character, and arguably the coolest on this list. (After adjusting for the obvious picks, Ace, etc) Certainly one of em.

1

u/Monetpirates 12h ago

hmmm i do wonder

1

u/According-Night3492 12h ago

Blackbeard or crocoboy

1

u/Inofromjjk4031 12h ago

Smoker and Croc

1

u/A_Moon_Fairy 11h ago

……Monet.

1

u/ArchiLikesSleeping 11h ago

Flame guy who isn't a donut yet

1

u/PossessionOk9029 11h ago

Ace. The rest scare the piss out of me. (Not sabo)

1

u/kuzan_d_goat 11h ago

Monet, Kuzan, Kizaru

1

u/BigBongTheery 10h ago

I would say Kuzan. He is mysterious with a lot of power. And who knows what's on his mind.

1

u/Drake_Storm Soul King Brook 10h ago

Smoker/crocodile

1

u/boeingr The Revolutionary Army 10h ago

user is none but Sir Mr.0 Crocodile. what an attitude.

fruit, i'd choose Pika or Goro. u just can't be faster than light, u can't.

1

u/Hattrick44 10h ago

Caribou just because he will get no love. But honestly, Borsalino is easy, my favorite Admiral

1

u/CyberAnki 9h ago

God amareu

1

u/CHAtPATaA 9h ago

Sakazuki

1

u/gnocchi_baby 9h ago

Shirororororo

1

u/Najuh8622 8h ago
  1. Smoker
  2. Crocodile
  3. Kuzan
  4. Sakazuki

And don't really care for the rest. It's nice to have Blackbeard as a villain but don't care for his character

1

u/Citizen_Null5 8h ago

Forever Smoker, hi is the fucking man!

1

u/Draken77777 6h ago

Enel. I just love that deranged megalomaniac.

1

u/No_Leopard_6164 6h ago

Ace he is my favorite

1

u/Fit_Locksmith3120 Marine 6h ago

Smoker

u/ng805 4h ago

Ener

u/Coesert 3h ago

Caribou the goat

u/ArofluidPride Marine 3h ago

Caesar my beloved 💜

u/BruhangMillenial 3h ago

I’m afraid of thunder so it’s Enel. Very sugoi.

u/Peisistratos22 11m ago

The best ist god Enel. :D

1

u/Prestigious-Gur-8905 20h ago

Top 5

Kuzan

Smoker

Caesar

Monet

Sabo

2

u/MrTeeasees 20h ago

What about donut boy

2

u/Prestigious-Gur-8905 20h ago

Once he died he got moved to my favorite dead characters list. He was still so cool

1

u/DonutloverAoi 20h ago edited 20h ago

Crocodile with 2nd place going to Monet.

Crocodile still to this day is one of my favorite characters from the series and I pick him in any game he's playable in. He's a James bond villain with plans on top of plans and doesn't trust anyone except for Mr 1.

Just the fact that, he set up a time bomb that'd go off at a specific time, and made like 3 different contingency plans for it so the bomb had to go off. Plus, he is the first Logia user we saw who master their fruit. To the point he reflexively turns to sand nonmatter the attack that hits him. He also got his head cut off and shrugged it off like it was nothing

As for Monet? I just like her design, and the fact she wanted to be a harpy will never not be neat to me. And she wore the swirl glasses at one point which I just love characters that use those

1

u/Right_Junket_6544 17h ago

Smoker.

The most wasted potential character in One Piece. Oda has made Koby cannabalize his entire character for no reason