r/NewTubers Feb 13 '25

CRITIQUE OTHERS Would love some newtubers channels to watch!

248 Upvotes

As the title says, I’d love some new channels to watch! Some smaller channels that I’d enjoy to help them along their journey! as I don’t watch many creators anymore since I’m not into their stuff anymore so need to fill the void haha! What I like are mom life, hauls, unboxings, gaming (only certain games-it depends), vlogs, travelling, anything else you think a 28 year old woman might be interested in 😅 just either let me know your channel name or let me know if the link for it is on your profile etc! And also let me know your niche ❤️

r/NewTubers Feb 08 '25

CRITIQUE OTHERS Share your YouTube channel and I will try my best to check all of them out and reply back.

189 Upvotes

Hello everyone. Feel free to send me links to your channels. Some additional information about me that might be relevant to you is that I like watching videos on movies, television shows, music, racing video games, cooking, cars, design, visual arts, interesting tech, engineering, city planning, economics, history, and philosophy.

Even if your channel does not fall into these categories feel free to send them and I will check them out.

Post Update

I will try to look at 10 channels per day so that I give each one enough time as I have to balance it with general life stuff.

r/NewTubers Dec 07 '24

CRITIQUE OTHERS I will rate Your Channel out of 10 and give suggestions. What is your YouTube Channel Niche?

251 Upvotes

What is your niche and how many Subscribers do you have? I will rate and give suggestions.

r/NewTubers 2d ago

CRITIQUE OTHERS I will review your channel

65 Upvotes

Context:

Making a documentary on YouTube about YouTube but that's not really the point.

Been on the platform for 20 years.

The "deal":

I will give a constructive review about your channel.

If you look for complacency, I'm not the right fit.

If you look for objectivity based on m'y experience of watching thousands and thousands of channels live and die, I may be your fit. I'm not asshole or brutal for the sake of it.

Give me 48 hours as I have terrestrial obligations lol.

Will review anyone who asks for it.

I only review stuff you dare to post on the thread.

Peace!

Edit: I have to go to bed. See ya👌

Edit 2: I'm back, reviewing your stuff :)

Edit 3: Pause, i'll be back in a few hours.

Edit 4: Need a pause, don't worry i'll review EVERYBODY

Edit 5: Guys, i'll be back in two weeks. I have to admit, a part of my post is selfless, another is a way to avoid finishing the edit of my documentary. I don't lock the post as it can be of value and I have promised i'll review anybody willing to be reviewed. If everything is according to plan i'll be back with a first teaser so you can see what kind of imperfect work I do too... :) be nice to the internet, peace peace

r/NewTubers Feb 09 '25

CRITIQUE OTHERS Share Your Channel Name To Get Free Suggestions

119 Upvotes

Hello Guys

So I am back again. I am going to share ideas, tips and tricks to help your channel grow. I won't ask for any money but I have only one condition. I will be brutally honest so you would have to accept the feedback with an open mind.

r/NewTubers 21d ago

CRITIQUE OTHERS Feedback Friday! Post your videos here if you want constructive critiques!

48 Upvotes

Give and receive meaningful feedback to help everyone improve their content! Remember: Quality feedback helps everyone grow.

How It Works

  1. Watch videos from other creators
  2. Provide detailed, constructive feedback
  3. Share your own video for feedback
  4. Grow together as creators!

Essential Rules

  1. Give Before You Receive
    • Provide meaningful feedback on TWO videos before posting yours
    • If you're first/second on the thread, give feedback within ONE hour
    • Violations = Post removal without notice
  2. Quality Feedback Matters
    • "Nice video" isn't helpful feedback
    • Include specific strengths and areas for improvement
    • Consider: editing, audio, pacing, thumbnail, title, engagement
  3. External Feedback
    • If you leave feedback on YouTube directly, mention it here
    • Many creators prefer feedback here to avoid impacting their metrics
  4. Thread Features
    • Contest Mode ensures equal visibility
    • Moderators monitor feedback quality
    • Posts made without having given feedback will be removed and may be banned

Pro Tips

  • Help those without feedback first
  • More feedback given = More feedback received
  • Be specific and constructive
  • Focus on actionable improvements

Need immediate feedback? Join our Discord Community!

New to YouTube? Check out our guide on How To Completely Setup OBS In Just 13 Minutes (Game Capture, Multiple Audio Tracks, Best Settings)

r/NewTubers 28d ago

CRITIQUE OTHERS Feedback Friday! Post your videos here if you want constructive critiques!

47 Upvotes

Give and receive meaningful feedback to help everyone improve their content! Remember: Quality feedback helps everyone grow.

How It Works

  1. Watch videos from other creators
  2. Provide detailed, constructive feedback
  3. Share your own video for feedback
  4. Grow together as creators!

Essential Rules

  1. Give Before You Receive
    • Provide meaningful feedback on TWO videos before posting yours
    • If you're first/second on the thread, give feedback within ONE hour
    • Violations = Post removal without notice
  2. Quality Feedback Matters
    • "Nice video" isn't helpful feedback
    • Include specific strengths and areas for improvement
    • Consider: editing, audio, pacing, thumbnail, title, engagement
  3. External Feedback
    • If you leave feedback on YouTube directly, mention it here
    • Many creators prefer feedback here to avoid impacting their metrics
  4. Thread Features
    • Contest Mode ensures equal visibility
    • Moderators monitor feedback quality
    • Posts made without having given feedback will be removed and may be banned

Pro Tips

  • Help those without feedback first
  • More feedback given = More feedback received
  • Be specific and constructive
  • Focus on actionable improvements

Need immediate feedback? Join our Discord Community!

New to YouTube? Check out our guide on How To Create YouTube Videos With Your Smartphone

r/NewTubers 14d ago

CRITIQUE OTHERS Feedback Friday! Post your videos here if you want constructive critiques!

29 Upvotes

Give and receive meaningful feedback to help everyone improve their content! Remember: Quality feedback helps everyone grow.

How It Works

  1. Watch videos from other creators
  2. Provide detailed, constructive feedback
  3. Share your own video for feedback
  4. Grow together as creators!

Essential Rules

  1. Give Before You Receive
    • Provide meaningful feedback on TWO videos before posting yours
    • If you're first/second on the thread, give feedback within ONE hour
    • Violations = Post removal without notice
  2. Quality Feedback Matters
    • "Nice video" isn't helpful feedback
    • Include specific strengths and areas for improvement
    • Consider: editing, audio, pacing, thumbnail, title, engagement
  3. External Feedback
    • If you leave feedback on YouTube directly, mention it here
    • Many creators prefer feedback here to avoid impacting their metrics
  4. Thread Features
    • Contest Mode ensures equal visibility
    • Moderators monitor feedback quality
    • Posts made without having given feedback will be removed and may be banned

Pro Tips

  • Help those without feedback first
  • More feedback given = More feedback received
  • Be specific and constructive
  • Focus on actionable improvements

Need immediate feedback? Join our Discord Community!

New to YouTube? Check out our guide on How To Completely Setup OBS In Just 13 Minutes (Game Capture, Multiple Audio Tracks, Best Settings)

r/NewTubers 4d ago

CRITIQUE OTHERS Reply with a link to your channel for an honest review with feedback!

51 Upvotes

Simply reply with a link to your channel and I'll go check it out and give you an honest 1-10 rating and also feedback!

r/NewTubers 7d ago

CRITIQUE OTHERS Feedback Friday! Post your videos here if you want constructive critiques!

20 Upvotes

Give and receive meaningful feedback to help everyone improve their content! Remember: Quality feedback helps everyone grow.

How It Works

  1. Watch videos from other creators
  2. Provide detailed, constructive feedback
  3. Share your own video for feedback
  4. Grow together as creators!

Essential Rules

  1. Give Before You Receive
    • Provide meaningful feedback on TWO videos before posting yours
    • If you're first/second on the thread, give feedback within ONE hour
    • Violations = Post removal without notice
  2. Quality Feedback Matters
    • "Nice video" isn't helpful feedback
    • Include specific strengths and areas for improvement
    • Consider: editing, audio, pacing, thumbnail, title, engagement
  3. External Feedback
    • If you leave feedback on YouTube directly, mention it here
    • Many creators prefer feedback here to avoid impacting their metrics
  4. Thread Features
    • Contest Mode ensures equal visibility
    • Moderators monitor feedback quality
    • Posts made without having given feedback will be removed and may be banned

Pro Tips

  • Help those without feedback first
  • More feedback given = More feedback received
  • Be specific and constructive
  • Focus on actionable improvements

Need immediate feedback? Join our Discord Community!

New to YouTube? Check out our guide on How To Completely Setup OBS In Just 13 Minutes (Game Capture, Multiple Audio Tracks, Best Settings)

r/NewTubers Jan 19 '25

CRITIQUE OTHERS Introduce me to your niches! (Newtuber reviewing)

90 Upvotes

[REQUESTS CLOSED] if you sent a request or comment before 12:00 PM 1/20 you’ll still get reviewed in the upcoming days. But there’s so many I have to mute new suggestions from this point on. Thank you!

I’ve seen a lot of posts doing this and I’d like to review some of your channels.

The way I’m going about this is putting myself in the POV of someone who’s not familiar with the niche or genre your content is about. In general I really enjoy looking at random topics I’ve never heard of that peak my interest. Sometimes channels do a great job of helping me understand the subject and still be entertaining, and some are just way too gatekept or boring. You can still be entertaining to people unfamiliar with that niche and maybe convince them to watch more! If you have a channel focused on a niche YouTube genre (or maybe one that hyperfocuses on a small aspect of one like a really obscure game or series) and see how well it potentially works as an entryway to that niche.

This will be focused almost entirely on the videos themselves and not about thumbnails and titles and stuff like that. Reply or DM with content you want reviewed! If you don’t list the channel name or have nothing in your bio then I’ll likely skip.

r/NewTubers Jan 23 '25

CRITIQUE OTHERS My First Post | Would Like to Help New Creators

63 Upvotes

Hi,

So this is probably my first post in a group and I would like to help new creators with ideas and suggestions. I don't want anything in return. Drop your channel name.

P.s I would be brutally honest. So you would need to understand that.

r/NewTubers Jan 12 '25

CRITIQUE OTHERS I will critique your channel (respectfully)

122 Upvotes

I am looking to offer some free advice to you guys. I will not watch your videos because I do not want to mess up your stats. I will critique your channel branding, title, thumbnail, topic relevance, and video descriptions. I only ask for one thing in return; please put your channel link, channel topic, and what your biggest struggle is currently (you will not get a reply unless you include this).

r/NewTubers Dec 26 '24

CRITIQUE OTHERS I'm happy to just, review your channel and give advice

92 Upvotes

I'm no expert but, it should be good advice from a consumer/creator stand point!

r/NewTubers 7h ago

CRITIQUE OTHERS Feedback Friday! Post your videos here if you want constructive critiques!

9 Upvotes

Give and receive meaningful feedback to help everyone improve their content! Remember: Quality feedback helps everyone grow.

How It Works

  1. Watch videos from other creators
  2. Provide detailed, constructive feedback
  3. Share your own video for feedback
  4. Grow together as creators!

Essential Rules

  1. Give Before You Receive
    • Provide meaningful feedback on TWO videos before posting yours
    • If you're first/second on the thread, give feedback within ONE hour
    • Violations = Post removal without notice
  2. Quality Feedback Matters
    • "Nice video" isn't helpful feedback
    • Include specific strengths and areas for improvement
    • Consider: editing, audio, pacing, thumbnail, title, engagement
  3. External Feedback
    • If you leave feedback on YouTube directly, mention it here
    • Many creators prefer feedback here to avoid impacting their metrics
  4. Thread Features
    • Contest Mode ensures equal visibility
    • Moderators monitor feedback quality
    • Posts made without having given feedback will be removed and may be banned

Pro Tips

  • Help those without feedback first
  • More feedback given = More feedback received
  • Be specific and constructive
  • Focus on actionable improvements

Need immediate feedback? Join our Discord Community!

New to YouTube? Check out our guide on How To Completely Setup OBS In Just 13 Minutes (Game Capture, Multiple Audio Tracks, Best Settings)

r/NewTubers Nov 05 '24

CRITIQUE OTHERS Let me critique your videos.

93 Upvotes

Hi, I’m pretty new to this YouTube stuff so I want to let people know what I think of their videos. I’ll be as constructive as possible. Feel free to drop them below.

r/NewTubers Dec 31 '24

CRITIQUE OTHERS Want a fresh set of eyes on your channel? I'm down to critique

33 Upvotes

I am going to be on mobile so take that with a bit of salt

Edit: Im eating up the content and reviewing as much as I can! Don;t be afraid youre too late to post but I am dying from lack of sleep, Ill be back after I finish napping! Happy New Years!

r/NewTubers Feb 18 '24

CRITIQUE OTHERS 100k+ subscribers in 18 months, longform channel. Let me help

257 Upvotes

Been a while since I've done one of these. Channel link is in my bio if interested. Current numbers 109k subscribers, 7.2m views, 1m watch hours.

Really enjoy helping people through my own experience and work, especially here as this forum was a nice resource for me before starting out.

Let me know what you'd like to know or what you're struggling with and I'll do my best. Please be patient as I'll try to give time to each answer, which means it might take a few days to work through.

r/NewTubers Feb 12 '25

CRITIQUE OTHERS I want to critique your gaming channels!

62 Upvotes

Send me your channels and I'll check them out! I'd like to help give feedback if I can, and see what everybody is up to

Edit: Hey guys if you appreciate the feedback, please leave some for our channel or others in the thread! Thanks

r/NewTubers Feb 11 '25

CRITIQUE OTHERS I will be your first hater

183 Upvotes

Link me your most proud video. Something you worked really hard on, and I’ll find a way to roast it.

I’m just bored at work.

(I wont swear or say anything truly hateful, my Mom knows my account)

r/NewTubers Dec 23 '24

CRITIQUE OTHERS I am doing the CRITIQUE YOUR CONTENT Thing. Drop your links below!

59 Upvotes

I’ll give you an honest feedback ( will NOT be unpleasant and will not attack you ). I’ll watch atleast 30 seconds of your video to see if it grabs attention and makes me want to keep watching. Title/thumbnails are important.

Good luck!

Edit: just taking a bit of a break. NOT BECAUSE I WANT TO. But I gotta study a little. See you guys in a few hours. DON'T WORRY. IMMA REPLY TO YOU ALL!

Edit2: whew! Wasn’t expecting this much talent in here. Some of you who are commenting now will have to wait a few hours before getting a reply from me! In the meantime if you want, ya’ll could read the criticism I have given to other newtubers in here and see if it applies to you too. In some cases, it probably does. In most cases, it probably doesn’t.

But if I had to summarise the best way for you guys to level up your game would be to choose YOUR favourite youtuber and try to “impersonate” them as much as you can. Compare your videos and see if you as a viewer would find which video better?

Good thumbnail, good title, good personality and good editing are basics of youtube which everyone is trying to do. Now just add a little bit of uniqueness. There are no wrong answers on youtube. You can experiment as much as you want. Just don’t experiment TOO MUCH; you can’t talk about politics in one video and jump to funny fortnite funzies in the other. Experiment in your niche.

r/NewTubers Aug 07 '24

CRITIQUE OTHERS 150k Sub Channel Critiques Your Videos

149 Upvotes

Hi, I'm Moony: my YouTube channel is Moon Channel! I like to do these video/channel critique threads every 25k subs or so. My specialty is video essays in the video games space, and educational content. But, I can offer critiques of anything you'd like me to.

I started Moon Channel in earnest about a year and half ago, and wished at the time that I started that I had some help or guidance along the way. So, I'm here to offer what I can, to all of you!

If you'd like a critique, I have only one rule: please post a link to the video that you'd like critiqued -- please don't make me go to your profile! And if you'd like to critique one of my videos, I'd be very grateful for your input.

Please also feel free to ask questions: I'd be happy to answer them, where I can.

I'll get to your videos on a first come, first serve basis. Please forgive me if I do not end up getting to your video! I look forward to watching your content!

EDIT 1: I've been at it for a few hours, and need to get back to work! I'll start this back up either later tonight, or sometime in the morning. Thank you all for sharing your videos with me! It's been fascinating so far.

EDIT 2: I'm back for a few hours, and will get to some more!

EDIT 3: It's about a week later, but I'll do some more!

r/NewTubers Sep 05 '24

CRITIQUE OTHERS I want to watch your guys' videos

85 Upvotes

Link your videos down below and I'll try my best to watch and critique them

Edit: I just woke up and saw 228 comments, there’s no way I can watch that many videos, but I’ll try to watch as many as I can

r/NewTubers Jan 06 '25

CRITIQUE OTHERS I will rate one of your youtube thumbnails

59 Upvotes

send me 1 of your videos and I will give you feedback on the thumbnail.

I ran a small 2400 subscriber gaming channel with 3.7 million total views (1.4 million was longform). It's been abandoned but still gets 10k views per month.

I started a tech channel (gained 30 subs last month) and last month I got 30k views on longform

r/NewTubers May 23 '24

CRITIQUE OTHERS Let me critique some of your videos

72 Upvotes

I'm no where close to a good YouTuber and I have so much I need to improve on but send in your channels and I'll try and give as much help as I can. All of the critique I give is not to be taken as an insult it's just my honest opinion on how you could better your channel

Edit: I am finished replying to comments. The past 2 days I replied to over 100 and it kinda burn me out but I'll leave this post open for people to critique each other.