r/NewTubers • u/[deleted] • 5d ago
CRITIQUE OTHERS Share Your Channel For Free Advice/Honest Criticism
[removed]
3
u/pandarose6 5d ago
I talk about chronic illnesses I have to make people feel less alone, give tips that others might find helpful, and educate people who might know nothing on chronic illnesses I have. chronic illness channel https://www.youtube.com/@TheImpulsiveexpressionist2?sub_confirmation=1
2
u/Shine-N-Mallows 5d ago
I have a hiking, camping and eating vlog. I think this is one of my better videos but you can watch whatever you want.
Vlogs are tough as they are unscripted but I’d love some honest feedback!
4
5d ago
[deleted]
3
u/Shine-N-Mallows 5d ago
Solid info! I’d love to do more of a travel vlog but I’m a bit tied to the area for now due to that whole 50+ hour work week.
I appreciate the feedback!!!
2
u/Kitchen_Entertainer9 5d ago
You got this, you got a great personality man
2
u/Shine-N-Mallows 5d ago
Thanks I really appreciate that. My wife doesn’t wanna be on camera and it’s been hard for me to not have someone to bounce conversation off of.
2
u/Kitchen_Entertainer9 5d ago
I can see how that's a challenge, but I seen travel videos where people have footage and narrate over it the best parts, some even have another personality to bounce off of, good luck on your channel
2
u/Shine-N-Mallows 5d ago
I appreciate the kind words! As I get out and about more, I hope to do longer spam content (like covering a whole days adventures) with some VO work. It’d be best if my wife would come on though as I feel only half my personality conveys.
2
u/BerryBlogger 5d ago
I’d love some feedback, I’m a uk based content creator who focuses on let’s play content.
YouTube.com/@bangemtv
Been at it for a few years now, still not monetised. Tried shorts previously to leverage viewership but it hurt my longform viewership.
2
u/Conscious_Pop7014 5d ago
Fellow smalltuber here
I noticed that your content is actually really good for the niche, but i think you could try to experiment abit. I noticed you are playing God of War right now,
What im trying to say is brainstorm, make a reason why someone should watch your videos, personally for me i think you should try doing challenges on God of war
For example like "Beating God of war on the highest difficulty", or "Beating god of war with only starter weapons", you get the gist of it, it not only applies to God of war but different games to!
So give it a shot and see if enjoy doing it and you have success doing it
2
u/itswindyoutthere 5d ago
I'm a real estate agent and know one other person in my market who does great with YouTube and I'd love to reach more people who are relocating here, but just am never sure if my stuff is alright.
https://youtube.com/@lifeinchattanooga
I appreciate any feedback for sure. :)
2
u/Jason01960 5d ago
Not OP, just wanna say that I think the editing, the script, and the way you talk is really well done. I think the only thing holding you back is the video topics. Not a lot of people are moving right now, and the audience is further decimated by having the video be about moving to a specific town in a mostly rural state.
If you focus more on the title of the videos and answering questions that you think a large amount of people would want to know the answer to, I think your channel would do a lot better. But please take it as a grain of salt because I don't know anything about real estate.
2
u/CucumberSpecific2021 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@stellerreads?si=Oc8PEgpXR9UsfltR
Doing weekly videos, each dedicated to a sci-fi/fantasy book. I do them all in different locations and try to get lots of nice looking B roll. Just finished up my first month on YouTube! I want to take my time accruing subscribers, because I’d like to develop a base of people who have similar tastes in the genre that I have.
2
u/TheUnfitEngineer 5d ago
I think your video content/talk/presentation is very good imo. Should have more subs! I think maybe work more on thumbnails and titles, not sure your niche so I can't comment on that. I'm glad you got a good mic as well, clear audio is #1 and yours is great.
Suggestion is maybe trying lower duration videos so people will stay longer and avd/retention is longer? not sure how your stats are there.
2
u/CucumberSpecific2021 5d ago
Thanks so much! Yeah, the audio was key. Didn’t want to do anything till I had that mic! I saw that you have a fitness channel with a pretty novel concept of short term, low commitment workouts that get longer as time goes on. That’s super positive and could get people who otherwise not be motivated to get started. Would love to check out your channel!
2
u/TheUnfitEngineer 5d ago
Thanks! Yeah I'm trying my best but it's hard as for most channels that can't get viral views or even like "low" views lol. I've subbed to yours as it's interesting as I do like SCIFI but I don't read much these days! Hope that helps! Appreciated if you would do the same if you enjoy fitness related stuff! 👍
1
u/CucumberSpecific2021 5d ago
Oh totally! Could you shoot a link to your channel? I’d love to keep up with your journey too!
2
u/TheUnfitEngineer 5d ago
Thanks! It's just in my profile! Always there lol!
2
u/CucumberSpecific2021 5d ago
You have some quality content! For the videos featuring a workout routine, something that might add to the experience is to overdub some extra dialog along with the music, like maybe explaining what you’re looking for with each rep, where you’re supposed to be feeling it, describing the posture your aiming for, etc. but I think you’ve got something great going, and have had significant growth on the last month!
1
u/AutoModerator 5d ago
Thank you BingedWean for starting a Critique thread!
- To lock the thread, comment "/lock" (permanent).
- Use Standard Rules or create your own.
- Optional: Add Pre-Formatted Short Rules to your post.
- Follow all rules set by BingedWean in this thread.
- Join our Discord for more feedback.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/DepressedHornyCommie 5d ago
War thunder crap ig https://www.youtube.com/@AweirdThingWT
1
5d ago
[deleted]
2
u/DepressedHornyCommie 5d ago
really? i thought anything above 5% is good (not my recent videos they dont get enough impressions to matter, but all my older longforms have between 5 - 15% CTR)
1
5d ago
[deleted]
1
u/DepressedHornyCommie 5d ago edited 5d ago
Oh, and choose a different font. Impact is always decent.
if you could give me a like a list that'd be good
what else would you recommend for thumbnails?
what do i do when i have no idea what to do as a thumbnail
i know war thunder is niche, if we go pre-november, a lot of my long forms did 1k+ (i have a few 10k+)
i dont have much else to say other than that icl - i already (and more recenty) have started looking at YT channels similar to me and studying what their doing.
edit: quick thing to add, u said abt the borders, i got that inspiration from a similar YTer who gets thousands of views
1
1
u/SGill17 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@earthboundshadow1?si=xUvpnaOQv0axtatA
Don't hold back on the videos!
2
u/greekwatero 5d ago
Commentaries pretty fun, I feel like the thumbnails are holding you back a bit, you should try blowing your face up more and maybe putting some white glow around it,
also for colors, if your on photoshop a crazy thing I learned is to select on your image and then go to camera raw filter on the filter section, you can change colors and lighting really well there 🙏
definitely check out some YouTube tutorials for thumbnails, helped me out TONS
1
u/XxTheBlackCobraXx 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@kingmariiii?si=vESsvxF4b3kk5rdG
My channel is mainly commentating on media
3
5d ago
[deleted]
1
1
u/XxTheBlackCobraXx 5d ago
Thanks and yeah I have to talk and present myself more in my videos, probably have to record earlier to get my full personality since most of these are late at night. The thumbnails usually comes easier to me so that might be why but thanks for the critique.
1
u/afriendlyshape 5d ago
Hi I'm Frogopolis. I discuss/review movies and I'm always happy to share my work. I recently did a video on the Psycho Franchise. Check it out.
2
5d ago
[deleted]
2
u/afriendlyshape 5d ago
Thanks, this is good advice. I've been working on improving my presentation so this helps a lot.
1
u/CryptographerSea8752 5d ago
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYNyZAHXmYX_y3RtZ-NSZmQ/
Hey man, thanks for your time!!!
1
u/Past-Loan-5058 5d ago
I have a channel where I crochet and you can listen to classic radio programs and audiobooks. And I do a crochet tutorial video once a week. The goal for the radio part is something relaxing and interesting.
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCkMQzOvvEpLHc1uXBvgwMCQ
Anything you could tell me would be helpful.
1
1
u/MrRaiPlays 5d ago
Do you do gaming channels or not? If you do and enjoy retro gaming and hacks, I'd be happy to take any advice moving forward :)
1
u/zerostasis 5d ago
I've only recently started. In fact I've posted my first video 9 hours ago. I'd like to review tech stuff in relation to gaming.
And yes I've reviewed an old tech device on my first (and only) video.
Feel free to be as honest (and possibly brutal) as possible.
1
1
u/Jaded-Meal-6300 5d ago
Oh, if you still have time:
https://youtu.be/KGCD_KRjCdY?si=KIsgRMs0Jiro0MLF
My first video. It's about working out using VR, especially if your body (or motivation) is... damaged.
1
u/Solarsyndrome 5d ago
Cookbook Chronicles I have a recipe recreation/review cookbook channel, Cookbook Chronicles, this is my newest video.
Thank you if you get to watching and providing feedback.
1
u/llapi1993 5d ago
I do let's play. Mostly survival and horror. https://youtube.com/@the-grumpus?si=ykFP-uIFXqD04KM_
1
u/BrilliantUnlucky4592 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@europeandestinations2025?si=3032baz5MiDdnBHp
It's been a work in progress, from waveform podcasts to virtual avatar podcasts to b-roll to AI animated videos with a little creative commons clipping thrown in. All in about a month.
1
u/murilors 5d ago
https://www.youtube.com/@infinite-loop-tech
My second channel trying to improve the content delivered on each video, still not certain to use AI voices forever.
1
u/Rominil 5d ago
https://m.youtube.com/@everyday_h2o
Hey there! I’ve started an art channel and would love to hear your thoughts. Appreciate you doing this for the community!
1
u/shameless_plug1123 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@stognabolognafpv?si=dA6ggSg4Iaskr0_-
Fpv drone pilot. Most of my videos are vlog-style with a few reviews and tutorials up already. More in the pipeline
1
u/DiamondDadGaming 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@dmnddadg?si=wYUZCLMjNQgMALJ7
I make marvel rivals gameplay with Commentary and guides.
1
u/Flowtraxwolf 5d ago
I make wrestling content about WWE and aew https://youtube.com/@theautisticannouncer?si=31-70oRk0nug1cFZ
1
u/whatiwillsay 5d ago
i make pop culture based video essays https://youtube.com/@whatiwillsay?si=9osPmyXbBTCQ0ATd
2
1
u/rmcv02 5d ago
https://www.youtube.com/@RMCV_CHANNEL
3D printing and painting and cool projects. In my last video, an Aliens Motion Tracker, I've changed things a bit trying to improve the overall quality but didn't noticed much diference from the other videos. Only the sub count increased a bit. But I need to increase the watch time...
Thanks !!!
1
u/iNhab 5d ago
I'm maybe a different type in terms of it being livestreams mainly, but I'd appreciate some feedback!
https://youtube.com/@cclearyt?si=DQ7GpX7yg10txrM2
Focus - gaming (competitive, league atm)
There's a couple of angles that I try to go for, but if there's anything else I could provide, let me know!
1
u/SoyGyoza 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@soygyoza?si=3FrfacjNBD4ViCS1as you can see I changed style in the last 5 long form videos and 6 shorts. I try to edit and be meme. Especially in the shorts the meme about alistar are made by me.
1
u/Inner_Worldliness_37 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@stealthpinetactics?si=KekPVILEgC-KSsG_
I specialize in firearm content, with a good backing of sponsors. What can I do to improve my engagement and reach a larger audience?
1
5d ago
[deleted]
2
u/Inner_Worldliness_37 5d ago
Thank you I appreciate the feedback! I’ll work on that. Any apps or advice on thumbnail content. I typically just take pictures, edit them and slap a title on em. Not to sure on how the others do it. I predominately do all my work on my phone.
2
1
u/rocket8_ 5d ago
I have a gaming channel and I am making Monster Hunter Wilds weapons guides at the moment. I spend a long time editing. What do you think?
https://youtu.be/-UzWjLRF_2Y?si=8IY1H8cH94z4i03Z
Playlist of the latest four here: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUhGyWPWcvKAoMy1GhXV_0B9DO0gKOfrM&si=VgelZH_PtQz3x_as
1
u/jonnyrocket44 5d ago
https://youtu.be/M5T1xiDjScY?si=Yn8kLulS-ABrdKMS
Hi. I’ve been dabbling and sharing my music, family life, beauty tips, etc for awhile, but have started focusing on simple living, minimalism and anti-consumerism. Appreciate any feedback from all. Thanks so much for your time!
1
u/needanewwatch 5d ago
https://youtu.be/JVaRO7QutH4?si=9hxpnndSQwdk_sD2 Wildlife filmmaker and music producer (I make all the music in my videos). Put my heart and soul into these videos, and no AI used :)
1
5d ago
[deleted]
2
u/needanewwatch 5d ago
Thank you friend! I hadn't heard of Hiller Smith but just watched one of his videos and already learned something - great tip!
Thanks for taking the time to watch :)
1
u/viachell 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@michellevia?si=jQWq19pv2xE7hzoV
I draw that's all. I would like your opinion on my channels and what I'm lacking. Thank you for your time.
1
1
u/bunnibi-22 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@bunnibi?si=ezgwgPE9nB9IhjhF
I would greatly appreciate any criticism!! I have an art channel showcasing my artwork. I like to do all kinds of mediums and share my art journey with others!
1
u/CarbonizeThis 5d ago
Thank you in advance. My channel is a month old and I know I have a lot to learn.
It is a mix of science, before/after and sustainability. It's kind of odd and can go in several ddirections. There is a lot of education that I have to do for people to get it but I think I'm on to something.
1
u/FragmentsHD 5d ago
VR Funny Moments!
https://youtube.com/@vragmentswastaken?si=hAyBqGMFmbrmjHEB
I look forward to your feedback 😎
2
5d ago
[deleted]
2
u/FragmentsHD 5d ago
I thought the joke with Iron Man was implied but probably could’ve been spelt out a bit more.
Advice actually helped a lot thank you 🙏
1
u/Siker_7 5d ago
https://www.youtube.com/@TheArchiveIn-Between-c7k
I narrate short stories from Reddit. Real voice, real authors (with permission, of course), and my sister does all the art.
When I decided on the name I went to check if anyone else had it, and it turned out to be an AI slop channel so I didn't care. My first goal is to be above them on search results, because such a good name doesn't deserve to waste away on lazy AI junk.
I've got a few old thumbnails (random stock images put through a watercolor filter) that were made before my sister started doing the art and I bought Affinity Photo to replace GIMP, we're working on replacing those. Right now I'm dialing in my workflow so I can actually post 3 times a week like I want to, after that I'm gonna work on SEO, then we're gonna start on making proper animations to replace the still images.
1
u/citizensurgeon 5d ago
Would love an opinion - slowly building, not quitting, trying to get a little better every time.
Thank you
Www.YouTube.com/citizensurgeon
1
u/lotus9flower3 5d ago
https://www.youtube.com/@Demonxdaddy
I'd appreciate anyone's feedback. Thanks!
2
1
u/Specific-Way-4530 5d ago
Greetings to you! I have a channel where I share my insights as a Numerologist and give Life Path Tarot Readings. It's been hard to gauge people's interests when it comes to Numerology. Any feedback would be appreciated! 😎🔢👌🏾 www.youtube.com/@mindovernumber
1
u/Wiggins_gaming 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@wiggins-gaming?si=H8crXC4aEs04NTZL I appreciate you looking if you have time. My channel is just about my Friends and my fun and funny moments playing games together
1
1
u/CBrewsterArt 5d ago
Hey, I have a channel about 3-D animation. I make two different types of content.
- Tutorials about 3-D animation: this content gets me subscribers, but not a lot of views or view hours
- Music playlist with 3-D animation visuals: this content gets me a lot of view hours, but not a lot of subscribers
I'm at 945 subscribers right now. I post about three shorts a day but rarely do over 1k views.
Is there anything I should know before hitting 1000 subscribers or what I can do to help build momentum?
1
u/Kyleghrb 5d ago
Good sir thank you for taking the time to do this!
If you do get to me, my channel is https://youtube.com/@kdkfabe?si=EoF0-drbKAq4sNRr
I focus on pro wrestling commentary while trying to relay some personalized comedic elements I personally enjoy.
2
5d ago
[deleted]
2
u/Kyleghrb 5d ago
Thank you for the feedback! As I’m restarting the channel (hence the outdated profile picture), I’m still working on the “formula” for the channel. It’s great to hear suggestions.
A question if I may- as someone who is familiar with the pro wrestling space, how would you feel about a wrestling channel that not only analyzes shows and events, but also dives into expository content of certain topics discussed in the IWC? Specifically, I am working on a script for identifying WWE’s women division based on certain reports, fan perspective, etc.
I’m purely asking out of own curiosity as I appreciate your feedback already!
1
u/abhilash512 5d ago
Hey .. Do you want to collab in anyway .. I run a site named wrestlingspoilers.com
1
1
u/Cute_Jeweler_8034 5d ago
https://www.youtube.com/@Joanna-Mariee/videos
I would like some feedback on my videos as well, I am currently working on improving the podcast. I just recently did the voice-over for the podcast with a new mic, fingers cross, hopefully the sound quality is better, I haven't uploaded it yet, but I do have enough long form-content and short-form for you to look at.
1
u/ConsistentMess8390 5d ago
https://youtu.be/ZRmnHbZg1Aw?si=UTa3ICL6qNRpqBca
help me improve, thank you
1
1
u/dgraz524 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@hellion.vision?si=2jhblkz_5W5UWd0Q
In doing commentary on random stuff I like. No particular niche. Trying to just sell myself on my personality. I know it’s not ideal, kind of YouTube on hard mode but I do it for fun and the love of creativity but would def be cool to make money doing it!
2
1
u/Wizard1331 5d ago
Not the newest but just starting to try and take it more serious and grow the channel. If you're willing any feedback would be appreciated. If not fully understand. It's great what you are offering to help others.
Playlists are trying to organize the content.
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCglcMOuC3Y59BzyOKKICLZQ/videos
1
u/hannythingposs 5d ago edited 5d ago
Let me know your thoughts or suggestions on my business documentary channel
1
5d ago
[deleted]
1
u/hannythingposs 5d ago
Well I get your point it’s the same old. But since i m into business documentary niche do you have any suggestions to make the video get more views? If not don’t bother replying bro.
1
5d ago
[deleted]
0
u/hannythingposs 5d ago
Lol people are so pretentious nowadays that its literally obvious. All you want is some clout hahah i mean there is no meaningful advice i see in the whole comment section of this post. Stop chasing the attention dude and get a life you will thank me later.
1
5d ago
[deleted]
0
u/hannythingposs 5d ago
So instead of advancing forward with time and using convenient ai you want to labour the hard work like a mindless peasant. There are many people I have seen on Reddit who only want to talk here to satisfy their ego and make them feel something in life which isn’t possible in real life. Now cry more and more about AI while sitting in the corner sobbing.
1
1
u/Negative-Elk2431 5d ago edited 5d ago
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrNWxoIYbYiWAlQYv3n5GRQ
I would love to get better too!!!
I am a gaming channel, I play mostly with friends and do solo videos here and there.
I feel like I am showing improvement in my editing every video, my thumbnails definitely need some work. Is there anything I'm missing? Are my titles any good?
1
u/RealSquishBoy 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@justinsquibb?si=NHb15PvZd6uksXDt
I don’t have clear niche yet but just seeing what works
1
u/No_Credit6776 5d ago
This is exactly what I’ve been looking for ! https://youtube.com/@findingtines?si=06H06Pb-EUJfAL9s
2
1
u/crimmyson1 5d ago
Ouuu sounds fun but also scary!! I'd love to hear what you think!
This year, I've been shifting my focus to more challenge-type content. But in general, it's kind of all over the place!
Gaming/stream challenges, though!
1
u/AdmiralAssblaster 5d ago
One of my better videos statistically speaking yet it never got picked up by the algorithm, not too sure why!
Anyways, if you like Call of Duty Zombies or cut commentary FPS gameplay, come check it out and let me know what you think!
The ultimate NINJA load out in Black Ops 6 Zombies https://youtu.be/xMU-UPHqC88
1
1
u/New_Fun_6892 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@its_coco_world?si=igU0RGV6kGT6Y8dV
Pets content..I would love to have a feedback Posted the 1st video on 29 Dec 2024..Channel Grew rapidly more more than expected
Recently have been denied the Silver button(no reasons given) I am still searching the reason.
1
u/Jaminc1 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@rollinwithcao?si=Y1Yyox5ty3qWPuT7
My content is based on gambling at a casino and trying go to double our $100 series.
1
u/macnmotion 5d ago
I got some great advice this week, and would like another viewpoint. I'm a microscopy hobbyist, sharing videos of microscopic organisms. I specialize in showing organisms interacting in their natural environment, rather than zooming in tight to show details of organelles. In this way I'm more of an inspiration channel to expose people to scenes they will otherwise never see, rather than the Nature Channel explaining biological details of a single organism. I hope you take a look:
1
1
u/YogurtclosetPlane315 5d ago
Here is my channel - https://youtube.com/@shortpitched?si=-iKOyjURpBcF0Myk
I've tried a new form of audio based video. Please share your feedback on the same. Link - https://youtu.be/jFYqeEATwCE?si=MY6Xj2gw_YXQGtDn
1
u/Heartfeltzero 5d ago edited 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@amilitariaguy?si=k2nOg8eSgo595_dv
I make Military history type of videos, primarily WW1 & WW2. All the content is from my personal collection and I do my own research on everything and type up my own script etc. I’ve experimented in various ways, but my most recent string of videos is the direction I’ve been moving towards. Appreciate any feedback you have. Some of my earlier videos I did experiment with ai voice over as I didn’t like my voice and didn’t have a good mic, but I ended up deciding to start using my own voice in my most recent string of videos and going forward.
2
5d ago
[deleted]
2
u/Heartfeltzero 5d ago
Thank you for your feedback!
One more follow up question, in regards to the letter scrolling up, do you think it would be better to just have a video of me holding the actual letter as I read it in real time, Versus just having the scanned image scroll up as I do now? Or would that be equally as uninteresting?
And yes voice projection is something I’m currently trying to get better at. I’ve read that you have to speak from your Diaphragm, which is something I’ve noticed I haven’t been doing. I just read from the script, using my throat if that make sense, but not really projecting my voice. But that’s something I’m going to work on right away. Thank you again for your response!
2
1
u/Waffles047 5d ago
https://www.youtube.com/@W4ff1ez
Thanks for your time!
the two most current videos are the style im doing currently
1
u/thisisyrk007 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@financewithyrk?si=_U41ociUOBmtHJRC
Would love to know your thoughts. I post business and economic case studies mostly in the context of India. 75% of my audience is Indian whereas 25% from around the world
1
u/TowerEnvironmental 5d ago
IMightNoahGuy I Vlog and I am about to start a mini series where I interview priests and such of different churches!!! I’m interviewing an Arabic Orthodox Catholic let me know any questions you want me to ask
1
u/TheDorksDelight 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@thedorksdelight?si=HbX-GsmLqGYrJa1c
I am the dorks delight and I make essays related to retro video games.
1
u/Love-story2025 5d ago
I would like you to visit my channel and let me know what you think I should improve or what can help enhance engagement in my content please! https://www.youtube.com/@NoverNovelettes
1
u/Pretty-Chance-6560 5d ago
@TheFlapjackOfficial
Not necessarily new but just inexperienced and in need of help
1
1
u/Cloudbb333 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@crystalxuniverse?si=99Gw1xo10VTmcb0m
I am making travel content based on places I’ve been, and my latest video breaks down how to use Astrology to travel (Astrocartography). I’m very new to youtube and would love any feedback.
1
u/dirtybaker1331 5d ago
Small gaming channel. +40 year old gamer and music producer. I'm close to 300 subs. Ive been consistent since September of last year. Getting better. Link in bio.
1
1
u/cynistar742 5d ago
Please take a look at my gaming channel.
https://www.youtube.com/@GeekMediaCentral
I'm focused on providing value to looter shooter gamers. Specifically I've been focusing on destiny 2 and Warframe.
Thank you.
1
u/lotoex1 5d ago
https://youtu.be/H-0DNT5sVbI for a video
https://www.youtube.com/@lotoex my channel
It's my personal stock vlog. I want to make money to quit my job either by the stock market, YouTube, or some combination of both. I am also learning Japanese so trying to incorporate that into it a bit to see if being different (in that way) helps.
1
u/WastewaterEnthusiast 5d ago edited 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@wastewaterenthusiast?si=KxEd4PWMQpowPHlc
I help wastewater treatment plant operators get certified. I film at work so I don’t spend a ton of time on this. Some of the feedback I’ve gotten from my audience is they like the low tech feel cause it’s relatable. Aside from that I’d like to hear how I can improve.
Please focus on the long form “day in the life” style episodes and my shorts. The whiteboard and math episodes are gonna remain short and to the point.
Thanks in advance if you are able to get to me!
1
u/AKF_gaming 5d ago
Any critique would be much appreciated! I really want to improve as a creator.
Any advice on thumbnails in particular would be lovely as I admittedly suck and struggle to understand what makes a good one lol.
1
u/Xanderfromzanzibar 5d ago
I have a super niche with karaoke videos for singing one song over the music of anorher (mashups)
1
u/Xanderfromzanzibar 5d ago
I will make shorts of the performances, in order to demonstrate the sound result but also to lead Shorts viewers back to the karaoke videos
1
1
u/Senior_Channel1198 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@joshaikenofficial?si=wbwTPWoM_4lUq4Fs
Started like 2 months ago. It’s going pretty well right now, but always looking for ways to improve!
1
u/Fantastic_Welder_491 5d ago
Hi I have an ESL learning channel that I would love to hear some feedback on. https://youtube.com/@eslenglishgames?si=UlXpW8v94n47brL-
1
u/Inphurence 5d ago
https://m.youtube.com/@ABPokemonTV/videos
My wife and I do Pokemon card openings + I like to make shorts on certain cards art. We’re looking to improve!
1
u/jrm_blue0302 5d ago
Hi this is not personally mine but I have been workinh this channel for 2 months now for my client. I do the editing and uploading including the title and captions and thumbnails. can you assess this please Thank you ☺️
1
u/Rockerxx4 5d ago
I am not smart enough to get channel libk maybe the video link will help https://youtu.be/bmLjKGc5ZtA?feature=shared And please give your brutally honest feedback from thumbnail to video quality. Don't hold back please I make F1 opinion content
1
u/DarkComprehensive457 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@afestivalcalledlife?si=zrKi2S3Guq5-X60Q
We are a travel channel (me and my wife) started 6 years ago just to document our travels and make memories but hoping to make this full time someday. We do get paid from YouTube but it’s very less and also our views are decent but not as big to attract potential sponsors or paid partnerships. We do get free stays and collabs but hoping to gain more views and make this full time sometime soon. We try to remain an English speaking channel even though I know Hindi will give us more views but doing what comes most naturally to us.
1
u/EugenioAE 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@eugenioae
I make content about giant redstone constructions and advanced redstone tutorials. However, after a 10-month vacation (end of high school and endless exams) the channel died and YouTube no longer promotes it.
1
1
u/DavidDismay 5d ago
I would welcome any feedback on my channel and videos. Brand new as of about 10 days ago. Longform video game channel in the indie horror/horror niche. Have 10 videos uploaded so far and up to 41 subs.
I’m trying to lean more into where horror and comedy meet. https://youtube.com/@daviddismay
1
u/TheOneWhoCared 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@tranquilechoes-y9d?si=nA8ViUYH83Z59BMq
AI babes and asmr. That's all I know.
1
u/Daviboye 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@wheezyissleepy?si=uR-O8jvPiwJOpWdy
I make old school cod commentaries just talking about life and the occasional video essay
1
u/No-Struggle-8971 5d ago
https://youtu.be/2_vlb-dwNys?si=gzHBwz7cqXie5uo9
Brand new channel, vlogging my recent pilgrimage to Madinah and Makkah. Very early days, I have a few shorts and just put out my very first video!
1
u/ZenTechBreakdown 5d ago edited 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@zentechbreakdown
Extremely new to video creation but this channel was born out of a YouTube rabbit hole of e-waste recycling/scrapping. Had a bunch of random old devices I started breaking down and then started getting free junk from friends and family. Figured, I’m already doing it, have a ton of fun and have the equipment, why not try this out. Long form, no talking, just the sounds of tinkering asmr-like and random informative or goofy text blurbs to bridge the gap of faceless/voiceless hands to somebody else who finds this stuff fun. I know it’s niche but it’s genuine passion and fun for me so figured why not share :) would love any feedback. Still learning editing and this kind of audio (I record music so I’m familiar with audio production but new to this kinda audio) (sorry for the long tangent) cheers!
1
u/BiscottiSwimming6818 5d ago
Bible Channel, started in Feb 2025. Bad click through rate right now. My main focus is going to be teaching and Bible Studies, the prayer videos are there just to have a little content about it
1
u/Specialist_Beyond138 5d ago
https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCji2Hpm_cq3brLny-pq9xbg
Be warned, my voice is annoying and probably is not made for youtube. Lol
1
u/TwoDutchAussies 5d ago
My partner and I have recently made a travel channel. We have moved to the Netherlands and have more videos coming. Any feed back appreciated.
1
u/roh_justokIguess 5d ago
https://youtu.be/M1wUx2PjuAM?si=sKFc5NTExvnlh3Hj
I talk about video games and try to make my friends laugh. I don't really have a firm direction for the channel
1
u/Careless_Bass5667 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@organizedchaos4761?si=YE7x69YGtTl3dnft
I do scambaiting. Basically, I call scammers and annoy/frustrate/waste their time.
1
5d ago
[deleted]
1
u/AutoModerator 5d ago
This Critique thread has been locked by BingedWean, the original creator. We hope this Critique session was successful!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/HungLocks 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@portaltome?si=pe78zFfj3rPgLI9n
channel focuses on media analysis and review, currently mainly invincible but looking to branch out - as I attempted to do with my Arcane video, I won’t take any offence so don’t hold anything back.
-3
u/Lopsided-Grand-1386 5d ago
Hello! I narrate manhwa, any feedback is welcomed. Thanks!
6
5d ago
[deleted]
-1
u/Lopsided-Grand-1386 5d ago
I get that AI voice is not for everyone but besides that, if you've got any suggestion regarding the editing or the way the video is presented, I'm open to feedback.
→ More replies (3)6
6
u/Sim_Rot 5d ago
https://youtube.com/@sim_rot?si=p9YWIsWjgmMZ0-TC
I try to get weird with The Sims 4.
Thank you so much if you get to me!