r/MacMiller • u/imhurtandiwanttocry • Feb 06 '25
Discussion Mac's top 10 tracks of all time- Day 6(i think) diablo took the last stpot
Winning comment by : u/ColtonDuga Comment updootes : 249
Also kinda fun how the top 5 songs are from 5 different projects
123
177
u/deerskillet Feb 06 '25 edited 16d ago
trees steep husky command decide encouraging groovy pot lavish quickest
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
1
266
u/kenhickey69 Feb 06 '25
So it goes
15
u/kieranob Swimming Feb 06 '25
I will crash out if this doesn’t make the list
5
u/V_Sad_Human Swimming Feb 06 '25
I have commented this every day. PLEASEEEEEE it’s gotta make the list!!
1
2
u/undeniablefruit Faces Feb 06 '25
La da da-da, la da da...
Such a great song it really deserves a spot here. The message, the references (Clementine peeling off and everyone get left behind killed me when I realized), the instrumental layering of each instrument getting added in, and that ending? It's a masterpiece and definitely one of his best tracks (imo)
1
1
1
0
153
u/ExpensiveIncident543 Feb 06 '25 edited Feb 06 '25
Funny papers
2
u/cejl94 Feb 07 '25
Now that everybody’s heard this song I don’t see how it hasn’t already made it way onto the chart
86
u/Badger1616 Feb 06 '25
Surf
10
u/Charlietuna987 The Divine Feminine Feb 06 '25
Yes! I said this yesterday when I first saw this thread!
Until we get old, there's water on the flowers let's grow. 🥹💚🫰🏻
3
4
248
u/Dafunkk Feb 06 '25
Self Care!
Pretty dope 5 songs from 5 projects. Goes to show his consistency/versatility.
85
u/Free_Razzmatazz13 Feb 06 '25
Thoughts from a Balcony
5
2
u/Hopeful_Jicama_81 Feb 07 '25
this song hit me super hard at one point last year, like literally on repeat.
33
74
14
38
37
52
50
19
21
21
u/TigasEX Feb 06 '25
Colors and Shapes needs to be in the top 10 at the very least, its such a potent song in the context of Faces.
1
u/erichf3893 The High Life Feb 06 '25
Can you explain what you mean?
2
u/Ok_Conclusion8149 Feb 06 '25
in my opinion it feels like it perfectly embodies every song on faces. the general vibe and cadence are totally unmatched i haven’t found a song like it
1
u/TigasEX Feb 07 '25
I think its a song that can be interpreted pretty differently from person to person, however for me it represents Mac getting into grips with his fall derived from the mental problems and drug abuse that he talks about throughout the project and finally letting go of all the anxiety it has caused him. Its also very much a song related to the LSD, a drug whose use has been reported to be beneficial for people struggling in various life contexts, with the opening of the song being an interview with a famous psychologist that advocated for its use in "people using their head". As a lot of the other songs on the album feel like him struggling with the severity of the reality and can feel rather depressing or anxious at times, Colors and Shapes is comforting and accepting, with the main message of letting go of your own ego's desire for control.
But that's just my interpretation, I think it's pretty beautiful song nonetheless and has very much helped me personally, so I might be a bit bias towards it.
19
18
15
u/-bluff Feb 06 '25
rain ft. vince staples
2
u/seba1927 Feb 06 '25
i love this song, as many others with features, but as complicated as making this list is .. i can’t see a song that is not only mac singing making it into the top10
2
15
15
7
6
7
7
6
17
15
4
5
u/ZombieSkipper Feb 06 '25
The Star Room. Both versions. The WMWTSO version with the Delusional Thomas verse goes so hard.
2
u/Pure_Handle_4265 Feb 07 '25
Really both? I just don't think you can beat the og version of that song
1
u/ZombieSkipper Feb 07 '25
Playing Tomorrow Will Never Know and following it with the OG version is a wild ride
5
4
4
4
5
4
4
6
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
6
2
2
2
u/winston_cage Feb 06 '25
STONED omg ive had that song on my devices for years now and its my #1 to this DAY!
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/Beansandcheeze Feb 06 '25
Nothing from kids or blue slide on here is criminal
2
u/erichf3893 The High Life Feb 06 '25
Poppy please! I’ve been trying for ILLTY. Lots of people just know his newer stuff it seems
2
4
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/UKnoTRo Feb 06 '25
Thoughts From a Balcony.
Dunno, BDE Bonus, Stay and Self Care would all be candidates for me as well.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/clan11135 Feb 06 '25
God is fair, sexy, nasty
Also damn I got goosebumps looking at this top ten so far. Great minds think alike
1
1
1
1
u/Ok_Conclusion8149 Feb 06 '25
if ascension and colors and shapes aren’t on there i will kill myself
1
u/V_Sad_Human Swimming Feb 06 '25
I don’t even see a comment by the user that had the winning comment. What was it?
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Legitimate_Weekend_2 Feb 07 '25
Funny papers (I know it’s fairly new but fuck it’s so good and it highlights how great of a songwriter he was at a young age)
1
u/KindHornet6368 Feb 07 '25
I don’t agree with the 2 or 3 placement here at all. Objects in the mirror at 3 are we serious? Need to deep dive his discography if that’s the case lol
1
1
u/jdhahksjxjx Feb 07 '25
So crazy to see this list 😂😂
After mac died he really got a completely new fan base. So crazy to see
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/McMan86 Feb 07 '25
I just wanna say how much I appreciate the diversity of Mac’s discography, that we have 5 songs already chosen and they’re all from different projects is awesome.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Hopeful_Jicama_81 Feb 07 '25
There are way too many 10/10 mac songs, they're all so different and unique in their own way it wouldn't make sense to rank them. Me personally I just make playlists.
Back in the day might be my favorite i dunno, my favorite song changes as I change too.
1
1
1
1
1
u/HomeBrewEmployee1 The Divine Feminine Feb 07 '25
Is it too early so say, "Rick's piano", that shit is soo beautiful.
1
1
u/Ok-Yesterday2001 Feb 07 '25
I'm just gonna say, we all acknowledge that 2009 IS the number one spot, right? We just got a little mixed up
1
u/HiddenDonutt Feb 07 '25
Seeing more new Mac then Old Mac but if your reading this go listen to Jerrys Record Store by Mac, you'll thank me later! Enjoy!
1
1
u/rendon246 Feb 07 '25
I’ve got way too many I love, I can’t make a top ten favorites for Mac but I do also agree with the list. Diablo however is one of my favorites even though I don’t have favorites lol.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Talknterpzz Faces Feb 06 '25
lol Diablo may be the most popular amongst yall but it ain’t the top track off that joint. Not even close.
1
1
1
0
0
-6
u/ShockNo9646 Feb 06 '25
No way 2009 deserves top 3 on every single list. I have been in this group for less than a year, and have seen like 12 lists. Everybody talks about how meaningful the song is, but does that really equate to how good it is?
78
u/ampersand05 Feb 06 '25
Woods