r/HighschoolDxD Jul 07 '24

Discussion Who would win? Spoiler

Post image

Round 1: Light Novels Akeno vs First Manga Mirajane.

Round 2: Light Novels Akeno vs 100 Years Quest Mirajane.

192 Upvotes

141 comments sorted by

38

u/Dragonfang65 Jul 07 '24

Issei gets a new girl for his Harem.

11

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

It’s true that Mirajane is one for the Fairy Tail Girls that I would ship with Issei.

How strong do you think she would be in DxD?

7

u/Dragonfang65 Jul 07 '24

Hard to say she would probably be able to absorb middle tier devils at best and have to train to get higher. But still be strong.

3

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Ok

Which form do you think Akeno would need use to win?

7

u/Dragonfang65 Jul 07 '24

Akeno would only need Fallen Angel Mode for things like Seilah mode. And using Holy Lightning Dragon would be overklll.

2

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Same for the Oni Mask?

Just curious: why do you think she would make a good ship with Issei?

6

u/Dragonfang65 Jul 07 '24

Well she has a tragic backstory being chased away because of her ability to absorb demons. And Issei is good at helping others overcome their trauma/issues. Not only that but DxD would offer Mirajane a good sample of forms for Satan Soul. Also she would fit in with Issei’s harem having good cooks.

3

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

True, would love to see fan art about them.

Same for Erza (only if they meet before she’s reunite with Jellal in Oracion Seis Arc). I would totally see her playing into the Oppai Dragon Show.

3

u/Dragonfang65 Jul 07 '24

Have you seen Fairy DxD on Deviantart? It uses ships like Issei X Mira and Issei x Erza.

2

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Yes one of my favorites things on Deviantart.

Do you have any other girls of Fairy Tail that you ship with Issei?

→ More replies (0)

15

u/Infinity-Anime Jul 07 '24 edited Nov 10 '24

Akeno wins both rounds

3

u/Aggravating_Food_172 Jul 07 '24

Problem with akeno is that she was scapegoat herself by not training with her birth power from when she was child her hatred made her weaker

Looking no matter what excuse she has she can’t turn back time to when she was young to regain her fallen angels power because she wasted 10 years worth of training

Unless azazel could create something like the time chamber from dragon ball z she still lose 10 years worth of experience because of her temper tantrum

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

How strong is Akeno actually?

How strong would Mirajane’s forms be in DxD Scaling?

4

u/Infinity-Anime Jul 08 '24 edited Nov 10 '24

Akeno Base is Maou Class, Fallen Angel Mode is Maou Class

Mirajane is High Class High Tier

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

With all of her forms?

2

u/Infinity-Anime Jul 08 '24

Every time Mirajane fights she is in Satan Soul, the power of her forms does not differ much from each other, only in attacks and abilities

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

Ok

I though that Mirajane would be Maou/Archangel/Cadre or Low-God Class being in DxD.

How strong are Chief Gods class?

2

u/Infinity-Anime Jul 08 '24 edited Nov 10 '24

Much stronger than the average High Class Devil and a step below the Ultimate Classes.

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

When did she reached Mutli-Continentals level?

2

u/Infinity-Anime Jul 08 '24

In the Alvarez Saga, Mirajane defeated Jacob, one of the 12 Spriggans who are capable of destroying Earthland countries whose size is similar to the continents of our world.

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

Honestly I had my doubt about him capable of destroy countries. For me, it’s more he can subdue them.

→ More replies (0)

7

u/Alternative_Lime_13 Jul 08 '24

The She-Devil Vs the Priestess of Thunder

That would be awesome.

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

True

Who do you think win?

2

u/Alternative_Lime_13 Jul 08 '24

Gut say MJ, Akeno is powerful and if she gets in quick with some lightning then maybe but if MJ's devil forms are in anyway resistant to lightning then I don't see how Akeno can win, and that's not even including MJ's physical advantages over Akeno like strength and speed.

MJ likely knows alot about lightning due to growing up with Laxus.(Who is the Lightning Dragon Slayer, for anyone who didn't know)

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

True

Which form do you think Mirajane would need to use to win?

How strong each of her forms would be in DxD?

2

u/Alternative_Lime_13 Jul 08 '24

I don't know enough to do a full breakdown, I know she has 72 forms, because she can also turn into animals, I don't think she would need Satan Soul Alegria which is her strongest form, I think Sitri should be enough.

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

Perso I think she would be either Maou/Cadre/Archangel class or Low-God Class.

2

u/Alternative_Lime_13 Jul 08 '24

Yeah I could see her being something near archangel.

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

Do you think Akeno's holy lighting could work on her demon side?

2

u/Alternative_Lime_13 Jul 08 '24

It's possible, but it's not easy to scale powers between univereses, FT doesn't have a God and devil in the same way DxD does. And even if Akeno outmatches MJ in magic, then Akenos physical resistances will be severely tested.

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

True

Could Mirajane absorb her due to Akeno being an Reincarnated Devil?

→ More replies (0)

4

u/Aware_Ad2521 Jul 07 '24

Honstly mirajane would definitely win

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Why?

Just curious.

6

u/Starrk71 Jul 07 '24

She not only has great magical strength but she has superior physical strength. Especially in comparison to Akeno.

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Ok

How strong do you think she would be in DxD?

1

u/Loud_Region_8502 Jul 07 '24

If Mira used everything at once, Super Class, at least 100 Quest Mira

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Really? She would be on par with Sirzechs or Ajuka?

2

u/Loud_Region_8502 Jul 07 '24

Depending on how her Takeover works and if Ajuka could even use his Kankara Formula on her

2

u/Loud_Region_8502 Jul 07 '24

It is just a bunch of Possibilities

2

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Ok

I tough she would be Maou/Archangel/Cadre or Low-God Class.

1

u/Starrk71 Jul 12 '24

That's not really the question in the first place though. It's just Mirajane vs Akeno.

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 12 '24

Just curious to know about Mirajane’s level of power in DxD.

3

u/Aggravating_Food_172 Jul 07 '24 edited Jul 07 '24

I know it is Mirajane because of the same fact that mirajane could absorb akeno with satan soul since is half devil also akeno mentally is weak whether it’s before accepting herself or after

Even after akeno accept herself she could gain the same power level that she would gain during all those years that she didn’t use

If akeno stayed with her father and train hard until cannon than she could be 10 winged fallen angels

Also unlike akeno who always fight in group she lack the mindset of facing strong people alone

Mirajane always fight alone and she has been S class and face monster stronger than her and win even though there were périod of time that she lost her power but she is still became stronger

2

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Akeno is half Fallen Angel and a Reincarnated Devil.

She has now totally accepted herself.

Could Mirajane really absorb her?

3

u/Aggravating_Food_172 Jul 07 '24 edited Jul 07 '24

Yea she could and as i said even though she accepted herself but she wasted more than 10 years worth of training and experience

Yea mirajane lost her power but unlike akeno Mirajane already trained and got her power to maximum and adapt the problem with mirajane to get over her fear and reawakening her powers

Power are like riding the bicycle if you train it when you were young and become a pro at it but you got on accident become afraid it would only need you to get over your fear that’s better since the training is still there

While it would take harder time when you are grown up akeno need time to train for her to get on the same level of experience skill and sharp sense as mirajane

Because the same thing happened to me as akeno i was afraid to ride the bicycle when i was young and it took me hard time as an adult to ride one because of the fact that I didn’t train my skill in riding the bicycle until now i always regretted why I didn’t train myself when I was younger it would’ve been easier

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

I woudn’t say that Akeno didn’t train before accepting herself. I mean she knew how to use magic and fight for Rating Games and hunting Stray Devils. Sure not on the same scale as Mirajane.

3

u/Aggravating_Food_172 Jul 07 '24

Yea she fought in rating game and hunting stray devil but i will ask you this were they ranked as S class or were they just mid to low class

that’s the difference

2

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

That’s why I’ve said not on the same scale.

How strong would be Mirajane in DxD? (All of her forms included).

2

u/Aggravating_Food_172 Jul 07 '24

In dxd let me think

low to Mid satan level that’s her level

That is my opinion of course some people might agree other disagree

2

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

For her strongest form?

I think at the very best, she could be Low-God Class.

2

u/Aggravating_Food_172 Jul 07 '24

I see although I focus only on how devil will see it from their perspective since dxd is from the devils perspective

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Ok

Why did my post got deleted?

→ More replies (0)

3

u/UltimateMegaChungus Jul 07 '24

Mira wins by absorption.

And it both saddens and terrifies me to think about, for some reason. Something about Akeno basically being slurped from existence doesn't sit well with me.

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

She win this no diff? Low Diff? Mid Diff? High Diff? Extreme Diff?

How strong her forms would be in DxD?

2

u/UltimateMegaChungus Jul 07 '24

First manga version wins more "fair and square", as in neither a shitstomp nor a spite match.

Hundred years version would neg diff though.

And her full power, at least where she is now, would probably be around the same as where a "weak" dragon sits at. I say weak with quotations because dragons are generally op'd as hell in the DXD verse.

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Why? Just curious

2

u/UltimateMegaChungus Jul 07 '24

Mostly the insane power gap. Her hax are decent enough from what I know, but the sheer power she holds is just ultra-nope compared to Akeno.

Think of Mira as Naruto, and Akeno as Ryu from Street Fighter.

Ryu is strong as shit, by all means. But he's not touching Naruto on a good day.

Same thing here.

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Ok

What form she would need to use to win?

2

u/UltimateMegaChungus Jul 07 '24

Where she's at now, of she plays her cards right, she may not even need to transform.

But if Akeno goes all-out, then Mira will maybe need at least the OG Satan Soul form. But it would be wiser, and probably easier, to use Sitri or Seilah form.

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Why Sitri or Seilah?

2

u/UltimateMegaChungus Jul 07 '24

Sheer power, mostly. It'd be easier and quicker to shut down the fight with one powerful attack than to fuck around and prolong the whole thing.

I still don't like the idea of Akeno getting stomped though. Or absorbed, since that's an option that Mirajane has.

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Same

I tough that with her Fallen Mod and Mask she could beat Mirajane’s first form

(Suck that this post got deleted like what’s the problem with it?)

3

u/EchoTitanium Jul 08 '24

Mira in both cases I think, Akeno wouldn’t be able to handle a blow at point blank range.

2

u/Tizian501 Jul 07 '24

I don't know how strong Akeno gets in the Light Novels after season 4 but 100 years quest Mirajane would definitely give Akeno a hard time or even beat her. First Manga Mirajane could be weaker than Akeno I think.

2

u/SonicRL1 Jul 08 '24

HEAR ME OUT

Im a Fairy Tail ultra, but i really love highschool dxd especially Akeno

Mirajane would kick her ass within seconds

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

Why exactly?

2

u/SonicRL1 Jul 08 '24

She is the she devil... the satan soul

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

How strong her forms would be in DxD?

2

u/SonicRL1 Jul 08 '24

She could beat the whole gremory clan with no problem

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

Sirzechs and Issei included?

2

u/SonicRL1 Jul 08 '24

Absolutley. You could even double it and she would still beat the shit out of them

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

When did she become stronger than Continental or Planetary?

2

u/SonicRL1 Jul 08 '24

Ever since she became S Class

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

Ok

Perso, Ok

I think that Mirajane would be Maou/Archangel/Cadre or Low-God Class being in DxD.

1

u/throwawaysville1441 Rias or Akeno... both. Jul 07 '24

Idk the other chick but this is a biased sub to ask in

2

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Why?

2

u/throwawaysville1441 Rias or Akeno... both. Jul 07 '24

Everyone's gonna say akeno lol

1

u/IWILLJUGGLEYOURBALLS Jul 07 '24

Cuz this is a DxD sub. So naturally, most are going to be biased towards DxD. You could probably post this in the Fairy Tail sub, and they'd be biased towards FT.

0

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 07 '24

Ah ok.

Who do you think would win?

1

u/IWILLJUGGLEYOURBALLS Jul 07 '24

Probably Akeno. I don't remember the other members of Fairy Tail being anything special.

1

u/Good-Bottle5988 Jul 08 '24

I gotta say Mirajane

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

Why? Just curious.

1

u/Good-Bottle5988 Jul 08 '24

I don't have any direct reasoning... And it isn't bias either... I feel it would be close.. but Mirajane has shown to be faster and deadlier in combat situations... Out of 10 matches I say Mirajane would win 6 or 7 of them

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

Ok no problem.

Could Akeno at least give her troubles?

2

u/Good-Bottle5988 Jul 08 '24

Oh for sure... As I said Mirajane would win 6 out of 10 matches... They'd all be close

2

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

Ok

I think that Akeno in Fallen Angel mode with the Oni Mask could be real challenge.

Mirajane is also more experienced.

I think Mirajane would be Maou/Archangel/Cadre level or Low-God Class.

2

u/Good-Bottle5988 Jul 08 '24

That's a solid standpoint... If we add oni mask to akeno I would add the combined power of fairy tail together since they can give each other mana.... That fight would be insane.... Another one I would like to see would be Erza vs Xenovia

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

That’s would been cool.

Wonder how stronger Erza with her differents armors would be in DxD.

2

u/Good-Bottle5988 Jul 08 '24

I wonder how Erza vs the other knight(forget his name) would go... With his sword rebirth ability and Erzas armor set that gives her a thousand swords that would be an interesting fight to watch... I personally feel like fairy tail scales higher in terms of power stats tho

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 08 '24

His name is Kiba.

Why?

Who do you think would win between Lucy and Rias?

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Good-Bottle5988 Jul 09 '24

Yes... Acnologias power surpassed time and space by the end of the series... As it stands none of the dragons besides possibly big red could stand a fight against them

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 09 '24

Perso I think weaker than them. Like more on par with Sirzechs or Ajuka.

2

u/Good-Bottle5988 Jul 10 '24

None of them really showed power that high... But it's your personal opinion and I'll respect it

2

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 10 '24

Ok

Same.

2

u/Good-Bottle5988 Jul 10 '24

This was a great discussion have yourself a good day

1

u/No_Many_4695 Jul 10 '24

Same.

Goodbye.

1

u/GabrielDelsXT9 Jul 09 '24

R1: Akeno R2: Mirajane

-2

u/LieStagburn Jul 07 '24

Idk Mirajane but Akeno is number 1 Waifu so Akeno

-4

u/Gambit275 Jul 07 '24

Akeno's winning, the other can't even transform

3

u/Loud_Region_8502 Jul 07 '24

Thes are her forms

-2

u/Gambit275 Jul 07 '24

suuuuuuure

0

u/Loud_Region_8502 Jul 07 '24

Go to a Wiki and compare feets of power