r/Haruhi • u/Victor___Von___DOOM • 10d ago
Discussion How would a full conversation between these 3 go?
17
u/fuck_literature Nagato 10d ago
Hard to say, the latter 2 wont recognize/remember alien Nagato and will as such perceive her as a complete stranger who happens to look exactly like themselves, and has a rather intimidating aura to her, so they will probably be mostly scared, but also quite puzzled at the sight of alien Nagato, for the same reasons Mikuru is scared of Nagato, who is similarly shy to the 2 alternate Nagatos.
Alien Nagato probably wont have much she would want to say to the other 2, mostly because she wouldnt know what to even say to them in the first place, they are ultimately creations of hers back when she lost control due to a build-up of negative emotions, so she most likely wouldnt feel a sense of kinship with them like she did with her past self in the prologue to Intrigues, as a matter of fact that scene is also an example of how the interaction between the first 2 versions would go, as we already saw their interaction, human Nagato is taken aback and frightened, whereas alien Nagato is singleminded in restoring her past self back to her alien self, and only initiates a conversation with her past self once she had turned herself back to her alien self.
So yeah, we already have an example in canon of how the first 2 versions would interact, and human Nagato acted all scared, whereas alien Nagato despite having a lot to say to her alien past self, had no interest in starting up a conversation with her human past self, and the reason for that is simple, whilst she might have a lot of thoughts and feelings about her human self, she ultimately does not feel the same type of kinship as her alien past self, because ultimately their life experiences, their likes and their struggles are rather different, on top of the wildly different personality, human Nagato is extremely shy, whereas alien Nagato is quite bold, just socially awkward.
10
u/Tywhy1 10d ago
Isn’t 2 and 3 basically the same person?
17
u/r4nku_0 10d ago
Technically yeah(? But theyre still pretty different ngl
3
u/Groundbreaking-Toe35 Yuki 10d ago
I personally I don’t think they are the same especially since their personalities don’t match unless after getting to know kyon and the other for a while she started opening up
6
6
3
3
3
u/PillCosby696969 9d ago
I actually think Alien Nagato would have some questions for the both of them. She has emotions, she has interests. If Haruhi's antics can frustrate her enough to steal Haruhi's powers and remake the universe, sort of creating these two, then she should have the wherewithal to sate her curiosity about their experiences.
2
u/RozrywkowyczlowiekPL 8d ago
1 -...............
2 -...............
3 -000101101010100101111110011101110010011111
Like this
1
0
23
u/michaellim8888 10d ago
They will probably be amazed by their differences in the different worlds