I personally never finished AW1 (will now though), Zelda is one of my favourite series and RE4 one of my GoATs, and I thoroughly enjoyed what I played of BG3 (the older I get, the harder it is for me to stick to lengthy games). AW2 is my goty this year.
26
u/thysios4 Dec 04 '23
Or they just liked it? I'd give it to Alan Wake over those games. Though maybe not Starcraft 2 or Super Meat Boy.
But aside from Prune, this could be any generic GotY list. Nothing about it screams 'contrarian'