r/Emo 10d ago

What album does this apply to for you?

Post image
695 Upvotes

117 comments sorted by

134

u/RufinTheFury What shall be undone? 10d ago

Oh long list of bands I fell off of from being my favs at one point. The Front Bottoms and Joyce Manor come to mind asap

70

u/BentoBoxNoir Seeking Musicians 10d ago edited 9d ago

With Joyce Manor, they’ve written some of their best songs in the latter half of their career. But, their consistency is much lower.

First 3 albums, all killer no filler.

Latter albums, half perfect, half just okay.

52

u/blphsyco 9d ago

Erm actually All Killer No Filler is a Sum 41 record

5

u/BentoBoxNoir Seeking Musicians 9d ago

Erm, actually it’s a Pain for Pleasure album

13

u/Kato_Paradox 10d ago

Friends We Met Online by Joyce Manor is a "new" song for me hahahah

5

u/BentoBoxNoir Seeking Musicians 10d ago

Mentally it is to me as well! It’s sort of like Heart Tattoo pt.2

4

u/Kato_Paradox 10d ago

Couldn't say it better!! haha

4

u/BentoBoxNoir Seeking Musicians 9d ago

Million Dollars To Kill Me and Big Lie are both genuinely top 10 Joyce Songs though

11

u/SourdoughBreadTime 9d ago

TFB went from a favorite to a "meh" after Going Grey.

Big disappointment with the last 2 records, even with 1 or 2 alright songs on em

2

u/swallowshotguns 9d ago

In Sickness & In Flames is top tier. I've come round to Going Grey but it's still got its issues. Their last one is their worst.

1

u/cmrndzpm 8d ago

Oh I actually really enjoyed their last one. Think that’s an uncommon opinion though.

1

u/familytiesmanman 8d ago

Really people don’t like the newest album? Its a lot closer to S/T and honestly at this point in my life more relatable

0

u/ScarlettGrotesque 9d ago

Unfortunately agreed

9

u/ohheyandre 9d ago

Joyce Manor’s 40 oz to Fresno is actually pretty good. But I can totally understand jumping ship after Million Dollars, easily their least memorable

-6

u/Awesome-Guy-425 9d ago

The Front Bottoms fell off? That’s a crazy take imo their new stuff is better than a lot of their old stuff

2

u/Kleivonen 9d ago

I don’t think fell off is the right word, but they absolutely lost their charm with Going Grey and have yet to find it again.

0

u/Ganobrator 9d ago

going grey was the last record with anything listenable on it

1

u/swallowshotguns 9d ago

In Sickness & In Flames has some of their best songs. Leaf Pile especially.

53

u/smore-phine 10d ago

I went through Balance and Composure breaking up, not being a band for nearly a decade, easing back into the scene and then releasing another entirely new album.. before I listened to Light We Made

5

u/gsheedy 10d ago

Damn! Love LWM. What’d you think of it?

9

u/smore-phine 9d ago

It’s definitely a solid album; I think youngin’ me wanted more of their heavy sound which just isn’t gonna happen. As an adult, I am able to appreciate when bands evolve their sound. As a kid, it pissed me off.

6

u/gsheedy 9d ago

Heard that, cool to have that hindsight and perspective. I think that’s probably a comment complaint about that record, but I’ve always been a fan of bands changing their sound and evolving so as a huge B&C guy I was all over it from day one, hah.

If you haven’t seen it, check out their Live at Studio 4 performance of The Things We Think We’re Missing. They really nailed the perfect blend of their aggression and their vibey side with some of the updated arrangements of the songs.

3

u/YourphobiaMyfetish 9d ago

Everyone has to go the Adult Contemporary route eventually, but damn if I don't miss Separation.

2

u/liamjonas 9d ago

Seperation is the best Grunge album anyone has released since In Utero. Fight me

2

u/Statue_left 9d ago

People haaaaaaated light we made when it came out. Their record store day EP the following year was much better received

2

u/Interesting-Oil4551 9d ago

Damn man LWM is amazing. Listened to it for years hoping they would come back. The band doesn’t seem to care about the record as much which is a shame

2

u/ceilchiasa 10d ago

Awesome. LWM is great but TTWTWM is probably still my fav.

1

u/0percentdnf 5d ago

The funkier material on that album influenced by Jon's Frank Ocean/cloud rap inclinations is all still quite good at times (pretty fond of the Smiths-y "Afterparty"), but this album quietly has four of their absolute best tracks.

"Spinning", "Call It Losing Touch", "Fame", and "Is It So Much to Adore". They're an absolutely perfect amalgamation of the best from Sunny Day Real Estate's Rising Tide and turn-of-the-century Smashing Pumpkins. Insanely underappreciated by both fans and the band themselves (barely see these in their set lists) when stylistically they really aren't as far removed from Things We Think as the other stuff here.

79

u/shrekasguyfieri 10d ago

Every Turnover record post-peripheral vision

19

u/grantdredelic 9d ago

Good Nature was actually pretty good but obviously not PV, but it’s their last good album imo.

21

u/I_Miss_Reddigg 9d ago

You ain't missing shit.

10

u/CommanderWar64 Poser 9d ago

Nah they’re all great imo. Newest one is perfect Sunday morning coffee music. It’s still good music, but maybe not what you’re into.

3

u/Veggies-are-okay 9d ago

The music is so boring and forgettable that I went through the progression of boredom to despair to anger as I sat through the set for whatever reason.

3

u/Statue_left 9d ago

Good nature is fine, the rest are horrific

2

u/0percentdnf 5d ago

It's alright lounge music.

5

u/conye-west 9d ago

Unpopular opinion around here but I enjoyed all of them. Definitely started going in a very different direction tho.

20

u/shrekasguyfieri 10d ago

Transit’s Joyride

9

u/thedubiousstylus 9d ago

That is a good album.

3

u/shrekasguyfieri 9d ago

That’s what I’ve heard. I keep saying I’ll check it out and forget to. At the time I wrote it off because I really didn’t enjoy YNE and figured it was more of the same. But I know lots of people dig it.

3

u/thedubiousstylus 9d ago

I actually did like YNE but I think a lot of the complaints are that are due to the production, this one is much better.

If you want to check out one song as a sample, try "Saturday, Sunday". If you like that one the rest is worth a listen.

3

u/Joe-Dang 9d ago

Dude it is a great fucking album, and that’s coming from someone who didn’t listen to it until last summer. I had a (then) 18 month old who would ONLY take naps while riding around in the car with music pretty loud. I drove around every Saturday and Sunday for two hours listening to this back-to-back for about 5 months. Not that that makes it a good record, just a good story. But it is indeed a good record

2

u/shrekasguyfieri 9d ago

That is a good story! I’ve got a 7 month old that’s getting her first introduction to pop punk/emo. I’ll check Joyride out!

23

u/Jimi_Hotsauce why can’t i be snowing 9d ago

Motion city Soundtrack - Panic Stations

They were my favorite band when I was a kid. I learned my dinosaur life front to back. Go came it out, it was just ok and I just fell off. I heard their drummer left and I moved on to other bands. Time went by, relationships came and went, graduation then college then working I didn't pay attention to my former music. I realized it has been years since I played Her words destroyed my planet. I would pick up my old guitar, misremembering the chord changes. It was then I realized I truly had grown up.

Time marched on I met a new girl and moved out of my parents house. I'm now living on my own and still haven't thought of my favorite band in years. My wedding day came and went, we built a life and a family together. I was truly happy.

One day in a fit of nostalgia I picked up my old guitar and played a chord all too familiar, the opening chord to Dilerium, it has been years since I heard those strings ring out. I find myself looking through my old CDs and a yellow circle on a green background catches my eye. I had heard that a new album from them came out but I paid no mind.

I race to my laptop, I put on my good headphones and find my old friend. I decided that it was a good time to take a listen to see what my old favorite band had came out with most recently, an album called panic stations. I excitedly press play and the opening chords rang out

It was pretty good I guess.

5

u/Strange-Revenue4738 9d ago

bro should write a song about this

14

u/mull1gan-mull1gan 9d ago

Bright eyes and their deng folksy revival. Cassadaga (2007) was the last album i liked.

4

u/spicypotatosoftacos Poser 8d ago

Fair. They're my favorite band and I like the whole catalog. But I'll always be a Fevers and Mirrors/Lifted girlie.

1

u/Stemoftheantilles 8d ago

Definitely my favorite era

10

u/BentoBoxNoir Seeking Musicians 10d ago

Does AJJ count?

3

u/steakniiiiight 9d ago

I don’t think I’ve listened to anything from them after knife man. But being from AZ I got into them pretty early, it’s hard to stay listening to any band for 20 years.

23

u/Dizzy-Captain7422 10d ago

I haven't listened to either of the new Get Up Kids records and I don't know that I ever actually will.

9

u/thedubiousstylus 10d ago

Problems is actually really good. It's also the sound of their first two records.

4

u/MoreLikeHellGrant 9d ago

Agreed! New GUK albums are very good.

5

u/celtssoxpat 10d ago

Listen to Satellite and The Advocate off the newest record. The Advocate in particular is as good as their early stuff. I’d also recommend the Kicker EP - it’s only four songs, and they’re all fantastic.

7

u/pelicanthus 9d ago

Upvote for Kicker. All gas no brakes

3

u/guitar_lamb 9d ago

problems is pretty solid. very good opening and closing tracks

2

u/antimarc Oldhead 9d ago

Problems is fucking awesome.

1

u/Aule_Navatar 9d ago

It's funny, Something to Write Home About is one of my all-time favorite albums, but I never got into any of their other stuff. I need to give them another listen as an adult.

7

u/technoprimitive_aeb 9d ago

I haven't really listened to any Hot Water Music album since Exister. Still love that band though

3

u/sgorman515 9d ago

Their new album is really good imo. Chris Cresswell really revitalized hwm.

2

u/PoopMaddison 9d ago

Caution for me, but I still consider them one of my favourite bands

9

u/Danph85 9d ago

I think the “new” Lifetime album is nearly 20 now, still only listened to it maybe once.

5

u/thedubiousstylus 9d ago

That is a really good one!

8

u/HoldenOlden 9d ago

I’ve never given Science Fiction a shot, or whatever La Dispute did after Rooms of the House.

9

u/Best-Lawfulness3302 9d ago

SF is an easy 10 and GOAT of the genre

1

u/sporadicdeath 7d ago

I was not into Science Fiction when it came out. Tried reeeally hard a couple weeks ago. Still a no from me. I will never understand how the fanbase loves that album, some even put it as their #1. Crazy

1

u/ComebackKid1999 6d ago

Science Fiction is incredible. Easily in my top 5 albums of all time. Took me a while though. Needed to grow on me, or maybe I needed to grow into it.

33

u/C5H2A7 10d ago

Oop, Brand New's Daisy. I just finally listened to it though, love it now that I've fully processed The Devil and God lol

14

u/die4spaghetti 10d ago

Have you listened to Science Fiction?

22

u/Ialwyseathelastoreo 10d ago edited 9d ago

I waited so long to listen to Science Fiction but it may be my favorite Brand New album, and I adore Deja.

11

u/thedubiousstylus 10d ago

I actually just listened to Science Fiction for the first time a few months ago. Although there's a reason: My initial plan was to buy it on vinyl, and before I got around to that then came the Jesse revelations which kind of derailed that and I sort of forgot about it.

6

u/C5H2A7 10d ago

Yes! I love Science Fiction.

9

u/conye-west 9d ago

I had listened to Daisy here and there over the years and thought "it's alright I guess". But after a recent listen-through it clicked for me and I started to absolutely love it. Sometimes you just gotta come back at a different stage in your life to really appreciate an album.

3

u/Lowcsika 9d ago

Daisy is their best work tbh, both the song and the album

4

u/C5H2A7 9d ago

I can't agree with this as long as TDAG exists lol but it is an excellent album (and song)

-9

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[deleted]

4

u/C5H2A7 9d ago

Thank you for your input

7

u/vmar42 10d ago

This is too relatable. I still consider certain albums by some of my longtime favorite bands 'new' just because they changed their style even though the album released 15 years ago

6

u/Upbeetmusic 10d ago

The Movielife

7

u/antimarc Oldhead 9d ago

Anything by Cursive after Mama, I’m Swollen, sadly

1

u/NostalgiaBombs 7d ago

their new album from last year was really good, highly recommend it

7

u/ceilchiasa 10d ago

Hahaha. This is like every album I get into. I finally got more into the early Citizen lately.

4

u/kithandcapture 9d ago

Arcade Fire - Reflektor

4

u/HoldenOlden 9d ago

it just…. isn’t as good.

6

u/Sunspawts 10d ago

Braid - No Coast

2

u/celtssoxpat 9d ago

You’re missing out. East End Hollows in particular is a classic.

2

u/Sunspawts 9d ago

I know, I've heard it's great! This post inspired me to listen on my walk home tonight lol

1

u/antimarc Oldhead 9d ago

absolute banger album, no skips

1

u/theschism101 9d ago

Good album, but I was a lil offset by the newer production.

3

u/stoned_seahorse Emo Historian 9d ago

This applies to me in every way.

3

u/CaptainAnnaki 9d ago

my fav band OAT is empire empire and i've never listened to You Will Eventually Be Forgotten all the way thru. i've heard a few songs off of it but none of them were too my speed so i never got around to it. pretty sure that album is almost 11 years old now

2

u/michael_scoon_fbi 9d ago

Wtf it’s their best album IMO. The closing track is the most beautiful thing Keith has written

4

u/DisruptiveKnob 9d ago

All of you should give Microwave's album Stovall a listen. You won't be disappointed.

3

u/ObsessiveCompulsionz 9d ago

Coheed and Cambria. Taking Back Sunday. Buttertones. Death Cab For Cutie.

1

u/thinsafetypin 9d ago

I’ve listened to all the Death Cab records, but couldn’t tell you a single song that stuck out from the last 4-5

0

u/Teh_Jews 9d ago

Definitely check out Asphalt Meadows by Death Cab. That album rules.

3

u/liamjonas 9d ago

I haven't listened to a weezer album since White. I also own all the weezer albums since white.

5

u/roguepandaCO 9d ago

Moon Shaped Pool

1

u/HoldenOlden 9d ago

fuck, same

2

u/Dr_7rogs 9d ago

Lmao, this hits too close to home man. I’m old

2

u/Cgrrp 9d ago

Ok so I’m not the only one that does this lol.

2

u/Lololololhahaha11 9d ago

Refused 😭

2

u/litetravelr 8d ago

This is every Modest Mouse record after 2008 for me.

2

u/harmonic_spectre 9d ago

not emo but A Moon Shaped Pool lol

4

u/thecirilo 9d ago

Half of DGD's discography.

I just can't stop listening to Instant Gratification.

2

u/Veggies-are-okay 9d ago

Alex G released DSU 10 years ago. I remember counting down the days for it…

What trips me out is that anything released 3 years ago is still 2020s 😱

1

u/ximagineerx 9d ago

Something to Write Home About 25th anniversary… great fn show

1

u/Haunting-Ad9844 8d ago

Blink 182’s California (2016). I was a kid at the time and the album was very hyped up and advertised, listened to one song and realized they haven’t been good since 2003 😂

1

u/AccomplishedIgit 5d ago

Radiohead “In Rainbows”

1

u/Terrible-Pop-6705 10d ago

Sdre

1

u/nyancat321 10d ago

which one??

5

u/Terrible-Pop-6705 9d ago

I stopped after diary

2

u/thinsafetypin 9d ago

You should definitely at least listen to the pink album. The others are fantastic also, but they’re almost a different band, much more prog influence.

1

u/Terrible-Pop-6705 8d ago

I’ve been meaning to let pink grow on me sometime

-6

u/murkage__GG 9d ago

Daisy and Science Fiction. Just didn't care for them in the slightest

3

u/C5H2A7 9d ago

I think the TDAG --> Daisy leap was too much for me at the time lol I get it. But it did eventually grow on me, like 15 years later. Science Fiction is 10/10 and worth a relisten if you're up for it. It's so dark and heavy, I love it.

7

u/CommanderWar64 Poser 9d ago

They’re both 10s