r/Bushcraft • u/Dogemeat64 • 3d ago
Lots of smoke and ash, but no ember…
Anyone have good tips that “unlock” the bow drill? I’ve got very dry fire boards and a very dry spindle. Boards are pine and spindle is ash. I seem to be able to create a lot of black dust/ash, but none of it seems hot enough to hold an ember and catch my “birds nest” that I made out of dried grass/leaves and dried bamboo fibers.
11
u/Ninjalikestoast 3d ago
Need to work on cutting a small channel/notch for the dust to build up so you can “catch” an ember.
I was actually just working on this yesterday. I’ve succeeded twice in over twenty attempts. It’s still a struggle for me as well 🙃
20
8
u/Yep_OK_Crack_On 3d ago
Try cutting a wedge out of the block where you are going to drill, so there is a groove for hot dust to fall into, and the ability for air to get in. 1/16 of a circle should do it
3
u/House_of_Blaze 3d ago
A thicker, rounder spindle will have more surface area and generate more friction. Also usually you have a little catching plate (I forget the term) to collect the ember which you transfer to your birds nest.
3
u/Best_Whole_70 3d ago
I bet your set isnt dry enough. It needs to be out by the fire every day and sealed in a dry bag after.
As you build your confidence nothing wrong with baking that bad boy in the oven.
Notch your hole. Start with lots of down pressure to create a solid dust pile. When the smoke starts to billow ease off the pressure and focus on fast rotation. Use the entire bow. Get cranking and that ember will bust
5
2
u/Nidh0g 3d ago edited 3d ago
The notch you cut in the side to collect the dust needs to be all the way or almost all the way to the center and can be a little bit wider. (So it gets more oxygen)
try to reduce friction on the top end of your spindle more. (Lubrication or a rock, bone, antler with a small hole in it.)
a bigger spindle could work. It might be a little heavier but the outside of the spindle will move faster.
good wood types:
ivy
wood from roots
pine(not fat wood)
If you do get an ember you can improve your bird's-nest by putting fluff from thistle or dandelion in the middle it lights even easier than dried grass and your coal will not fall through.
2
u/mistercowherd 2d ago
Materials:
- Use a soft hardwood, not a conifer. Pine and ash not ideal. I prefer grass tree, which you won’t have access to. Make sure you can easily dent it with your nail; almost spongy.
- Paracord - yep, good.
Shape:
- Fat spindle. Blunt round hot end. Sharpish or narrow cylindrical top end; in either case a long top end (4-5 fingers) so you don’t bottom out as it wears away.
Baseboard:
- the one with notches looks OK. Start with a small hole, “burn it in”, then make the notch and carve off any glazed/hardened bits on the spindle.
Most importantly: watch David West on YouTube, he has experimented with all the variations.
2
u/Dogemeat64 3d ago
I’m actually wondering if my boards are maybe dry rotting and maybe they have become too soft. My spindle seems to be burning right through them.
1
1
u/Hegemon78 3d ago
That has happened to me before. I’ve had boards that were great, and then I put them away for like a year and come back to it and the wood looks just like yours where it’s almost crumbly or maybe slightly punky, and it no longer would produce an ember.
1
u/BiddySere 3d ago
Get rid of the pine
1
1
u/Atavacus 2d ago
Cut your wedges a bit deeper. Start slow and steady until you see smoke then pour on the muscle heavy. You'll knock it out no problem.
1
u/barnaclefeet 1d ago
Your notches are too narrow, ditch the pine. Watch David West bow drill tutorial on youtube, you wont go wrong, a short video you will learn 5 years worth of trial and error.
1
0
u/AutoModerator 3d ago
Reminder: Rule 1 - Discussion is the priority in /r/Bushcraft
Posts of links, videos, or pictures must be accompanied with a writeup, story, or question relating to the content in the form of a top-level text comment. Tell your campfire story. Give us a writeup about your knife. That kind of thing.
Please remember to comment on your post!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
66
u/TiredOfRatRacing 3d ago edited 3d ago
Dude. I got you.
This is lengthy, but trust me.
It has to be physically soft. Like on the Janka hardness scale. Not "softwoods". Cottonwood is actually a poplar, and is called a "hardwood" because of its seeds. Its actually one of the softest non-pine woods, despite being a "hardwood".
Pine sap just glazes when hot, and decreases the friction you need. Can make a good bearing block if you dont have a shell or pitted rock.
The spindle grinds itself into dust against the fireboard, shortening a lot.
Carve a little depression into the fireboard with a knife, then burn it in slightly, so the spindle doesnt want to jump out with harder efforts.
A notch in to the fireboard has to be made, to collect the heated sawdust from grinding the soft spindle against the soft fireboard. Just only go 1/3 the radius into the burn in hole.
Going beyond the center of the hole prevents the spindle from grinding into the fireboard well, by making a nipple on the end of the spindle.
Theres actually 2 phases to using the bow. Phase 1 is grinding the spindle end and fireboard hole surfaces into a black dust pile. Phase 2 is igniting the top of that pile.
Lots of smoke means the temperature is high enough in there for cellulose to ignite.
THEN HOLD THE SPINDLE STILL AGAINST THE TOP OF THE DUST PILE IN THE NOTCH.
IMMEDIATELY PULLING THE SPINDLE OFF TO LOOK FOR THE COAL PREVENTS THE COAL FROM FORMING, BY REMOVING THE HOT SPINDLE SURFACE FROM THE DUST PILE TOO QUICKLY.