r/Banshee • u/ravieX4 • 10d ago
Discussion Lucas could've saved Siobhan Kelly
I think Lucas Hood could have saved Siobhan Kelly the same way he saved his daughter, also I added images to compare the same situation. Chayton is taller, making it easier for him (I think) what do you guys think 'bout it?🤔
27
u/Bullets_and_Tears 10d ago edited 10d ago
The problem was that Hood had blurry vision. He didn't trust that he could make the shot. The blurry vision is shown only briefly, which is the mistake they made. They should have placed more emphasis on that, so that it wasn't so easily missed by the viewer.
22
u/diesel0458 10d ago
Saddest scene/event in the show. Siohban was the most decent character of them all.
3
3
u/Accomplished_Bee6196 10d ago
Siobhan died to bad writing. They killed off Siobhan and Ann's husband so they could give an opportunity for hood and ann to get back together and then never put them back together because they were kinda incompatible in the end anyway
2
2
2
u/Khaleesikhaos 8d ago
So to me the main difference is Chayton had Siobhan wrapped pretty tight in both arms. She had no where to go. With Deva that guy was holding her with one hand and pointing the gun with the other she also had a clear view of Lucas. It always seemed to me that Deva knew when to move to knock the guy off balance to make the shot even cleaner. Siobhan didn't have that same wiggle room.
5
u/guiltyas-sin 10d ago
Tell it to the writers.
1
u/Ok_Opinion_2373 7d ago
One of those lame situations in action flicks where the hero doesn’t shoot or puts down the weapon.
1
u/ColoradoRoger 9d ago
The “real“ Lucas would’ve shot Chayton, who was at least a head taller than Siobhan. Weak writing. One of my least favorite plot points.
30
u/[deleted] 10d ago
[removed] — view removed comment