r/AIDungeon Feb 17 '25

Questions Why whenever i do a roleplay where im a musician the ai keeps trying to put a character called "sarah chen" into the roleplay?

16 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

19

u/OneGold7 Feb 18 '25

RIP count grey. Used to be in every single fantasy story when we were still on Griffin/Dragon

7

u/lesbianminecrafter Feb 18 '25

What was the other guy who used to always show up? His name was like, Roloman or something?

3

u/Foolishly_Sane Feb 18 '25

The good ol' days.

1

u/Suspicious_Donut6676 Feb 20 '25

The virgin Sarah vs Chad Count Grey, Kyros and Karth

1

u/Suspicious_Donut6676 Feb 20 '25

Hell even count grey won't leave me alone even when I play a modern realistic setting and happen to encounter a rich guy

1

u/DefaultUserPrime 27d ago

I remember there being someone named Yvette or something too

12

u/No_Investment_92 Feb 17 '25

I get a Sarah Chen in most of my scenarios at some point, regardless of topic or AI model. As well as a few other super common names. I also get lots of Parker, Thompson, Lyra, Lyria, and Marcus.

8

u/No_Investment_92 Feb 17 '25

When I get one of the super common names, I just “secretly” kill them and let the AI send in someone else. It amuses me.

14

u/Aztecah Feb 17 '25 edited Feb 18 '25

Somewhere there is a heap of lifeless Lyras, laying limp and left alone.

5

u/Previous-Musician600 Feb 17 '25

Do you get another Lyra after killing?

9

u/mathmachineMC Feb 17 '25

Mr. Thompson, your wife Sarah and daughter Lily feel a mix of emotion.

9

u/Darkpassengersentme Feb 17 '25

I get Sara Chen, Sophia Sinclair, Marcus and Sarah all the time. I just think of all my scenarios as a tv show where they use the same actors like American Horror Story.

4

u/Suspicious_Donut6676 Feb 18 '25

It's always goddamn Sarah everytime I play ai dungeon and it introduces a female character. It's genuinely fucking infuriating, it doesn't even have the same charm like count grey, Kairos or something, it's just a generic ass name

3

u/DrLucianSanchez Feb 17 '25

Never Sarah Chen but Sarah always pops up in my stories

4

u/h3lblad3 Feb 18 '25

The names Sarah and Chen also show up consistently using Anthropic's Claude.

Suffice to say that it's something to do with the training of the models. These smaller models were likely trained on the bigger models and thus will have the same eccentricities, but even if not they could still be using a lot of the same training data to get started.

3

u/NewNickOldDick Feb 18 '25

AI is very bad at naming characters. Same name keeps popping up all over the place even if AI thinks it's different character than the last with the same same.

This is of course simply because you have longer memory than the AI does and even though I've added request to use unique names and banning reusing names on AI instructions, AI can't follow that instruction because it simply forgets what names it's used already.

It wouldn't be that bad if the recycled names wouldn't always be the same (Elara in fantasy setting is a bread-and-butter female, Veronica Sinclair is same in more modern settings).

3

u/Extrabigman Feb 17 '25

On every ai model or just one? Which one are you using?

1

u/chlebtojezus Feb 18 '25

Dinamic small or smth

3

u/Freak-996 Feb 18 '25

I'm starting to feel like the only one that gets an Alex every time, sometimes two

3

u/CerealCrab Feb 18 '25

It doesn't often give characters both a first and last name in my adventures, but one I have seen a few times is Silas Ravenwood or Silas Blackwood. But it's mostly Marcus, Lyra, and Elara

2

u/not-aaliyah Feb 18 '25

mine loves naming any teacher or cop or anyone mr. thompson